News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by bediger4000 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @09:53AM (#43601435)
The systems you describe exist. An interesting story would investigate why the systems weren't used in the Goldberg situation.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by 9283409232 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:03AM (#43601488)
I think the easy answer is that current systems are subject to FOIA and they are doing their best to avoid FOIA because whatever they are doing is very illegal.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by mcculley on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:13AM (#43601544)
It would not have to be illegal, much less very illegal for them to want to keep their discussions away from public scrutiny. It is unacceptable even for mundane official discussions.

I have often observed government officials carrying two phones and using both of them in the same meeting.

Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by 9283409232 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:45AM (#43602289)
> I have often observed government officials carrying two phones and using both of them in the same meeting.

I have two phones. One for work and my personal phone. What's your point?

Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by mcculley on Sunday April 06, 2025 @01:01PM (#43602941)
When working, one should primarily be on only one of those devices. I have observed government officials using both concurrently to escape some conversations being subpoenaed.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by nsagent on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:09AM (#43601523)
I'm completely unfamiliar with what systems exist, but here's what the article states:

> the White House had authorized the use of Signal, largely because there is no alternative platform to text in real time across different agencies, two people familiar with the matter said.

> Previous administrations, including the Biden White House, did not develop an alternative platform to Signal, one of the people said.

Are you saying these sources are dissembling? Wouldn't surprise me at this point, but just making sure I understand what you're saying.

Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by the_snooze on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:15AM (#43601556)
The systems exist are in the form of "you go into a secure room with specially-networked computers and do your sensitive comms there." These are secure not only because of the use of strong encryption (which Signal does) but also because of the restricted access (which Signal doesn't). You can't accidentally add a journalist on these secure systems for the simple reason that the US government doesn't give accounts or physical access to randos (which Signal effectively does).
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by OneDeuxTriSeiGo on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:16AM (#43602037)
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by nsagent on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:58AM (#43602417)
Thanks for clarifying! Certainly seems like dissembling to me. Wish news organizations actually did the due diligence and reported these kinds of details.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by edgineer on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:25AM (#43602106)
This sell sheet describes a phone capable of and approved for TS voice calls and data hotspot, but does not advertise text messaging.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by OneDeuxTriSeiGo on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:36AM (#43602195)
While the sheet doesn't mention it, the Cellcrypt app is a fully functioned encrypted text messaging app.

https://www.cellcrypt.com/cellcrypt-federal

Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by lukan on Sunday April 06, 2025 @05:38PM (#43605172)
With post quantum protection. Amazing.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by simplicio on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:47AM (#43601792)
I mean, if the devices exist, I'm skeptical its that hard to just give them to whomever you want to use them and give them all DoD accounts or whatever. The people involved being in different agencies seems like a dodge.
Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by est on Sunday April 06, 2025 @10:52AM (#43601828)
As described near the end of the article

> White House had authorized the use of Signal, largely because there is no alternative platform to text in real time across different agencies, two people familiar with the matter said.

Re:How the Atlantic's Jeffrey Goldberg Got Added to the Whit... by apical_dendrite on Sunday April 06, 2025 @11:01AM (#43601899)
All of these guys have SCIFs at their homes and offices, and if they're traveling they have access to a SCIF. They can absolutely get secure messages across agencies in real time - Waltz even says this in the group chat when he tells them to check their "high side inboxes". They just can't get them as texts to their personal phones - for very good reason. It's a more inconvenient system by design.

What these guys are arguing is that there's a case for using Signal for something like what Waltz was initially doing - telling people to check a more secure system and asking them to name a point person. But of course the risk is that a) even that information is extremely useful to an adversary; b) once the more convenient system exists, you're relying on people to carefully adhere to the rules about what should go on it, and guys like Hegseth are morons who don't feel like they need to follow the rules.