News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by fleitz on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:08PM (#4357042)
This is what I love about linux on the desktop, on one thread we've got serious complaints about usability, on another thread we're switching window managers because it won't fit on a CD.

A CD? In 2012? Windows and OS X haven't fit on a CD in almost 10 years and you can barely find a copy of OS X on DVD. Yet the primary concern on linux is not usability but whether it fits on an install CD.

I think there might be higher priority concerns than whether a user is able to install a modern operating system on the Pentium MMX & 8X CD drive they found in the dumpster.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by powerslave12r on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:11PM (#4357067)
Your point is understandable, but distribution restricted to the size of a CD is a major feature.

It fits right in with the linux way of supporting really old hardware. It's not about the newest and shiniest hardware. Debian is known to be a slow moving but very stable distribution. Support for older hardware (without DVD Reader/Writers) might have been a big point of consideration.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by fleitz on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:16PM (#4357097)
People like you and me will have no problem creating a custom install CD that defaults to XFCE to run on our really old hardware.

Normal people will download a debian CD and get XFCE and think that's linux on the desktop.

What I don't understand is why linux always optimizes for the corner case of a couple ultra cheap geeks who can't stand the idea of upgrading their 300 mhz celeron.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by powerslave12r on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:24PM (#4357156)
Valid point about the option of a slim xfce-based install being available.

I disagree about the 'normal people' point. 'Normal people' are less likely to download Debian as opposed to Mint or Ubuntu. If they venture into Debian territory, they're looking for something more and know what they're doing.

Which leads me to your third point, that is, I would venture a guess that the number of people who would care about this might not be in the minority after all. (Disclaimer: I have made assumptions about the numbers, if someone has nice numbers to refute/support this argument, please do the honors.)

Also, 'ultra cheap geeks' are usually puppets controlled by the management.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by Adam503 on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @10:13PM (#4359173)
Most of the Open Source/Free Software is far more concerned that new Linux releases can install with no problems in a used computer some low-income person volunteers to help rebuild someplace like Free Geek...

"The Adoption Program

Free Geek receives donated used computers from the public and Build volunteers refurbish them with care. These computers are then “adopted out” to volunteers in exchange for 24 hours of volunteerism to our Adoption volunteers.

Volunteers in the Adoption Program

    disassemble computers for recycling
    help receive computer equipment from donors
    test basic computer components
    help keep our facility clean
Volunteer tasks in the Adoption Program can accommodate a wide range of abilities — we’ll work with you to make sure you can spend the time necessary to earn your computer. No computer experience is required to participate in the program.

Adoption volunteers disassembling computers When you complete your 24 hours of volunteer service, you’ll sign up for a basic class on how to use your computer. At the conclusion of the class, you’ll take your new-to-you computer home. Adoption volunteers must take the class in order to receive tech support. You can learn more about What You Get with your adopted computer.

It the Adoption Program sounds perfect for you, here’s how you can Get Started.

Volunteers can receive one computer per year.

http://www.freegeek.org/volunteer/adoption-program/

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by cdavid on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:57PM (#4357383)
Linux is used a lot in countries where buying the last and greatest is not an option, nor is fast internet connection.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by einhverfr on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @09:37PM (#4359069)
Agreed with this. I do like being able to install without downloading more than 700MB in software. Saying download the DVD is very annoying, esp when you have a less than perfectly reliable internet connection.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by shanemhansen on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @08:22PM (#4358849)
My understanding was that even in those cases, most people just pirate windows xp. I am not even close to a windows lover, but have you seen the system requirements for windows xp? http://support.microsoft.com/kb/314865

Basically a 233MGhz processor and 64mb of ram will get you a usable windows xp installation.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by vacri on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @09:47PM (#4359105)
"usable"? No. Those specs are simply wrong.

But even then, you're showing incredible hubris by saying "screw those guys, let them pirate XP". Debian's strength is that it tries to be universal - platforms and languages.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by einhverfr on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @09:37PM (#4359070)
So is that a reason not to try to compete?
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by DanBC on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @11:36PM (#4359403)
Why should those computers[1] go to landfill when they're perfectly capable of doing whatever is needed by the owners? Especially if the "extra functionality" that needs all that power is, well, what?

There are continents where Internet speeds are not great (or are expensive) - some of those are first world countries too. (EG Australia).

Many people don't care if they can bash the arrow keys on a Google Doodle. They just want to send a bit of email and do a bit of gentle web browsing; maybe a bit of light office work and some pdf reading.

WordStar and WordPerfect sold a gajillion copies and are fondly remembered by many. Abiword would cover the needs for 90% of its users.

[1] and all the copper; lead; rare earth heavy metals; aluminum; plastics; gold; etc etc.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by rdtsc on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @05:06PM (#4358079)
> Normal people will download a debian CD and get XFCE and think that's linux on the desktop.

Would "normal" people download Debian CDs though? I wonder if this change will pass unnoticed precisely because it is only people like "you and me" that will be interested in Debian.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by gareim on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:41PM (#4357275)
Exactly this. People that really care about optimizations aren't going to install the default Debian install anyways. They'd do a net install and build from there to get max performance for their old computers.

And I love that about Linux. I absolutely love how minimal you can get it (CrunchBang for me is the right mix). But it's time to focus on user experience if we ever want Linux adoption to spread. And that means we have to stop optimizing for computers that came out 10 years ago.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by vacri on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @09:52PM (#4359120)
Debian supports a huge number of architectures, not just the 386 that comes in most desktop computers. Not all modern computing devices have the power of Intel Core 2 processors.

The other thing is, if people want a sweet enduser experience, they're not going to install the default Debian install anyways. They'll use an enduser-focused distro like Ubuntu.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by brdrak on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @03:19PM (#4357497)
> People that really care about optimizations aren't going to install the default Debian install anyways. They'd do a net install and build from there to get max performance for their old computers.

I recently installed Debian on a Dell server with Broadcom network adapters. Couldn't use the netinstall image because by default Debian doesn't include non-free firmware. It was nice to be able to use CD1 to get a fully functional headless Debian system, to then install the non-free firmware package from a USB flash drive to get network connectivity.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by petemc_ on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @03:56PM (#4357712)
Images with firmware included are available from http://cdimage.debian.org/cdimage/unofficial/non-free/cd-inc...
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by brdrak on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:25PM (#4357878)
Thanks!
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by jonathansizz on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @11:24PM (#4359374)
No, normal people aren't even aware of the existence of Linux. That's primarily where GNOME (and Unity) have gone so badly wrong: optimizing for an audience that doesn't exist.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by lloeki on Thursday August 09, 2012 @04:27AM (#4360135)
Many people aren't, yet these days I'm regularly surprised by random folks (some bordering ludditeness) knowing about Linux's existence and role.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by fusiongyro on Thursday August 09, 2012 @12:06AM (#4359458)
IMO, it's because optimizing for the 300 MHz Celeron is a concrete technical objective. Optimizing for usability and design takes you right back into the subjective territory most of us are uncomfortable with. You've seen the fighting over Ubuntu's Unity. "Will this fit on a CD?" is a question that can be answered with facts.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by einhverfr on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @09:34PM (#4359059)
I doubt the Debian downloaders are the sort that will think that's Linux on the desktop. Debian is a great distro but their specific download target is, shall we say, somewhat more exclusive than others, such as Fedora or Ubuntu.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by xentronium on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @10:48PM (#4359280)
"Normal people" don't use linux, so I don't buy your argument, sorry. I'd rather linux distributions stopped optimizing for idiots who can't tell what's going on without huge icons.

That said, I don't see how xfce is worse than gnome in its current state, so it's entirely win-win situation imho.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by djeikyb on Thursday August 09, 2012 @04:25AM (#4360129)
A number of normal people I know use linux. The scenario is usually: 1) Computer "breaks", ie needs os reinstall 2) they don't have os media 3) I offer a choice of buying a full copy of Windows or trying linux for free. Some that choose linux find it isn't for them. Some stick with linux.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by icebraining on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @07:56PM (#4358745)
Normal people will download a debian CD

No, they won't. Most normal people are not even capable of burning an ISO, let alone selecting ("so, do I use i386 or MIPS?") and downloading Debian.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by smegel on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @11:15PM (#4359352)
"but distribution restricted to the size of a CD is a major feature"

For me a major feature would be VirtualBox images ready to go. I haven't installed a Linux distro in years, and I would much rather let Windows/OSX act as the HAL so I just just focus on what I want to use Linux for.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by hammersend on Thursday August 09, 2012 @12:26AM (#4359509)
The best experience for me is the other way around. Linux does 99 percent of everything I want and lives on the bare metal and if I need some random Windows app I just thaw out one of my VMs until I'm done with it then it goes back into the freezer.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by onli on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:17PM (#4357838)
It's not given that xfce is necessarily a bad choice. That seems to have played into it, regarding to the comment.

Personally, I would say it is the most natural choice for Debian. Also, staying away from DEs regarded as developer-unfriendly like gnome3 or unity fits (remember the eclipse-bug?).

Furthermore, developers I know seem to not like medias like dvds, switching instead to the internet where possible, so they are quiet likely not to buy something fancy like a dvd-burner. Or maybe that's just me.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by rijoja on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:40PM (#4357944)
I agree that xfce is a natural choice for Debian. I suppose that most computers have DVD players, but DVD discs are more expensive than CDs. Even if the difference is rather small it feels unnecessary to waste a DVD when I CD could do the trick. Especially since you only use the installation disc a few times. Having a physical disc has a advantage over USB drives namely that it can be used as a rescue disc later on. Data on a USB drive tends to be overwritten and you might not always have another computer available.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by jlgreco on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @07:40PM (#4358694)
Frankly they are likely resolving more usability complaints by switching to XFCE than they are generating.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by rwmj on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @04:01PM (#4357738)
Fedora have a bunch of people giving out CDs throughout the developing world, and according to the discussions that flare up periodically on the Fedora devel list when this topic comes up, the CD size is useful for them. It's more to do with the time taken to download the CD when you have really poor network backwidth, rather than availability of CD/DVD drives. Which makes sense because Fedora almost certainly doesn't run on CD-only era PCs.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by scottjad on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @11:30PM (#4359391)
A CD? In 2012? Windows and OS X haven't fit on a CD in almost 10 years and you can barely find a copy of OS X on DVD.

Most (legal) Windows and OS X users aren't downloading and installing the OS from cd/usb/dvd. Most Debian users are. Restricting size decreases download time and decreases the difficulty of finding installation medium with sufficient space.

Also, since it's more work to install additional packages on non-apt-based OSes the benefit to installing initially is greater.

Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by vacri on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @10:07PM (#4359161)
I imagine that "it won't fit on a CD" is an easier argument to win than "gnome has lost its way and is no longer suitable to be the default on a Debian system".
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by bnegreve on Thursday August 09, 2012 @04:52AM (#4360201)
I agree. Most users are not interested in understanding/testing the new UI concepts introduced in Gnome 3. It cannot be "the default wm" anymore. This is a very diplomatic way to say it.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by graue on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @03:36PM (#4357592)
On the other hand, if you're NOT installing from a single CD (which, by your hypothesis, most people aren't), then it really makes no difference what's the default desktop on Debian. It's easy to install whatever you want.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by SkyMarshal on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @06:18PM (#4358400)
First world folks tend to forget there's an entire developing world out there, that is still going from 0 to 1 instead of 1 to 100.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by pippy on Thursday August 09, 2012 @12:04AM (#4359456)
Usability and filesize aren't correlated. Perhaps with some attention from Debian Xfce can fix some of it's usability issues.
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by romaniv on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @05:45PM (#4358256)
What usability issues were introduced by using XFCE?
Re:Debian Now Defaults To Xfce Desktop by est on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @08:44PM (#4358918)
yeah, warez still distributes zip volumes in floppy disk size.