Re:Marine Le Pen banned from running in 2027 and given four-...
by hollerith on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @12:05PM
(#43548428)
You seem to have failed to see the thorniness of the problem maybe because in the current instance (Le Pen's ban by the French judiciary) you agree with the outcome.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Marine Le Pen banned from running in 2027 and given four-...
by woopsn on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @02:38PM
(#43550080)
Probably impossible to separate Le Pen's disqualification from the situation in the U.S. It's the song of the day. I seem to recall some account arguing in 2020, nominally on their expertise as a lawyer, that the election result could not be determined except in the courtroom. If you asked in 2020, should lawyers be disgraced if not disbarred for attempting to nullify the election - answer from GOP would be no. When asked today, suddenly answer is yes.
Re:Marine Le Pen banned from running in 2027 and given four-...
by surgical_fire on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @04:12PM
(#43550857)
I agree only in the sense that K think that politicians should be punished for their wrongs.
I would only see thorniness is the courts refused to punish Le Pen out of fear of punishing a somewhat popular politician, as this would embolden others to act in ways to break the rules, and would undermine the independence of the court, which is a core tenet of a functioning democracy.
I think you only see thorniness here because you wanted Le Pen to keep doing her thing. See? it works both ways.