Re:Samsung internal doc: 125 iphone pic competitive analysis
by Blara on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @07:44AM
(#4355023)
But she didn't say: "Look a new iPhone" so in other words she saw that it was in fact not an iPhone?
Re:Samsung internal doc: 125 iphone pic competitive analysis
by sbuk on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @07:54AM
(#4355051)
That's not the point. That people need to do a double take to realise the thing wasn't an iPhone is bad enough IMHO. Samsung look to have gone out of their way to actively make the Galaxy S look similar enough to the iPhone that there is confusion. I cannot accept that the near facsimile is through "inspiration" or is coincidental. This document, contrary to what other posters have said, does not resemble a market product analysis. It's an evaluation of what they think they can get away with copying. It's very definately a smoking gun.
Re:Samsung internal doc: 125 iphone pic competitive analysis
by vidarh on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @08:10AM
(#4355101)
It is the point legally, though. Copying in itself is not illegal. It takes other elements, such as explicitly violating design patents or making a product that is similar enough to confuse consumers before it becomes illegal. And in this case I have a hard time seeing how phones that have "SAMSUNG" plastered all over the top would confuse consumers...
Re:Samsung internal doc: 125 iphone pic competitive analysis
by sbuk on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @02:16PM
(#4357098)
"Copying in itself is not illegal" Yes, it is! That's what all those design patents, copyrights and registered trademarks are all about. It's morally abject too. As a designer, I see no issue with Samsung taking the iPhone, along with other phones, and examining it to see how they can do a better job. I see no issue with them being inspired by Apple. The plagiarism here is blatant though.
Yes, that's what Apple are suggesting. FWIW I can offer you some anecdotal evidence. Shortly after the original Galaxy S (GT-I9000) was released, my partner (who was by then using Android) saw the advert for it and said "crikey, that's a bit close to the bone, isn't it?" refering to it's similarity to the iPhone. She said this before any of the brouha-ha had started. Again it's purely anecdotal so take it at face value.