News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by canpan on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:08PM (#43500676)
Currently also looking at Framework+AMD.

I want Mac hardware but Linux software. The other makers build quality is horrendous. Especially in the 13inch segment which is my favorite. Using a pretty old laptop because there is no replacement right now.

The new Ryzen AI looks really interesting! Sadly there is no Framework shop for me to look at it and they not ship to Japan..

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by adastra22 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:34PM (#43500853)
Asahi?
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by canpan on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:50PM (#43500969)
Yeah, I heard good things about it. I do a lot of gamey development stuff and x64 makes that easier. But Asahi seems to be catching up a lot recently, maybe I should look at it again! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41799068
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by MillironX on Friday March 28, 2025 @12:10AM (#43501441)
Asahi is an adventure. I am in the same camp where I got a MacBook for the hardware, but am really a Linux guy. I got really excited when the fex/muvm patches came out for Asahi, and switched to mainly booting it for a couple months. 80% of what I needed to do worked, but that 20% still wasn't there. It was mainly the little things too:

1. Display output from USB-C didn't work 2. Couldn't run Zotero 3. Couldn't compile Java bioinformatics tools 4. Container architecture mismatches led to catastrophic and hard-to-diagnose bugs

There were things that worked better, too (better task management apps, and working gamepad support come to mind). Overall, even though I only needed those things once or twice a week, the blockers added up and I erased my Asahi partition in the end.

I really appreciate the strides the Asahi project has made (no really, it's tremendous!), and while I would love to say that Linux lets me be most productive, features like Rosetta2 are really integrated that much better into MacOS so that I can't help but feel that Asahi is getting the worst of both worlds right now. I'll probably try again this summer and see what has developed.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by noisy_boy on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:00AM (#43501693)
The biggest issue Framework have right now is shipping. I can order a ThinkPad practically anywhere. No so with Framework - they are literally leaving money on the table from what I would assume their core segment: affluent tech savvy users trying to get off the planned obsolescence cycle.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by jpk on Friday March 28, 2025 @01:54AM (#43501975)
I'm not sure I follow. Your complaint is that Framework only sells direct and not through retailers?
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by capitol_ on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:42AM (#43502253)
No, there is a lot of us who live in countries that framework doesn't ship to.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by xarope on Friday March 28, 2025 @03:44AM (#43502636)
ditto (insert sad puppy face here)
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by throw-the-towel on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:00AM (#43503441)
And if you use a mail forwarder, they deny your warranty.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by yesbabyyes on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:48AM (#43503788)
Tell me you're from the US without telling me you're from the US.

Jokes aside, I had to wait years for Framework to finally allow shipping via a friend in Berlin. I think they ship to Sweden now—they seemed to have an unfortunate misunderstanding that they needed to produce a Swedish keyboard and translate their website before shipping here, which of course is poppycocks.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by prmoustache on Friday March 28, 2025 @08:13AM (#43504405)
I am pretty sure that if you have reached the point that you are ordering a laptop online from a brand unknown to the general public, it means you are past the point you need the actual physical keys to match your keyboard layout on your OS settings. You could just have blank keys.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by jpk on Wednesday April 02, 2025 @10:02PM (#43563909)
To be fair, some international keyboard layouts actually have variations of key shapes and locations. The shape of the Enter key and the cluster around it is the main example. So it's more than just the labels.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by prmoustache on Friday April 04, 2025 @12:36PM (#43584800)
I own both ISO and ANSI keyboards on different laptops and use the same software keymap. I don't think it is such an important factor as I switch from one to another without thinking about it.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by sofixa on Friday March 28, 2025 @03:33AM (#43502565)
> The other makers build quality is horrendous

Out of curiosity, what are you basing this on? From having spoken to people who manage IT fleets, and being the person regular people ask for advice for what device to get, with the occasional exception (which Apple also had plenty of, cf. the butterfly keyboard), you get what you pay for. A 1k-1.5k+ Asus/Dell/HP/Lenovo will get you decent and good build quality.

The cheapest $500 Acer won't.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by BoingBoomTschak on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:32AM (#43502917)
At work, our Windows devs use expensive XPSs that are complete crap failing constantly, both hardware and software. As someone who used Latitudes and Precisions when these were the reliable workhorses you seem to describe, the new stuff is just outrageous. (My personal laptop is still an e6440).

My work machine is an M2 Pro MBP and except the shitty input HW (compared to the golden era of Thinkpads/Latitudes without chiclet keyboards) and MacOS being quite bad compared to Linux, it completely trounces the neighbouring Dells that constantly need repairs (mostly the USB-C ports and wireless cards failing).

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by nottorp on Friday March 28, 2025 @04:36AM (#43502940)
Maybe if you run a fleet that's statistically true. If you're a regular person you can have incredible bad luck with specific models.

Got two "2k" Lenovos at 4 year intervals.

The first one worked fine but that model was known to have a weak hinge. Had to replace it three times.

The second one had a known problem that some units simply stop working with the internal display and the only solution is replacing the motherboard. My unit worked about a week for me. Seller refunded me instead of repairing because it was end of the line and they didn't have replacements.

Got a "2k" Asus ordered now, let's see how that goes :)

Compared to that, even the one emoji keyboard macbook pro that i had worked for years. The keyboard on those models is defective by design and kept degrading, and I still think Cook should take his dried frog pills more regularly, but the rest of the laptop is still working. Not to mention my other, older apple laptops that are still just fine(tm), just obsolete.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by goosedragons on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:48AM (#43503786)
I think price isn't the only thing. PC gaming/consumer laptops lean pretty heavily on price to performance ratios and I think they cut build quality to do it. Business lines like Thinkpad/EliteBook tend to offer worse performance dollar for dollar but they are built better.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by nottorp on Friday March 28, 2025 @09:11AM (#43505006)
Yeah, I happen to need a laptop for that niche between gaming laptop and high end workstation.

Where's a Thinkpad that can run Maya comfortably for a student? AFAIK they only have models with Quadros that have anything but student prices.

So I'm stuck with "gaming" models.

Besides my daughter likes the bling :) If only they could sell me something that doesn't die in a week...

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by thewebguyd on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:41AM (#43506796)
> A 1k-1.5k+ Asus/Dell/HP/Lenovo will get you decent and good build quality.

And it still won't be on par with a $999 apple silicon air, or a MBP.

I've deployed latitudes, precisions, and thinkpads. They all still make tradeoffs that you don't have to deal with on the mac.

The X1 carbon is probably the "best" but, even with that - you are still getting a 1920x1200 screen unless you spend more than a MBP for the 2.8k display (which is still less than the 14" MBP, and costs more than an equivalent specced M4 pro). The trackpad is worse, the speakers are worse, battery life is worse, and they're loud under load.

They're all fine for a fleet where the end user isn't the purchaser, which is why they exist, but for an individual that doesn't want tradeoffs (outside of the tradeoff of having to use macOS), there's no other option on the market that comes remotely close to the mac. For someone that wants Apple silicon MBP level hardware but wants to run Linux, there are zero options.

The screen is the most egregious tradeoff though, the PC world is still adverse to HiDPI displays and even on high end models 1080p or 1200p is still the standard. I can excuse poor speakers, it is a laptop after all, if I really had to I can deal with fan noise, but I shouldn't have to spend more than a MBP to get a decent 120hz HiDPI screen with sufficient brightness and color accuracy.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by blt on Friday March 28, 2025 @08:27PM (#43511491)
Fully agree. Asahi is pretty good now though, and the list of missing features continues to shrink.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by Daneel_ on Friday March 28, 2025 @05:42AM (#43503330)
Thinkpad line from Lenovo. Amazing build quality, and you can order them with Linux.

I have a P1 Gen 7 and it’s fantastic. It feels premium, and it’s thin, light, powerful, has good connectivity and 4K OLED touch screen. I’d take it over Mac hardware any day.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by regularfry on Friday March 28, 2025 @08:19AM (#43504455)
Non-Thinkpad Lenovos have some standouts too. I'm running Debian Stable on an AMD Yoga Slim 7 from a couple of years ago and sure, it's not an Apple, but for the £800 or so I paid for it, it's a really polished machine. Loads of ports, and it's approximately performance-competitive with a Dell XPS13 from about the same time that cost literally twice as much.

The one snag I ran into was that when it was new, supporting the power modes properly needed a mainline kernel rather than the distro default. But in the grand scheme of things that's relatively trivial.

I have an M1 Macbook Pro from work and honestly I'm not tempted to get one for myself. I am tempted by the M3 and M4 beasts as AI machines, but as form factors go I'm just not sold.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by mzmzmzm on Friday March 28, 2025 @10:37AM (#43505978)
Aren't the only Thinkpads with displays in the 4k neighborhood 16-inches? The 14-inch Macbooks are 3024*1964 and have all been like that for a while. I don't know why the PC world (and Linux ready by extension) undervalues high DPI so much, because it makes it hard to consider going back.
Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by thewebguyd on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:28AM (#43506660)
The screen keeps me on macbooks as well (well, and the touchpad, the speakers, and the lack of fan noise).

But it is baffling how 1920x1080 (or 1200p) are still the "standard" elsewhere. If I want an X1 carbon, the best screen you can get at 14" right now is 2880x1800 (2.8k). Spec it with 32GB of RAM and it's clocking in at $2700, for a laptop that still has a worse trackpad, worse sound, and worse screen than a 14" MBP at $2399. And the Ultra7 in the thinkpad still doesn't beat the Mac, and it'll be loud with worse battery life.

There truly is nothing else out there with the same experience as an Apple Silicon MBP or Air.

So, my only options for the foreseeable future is wait for Asahi Linux, or suck it up and deal with macOS because at this rate I don't think there will ever be a laptop with the same quality (across all components) of the mac that can run Linux. The only one that came remotely close is the Surface Laptop 7 with the Snapdragon elite, but no Linux on that.

Re:Apple needs a Snow Sequoia by dsego on Friday March 28, 2025 @08:06AM (#43504336)
Consider a thinkpad or lenovog yoga pro. I don't think the difference is is that pronounced anymore, maybe it never was, but you always need to look at the premium segment. Somehow people end up comparing budget pc laptops and macbooks.