News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by StavrosK on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @07:52AM (#4349621)
From what I can see, that memo isn't anything that any company wouldn't produce internally when faced with such a strong competitor, and it doesn't imply that they wanted to outright copy the iPhone, but good luck convincing a judge of that...

Also, did their lawyer fuck up by mentioning the memo? I'm not well aware of how these things work.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by podperson on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:14AM (#4349668)
It seems like the lawyer may have fucked up, or it may be some brilliant Perry Mason-eque trap. But if the latter, why fight the memo's introduction into evidence in the first place? So I'd guess it was a mistake.

Anyway, the memo by itself doesn't damn Samsung, but in context with, oh, the radius of curvature of every corner of key products being changed to exactly match Apple's devices, the color and arrangement of icons, the color and choice of materials, and the design of packaging all matching -- it seems pretty damning.

Yesterday we had the internal memo revealing that most returns of the Galaxy Tab were literally caused by customers mistaking it for an iPad.

Burger King for a long time had a strategy of building new restaurants near newly built Macdonalds because it knew how much effort its rival put into researching locations. This seems kind of unethical, but apparently is perfectly legal competition. Samsung builds its restaurants near Macdonalds, copies the menu, erects a golden M over the entrance, and serves takeout in white bags.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by cyclinghacker on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:11AM (#4349891)
I've heard more than one person refer to their Android tablet as a "fake iPad", like it's some sort of designer handbag.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by Wohlf on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:42AM (#4350283)
Jokes on them, the Nexus 7 is a better product IMO.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by bdcravens on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:32AM (#4350536)
What % of Android tablets in circulation are the Nexus 7? I'm sure cyclinghacker2's friends are referring to the Galaxy Tab, the Xoom, etc.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by petitmiam on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:16PM (#4353523)
Probably not even those. There's still a flood of cheap no-name Android tablets out there.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by mcantelon on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:20AM (#4350475)
Kind of like how Apple modeled themselves after Sony. Interesting that this sort of legal battle never happened with car manufacturers as cars from various manufacturers tend to share fashionable design attributes.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by cube13 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:25AM (#4350505)
That's because they license the hell out of their patents to each other.
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by podperson on Wednesday August 08, 2012 @08:26PM (#4358865)
There's a difference between modeling yourself after someone -- "Sony is cool because it cares about quality and design, and we should too" -- and slavishly copying them.

Samsung certainly doesn't model itself after Apple. It just copies their product designs down to the packaging and marketing.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by philwelch on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:50PM (#4350925)
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by blu3jack on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @02:07PM (#4351362)
Even better: for years Barnes & Noble bought out the contract of every location that Borders tried to open in NYC, and opened a B&N there for the exact same reason -- and also to keep Borders out of NYC. In the rest of the country they did the open-across-the-street trick whenever possible.

Of course, Borders went on to screw the pooch all by itself later, but that's a different story.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @08:25AM (#4349700)
I don't think that this is intended as a smoking gun, it's one part of a picture Apple want to build up - that Samsung were highly aware of the iPhone, were actively assessing it's design in comparison to their products, and that this path ultimately lead to them copying significant elements.

In that context I think it's damaging to Samsung as it's hard to say it doesn't show a little part of that picture, but obviously Apple will need a lot more to make the whole argument.

The implication is that the lawyer fucked up - that the memo was out of scope until he referenced it at which point the judge considered it fair game - but it's not 100% clear.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by ajross on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:29AM (#4350520)
Well, of course they were. Everyone was. The iPhone was a groundbreaking, hugely disruptive device. And everyone else's products sucked in comparison. And Samsung knew it, and wanted to know why.

This very much seems like a misdirected argument, at least from the ethical perspective. The question isn't whether or not Samsung was trying to emulate the elements that made the iPhone a success, the question is to whether it should be allowed or not. A world where that kind of "copying" is disallowed isn't one I want to live in.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by cube13 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:32PM (#4350835)
> The question isn't whether or not Samsung was trying to emulate the elements that made the iPhone a success, the question is to whether it should be allowed or not. A world where that kind of "copying" is disallowed isn't one I want to live in.

But that's not what this case is about.

Apple is claiming that Samsung copied their product's aesthetics to mislead consumers. That's why Apple is suing Samsung.

And truthfully, I don't want to live in a world where that sort of copying is allowed.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by ajross on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @03:15PM (#4351748)
I understand what their claim is. My point was that it's entirely unrelated to the evidence in question. Unless you think the bezel and curves and color choices constitute the reason (!) for Apple's success with the original iPhone.

And to be clear: I'm fine with the idea that you can get a design patent on very narrow grounds to protect branding aspects that trademarks don't. Make Samsung change their plastic then. Don't use that as a springboard to argue they should be sued out of the market. That's just evil.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by cube13 on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @03:57PM (#4351950)
>That's just evil.

No, that's protecting the patent.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by paulsutter on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @09:40AM (#4350016)
The memo does nothing to establish whether Samsung is infringing patents. But this is just the sort of thing that sways juries. And trials are about juries.

So yes, this is how the system works. Both sides putting in enormous effort over admissibility of minor documents, outcomes swayed by minor missteps.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by jobu on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:37AM (#4350258)
I think the iPhone sketch with a Sony label was far more damning to Apple than this memo is to Samsung. (http://www.phonearena.com/news/Samsung-claims-Apples-iPhone-...)
Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by Terretta on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:49AM (#4350328)
Except this was not a Sony product being "slavishly copied". That mockup was a Apple design based on some Sony design theory remarks. Moreover, the black rectangle rounded corners Sony product discussed in those remarks was Sony's take on Apple's iPod:

http://www.blogcdn.com//media/2012/08/walkman8212.jpg

None of those products (iPod, Walkman, iPhone) would be confused for the other.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by paulsutter on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:45AM (#4350310)
Jury-impacting, yes. Relevant to patent infringement, no.

You're right that it's a great parallel and perhaps even more so.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by Tyrannosaurs on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @10:53AM (#4350349)
Jury impacting? No.

They've been excluded from the trial - Samsung's lawyers were late in submitting them.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by at-fates-hands on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:42PM (#4350891)
This is the distinction between what is "legally" provable and the court of public opinion.

When you look at from a consumer's point of view, it looks pretty damaging. When you start to look at what Apple legally can prove, this memo is not that damning. Like you stated, it says they wanted to use a similar design and UX, but never stated they would copy it verbatim.

It's just not the smoking gun Apple attorney's are probably looking for.

Re:IPhone caused "crisis of design" at Samsung by girishw on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @02:16PM (#4351420)
They're required to turn over the memo as part of the discovery process. Otherwise, they get into trouble for withholding/destroying evidence