News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by alsetmusic on Thursday March 27, 2025 @12:43PM (#43495403)
> But overall the algorithm has kept HN an interesting place. Any good moderation policy has side effects and tradeoffs.

I don’t think so. From his follow-up:

> My thesis is that the above might once have been an accurate summary of how Hacker News functions, but hasn’t been for years, and that there now exists a cabal of moderator/admins with their thumbs on the scale, and their personal predilections are the primary steering force of what’s permitted to surface and what gets ghosted. This moderation cabal operates more or less in secret. Their actions, and thus even their usernames, are invisible — lest the HN community discover that it’s steering things about as much as Maggie Simpson is.

Sounds right to me.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by graeme on Thursday March 27, 2025 @04:07PM (#43497601)
He cited the mod guidelines, which include:

>Other factors affecting rank include user flags, anti-abuse software, software which demotes overheated discussions, account or site weighting, and moderator action.

It's very plausible to me that there IS a negative site weighting to DF. But that it might come from the aggregate history of flags or angry/contentious comments posted on DF articles.

It certainly could be a personal moderator thumb on the scale, but at the scale of HN I'd expect they have some automated formula for site weighting based on the other factors mentioned.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by rurp on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:21PM (#43497084)
I think a simpler theory for this or any site not ranking high is that a small group of users consistently flag the posts, and flags carry a lot of weight.

We've seen this more blatantly with Elon articles. Almost any submission that paints him in a negative light gets flagged quickly and rarely makes the front page.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by vessenes on Friday March 28, 2025 @11:58AM (#43506991)
Interesting take. I was going to say any comment that doesn’t pillory him gets downvoted immediately.
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by js2 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @03:25PM (#43497125)
This is paranoid conspiracy-theory stuff. Or it's bait. It's also not falsifiable. Dang can disclaim it but Gruber's next step would just be to write "of course dang would say that."

Frankly, I find this submission and Gruber's followup insufferable and it makes me want to read him less. I say that as a regular reader of his blog who's purchased several of his t-shirts over the years. But really, these posts alone make me no longer a fan.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by tiltowait on Thursday March 27, 2025 @09:03PM (#43500199)
The treatment of Daring Fireball articles does feel inorganic to me, but if it is, no one who's talking can say whether it's because of mod abuse or a group of users who really hate the site and want to punish it.

And ... while I can understand frustration and disappointment on his end, the long post yesterday, let alone a second post, and apparently now discussion of it on a podcast where he was a guest, is overboard. He often comes across as a touch full of himself, and it's on blatant display here. Don't blame anyone for being turned off.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday March 30, 2025 @07:42PM (#43528979)
I can't comment of DF specifically, but as someone who uses the "flag" link when I think it's appropriate, I see people complaining all the time that their pet topic was flagged/downvoted, and then they instantly go to "the mods"/conspiracy mode, and I'm thinking "I'm just an average HN user, and I just thought the topic sucked or was inappropriate for HN. No 'conspiracy' needed, we just don't like your content."

All I can say is that I found this particular DF post annoying and narcissistic to the extreme. I'm glad it was flagged.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by graeme on Thursday March 27, 2025 @10:20PM (#43500757)
I don't think it is. The moderation guidelines explicitly say there can be site weightings. I think it's likely there is a negative site weighting on Daring Fireball and multiple other sites.

My guess would be it was algorithmically applied based on past tendency for them to gather early flags or flamewar comments, rather than personal animus. Why there would be a site weight rank is not falsifiable except by the mod team.

But whether there is one seems much clearer. Daring Fireball submissions perform very poorly, the notable one that should have been #1 by any measure was "Something is Rotten in the State of Cupertino".

Might be the most notable Apple article of the decade. That it wasn't number one suggests negative site weight. Which, I'll repeat, is explicitly within the public guidelines for how the site is run. Not a paranoid conspiracy. I doubt the mods would comment on specific site weights as that would open a whole can of worms. Which is frustrating for sites, but I can't think of any social media algo that's public.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by js2 on Thursday March 27, 2025 @11:42PM (#43501301)
The paranoid part: "there now exists a cabal of moderator/admins with their thumbs on the scale, and their personal predilections are the primary steering force."

What exactly does Gruber think this cabal has against him? He's not that important. The stuff he writes in the grand scheme of things isn't all that interesting. It's a niche within a niche.

There's not really even all that much to comment on about his posts, frankly. They are opinion pieces. Comments on opinions pieces usually take the form of flame wars or are simply too uninteresting to have much to say about. Same for the other bloggers he mentioned who think they are also being downweighted.

I don't agree his "something rotten" post was worthy of #1. After I read it (independently of HN), I sorta nodded along but never thought to submit it here.

There's only 28 comments on it, none very interesting;

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43348891

It only got 176 upvotes. That said, it's clearly lower than other submissions from that day, ending in the 88th position. I can't find any lower ranked submission with even close to that score:

https://news.ycombinator.com/front?day=2025-03-13&p=3

Also, geez, people sure do spam his posts to this site:

https://news.ycombinator.com/from?site=daringfireball.net

So maybe it does get down weighted due to all the repeated submissions.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by jgruber on Friday March 28, 2025 @06:55PM (#43510766)
I don't get it. You think my "Something Is Rotten in the State of Cupertino" piece was not suppressed here on HN?
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by js2 on Friday March 28, 2025 @09:05PM (#43511755)
I don't think it was suppressed by a "a cabal of moderator/admins". I think it was flagged by regular HN users who think you're a dicknose[^1][^2].

Regardless, none of us can tell you for sure. Only dang knows. Why don't you ask him?

[^1]: https://daringfireball.net/linked/2010/02/08/ill-tempered

[^2]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3019147

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by gcp123 on Saturday April 05, 2025 @05:37PM (#43597014)
Amen.
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by xcrunner529 on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @04:20PM (#43550919)
How libertarian not to make those rankings public and open...
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by philistine on Friday March 28, 2025 @02:22AM (#43502115)
Gruber's There is something rotten in the State of Cupertino is one of the most excoriating Apple take in years, in large part because it comes from Gruber. Why was this not front page !?
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by xcrunner529 on Tuesday April 01, 2025 @04:20PM (#43550911)
And has been around everywhere else. It's not even defensible. Something is rotten in Hacker News too and unfortunately for the cabal, Gruber wrote a very popular article that shined light into their back room dealings.

Guarantee you it's more popular than the million "nautil.us" or whatever junk posted here.

Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by adamlett on Monday March 31, 2025 @08:08AM (#43534017)
It's also not falsifiable. Dang can disclaim it but Gruber's next step would just be to write "of course dang would say that."

If all Dang did was deny, then yeah, it would be quite reasonable to not trust him. But presumably Dang is able to provide a reasonable alternative explanation and has the receipts to back it up.

[dead]
Re:The Website Hacker News Is Afraid to Discuss by CarlitosHighway on Monday March 31, 2025 @03:45AM (#43532275)
What genocide?