Re:Using LLMs to Understand Language Processing in the Human...
by suddenlybananas on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @04:11AM
(#43479935)
>a neural net, given the memories and senses that a humans has, is capable of approximating a human's response accurately enough to be indistinguishable from another human, at least to another human.
That doesn't remotely follow from the UAT and is also almost certainly false.
Re:Using LLMs to Understand Language Processing in the Human...
by hatthew on Wednesday March 26, 2025 @06:59PM
(#43488459)
I am not saying that follows from the formal UAT, I'm saying that in general, if we assume that the human brain is simply producing outputs in response to inputs, I have no reason to believe that a neural net couldn't be constructed to approximate the same outputs given the same inputs. And specifically, the threshold of "good enough approximation" I chose is effectively just a stronger form of the turing test. AI has arguably already passed a weaker form of the turing test (most people in the world cannot tell the difference between a human-written and an AI-written article, for example).
I philosophically reject the notion that consciousness is an important factor here. The question of whether or not you have a consciousness doesn't affect what I take away from this conversation, and similarly the question of whether an AI has a consciousness doesn't affect what I take away from my actions with it. If the (non-)existence of others' consciousnesses doesn't materially affect my life—and we assume that it's a fundamentally unanswerable question—why should I care other than curiosity?