You say "very little of the world is NYC/London/Japan."
Well you know what? The western US would have nearly no one living in it if it weren't for big infrastructure projects. It's naturally a very inhospitable place, too little water half the year, too spread out, etc. But we've turned it into a place millions can thrive in. High speed rail may not be as critical as water, but it's ridiculous to think we can't build a modern railroad today.
If we can't build a modern railroad today then we're already broken. And if we're already broken, what do we have to lose?
And it's also absolutely right that it's ridiculous for people out west to complain about the intractability of big infrastructure projects. Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, etc, wouldn't even exist without massive U.S. Army Corps of Engineers projects in the 19th century that made the harsh desert habitable.
There are several huge differences between then and now.
The big one is that that infrastructure exists. High speed rail can't make a 10x difference on any factor. That infrastructure did, usually on multiple factors.
Another is that that infrastructure was relatively cheap. We didn't "bet the economy" on it. CA's high-speed rail is betting CA's economy. (Govt then was roughly 3% of GDP. If it had failed, no big deal. That's not true now.)
A related factor is that we didn't have as much govt debt then as now.
> High speed rail may not be as critical as water, but it's ridiculous to think we can't build a modern railroad today.
High speed rail isn't at all critical in CA or across the US.
> If we can't build a modern railroad today then we're already broken.
HSR is technically possible, but that doesn't imply that it's a good idea.
> And if we're already broken, what do we have to lose?
That's insane.
I note that you didn't address freight....
The part that rail proponents miss is that very little of the world is NYC/London/Japan.
Rail, like freeways, can be a "tipping point" if other things are close. However, that isn't always true.
Also, you basically have to decide between freight rail and passenger rail, and freight rail makes a lot more sense for much of the US. (Yes, I know that you folks insist that one can have both, but how about some examples....)
High-speed rail is going to break CA financially.