News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ChocolateGod on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:41AM (#43395831)
By that logic they should rename GNOME too.

There's no problem with the name other than with people looking for cultural issues that don't exist to bang on about and fill their "do good" bank.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by soerxpso on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:40AM (#43396108)
I think the name concerns are legitimate just on the basis that it sounds awkward, regardless of whether it's offensive or not. An image editor named Gnome or Goblin, or even Midget (widely regarded to also be offensive), would be fine, because those make me think of cute little people. A 'gimp' is a weird guy in a leather suit or a guy with a messed up leg, and I don't really want to think about any of that when I open my image editor.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by panza on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:52AM (#43396143)
When I open up GIMP I think of the image manipulation program I'm opening. I think most people do.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by johnnyanmac on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:46AM (#43396961)
Tech isn't the best at naming thing but it hasn't really stopped much. A version control system is named after an insult in UK English. The tip tech companies are a fruit, a name thst sounds like clown sounds, and a rain forest (so, pretty horrible communication on what they do). The name of this site sounds like some kind of silk road at firs blush.

There can be some absolutely dreadful, politically incorrect names, but I don't think any of GIMP's significant problems came from it's namesake.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by echelon on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:58AM (#43395924)
Gnome isn't even in the same ballpark. We have gnomes in fantasy and hold them in high esteem.

Gimp is a term used to mock people that can't walk. It's not a medical term, it's strictly a pejorative like the n-word.

Gimp is also a term for someone who gets pegged up the ass while wearing a rubber suit.

Not a good brand.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by panza on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:17AM (#43396013)
And it's also the name of a venerable piece of software that stands for GNU Image Manipulation Program.

This is just a ginned-up non-controversy that should have stayed in 2019.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by mixmastamyk on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:05PM (#43401052)
^1999
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ChocolateGod on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:03AM (#43395960)
> Gnome isn't even in the same ballpark. We have gnomes in fantasy and hold them in high esteem.

I've heard Gnome used as an insult far more than Gimp.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by nine_k on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:01AM (#43395948)
If shampoo was introduced today, the product would be laughed out of the room: who would put some sham poo on their heads? Nevertheless, people are fine with this weird word once it's become traditional.

If "gimp" is an ableist slur, is "lisp" an ableis slur, too? And does that Unix manual-viewing command seem to assume masculine superiority? While at it, that Unik signal-sending command would definitely be banned in Boston for indiscriminate cruelty.

I mean, come on. Humans are able to differentiate between meanings of a word, and even possess a sense of humor, to a degree.

That said, I'm totally not a fan of naming projects in a playfully stupid, disgusting, or, worse, obscene way. Sadly, people get their kicks out of that more often than I would like. But I think that the hooliganish joy of doing so critically depends on the rest of us reacting to such a name in an inflamed way, like above. There's something to be said about feeding trolls as a self-defeating behavior.

I would rather celebrate the major release.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 9rx on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:27AM (#43396058)
> And does that Unix manual-viewing command seem to assume masculine superiority?

I don't think Eunuchs have ever been considered superiorly masculine.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by colordrops on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:32AM (#43396078)
No, they are referring to the manual page command "man"
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 9rx on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:06AM (#43396209)
Is there some other manual-viewing command that you believe it has been confused with? Is it that you are not aware that a eunuch is still considered a man?
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by mmooss on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:45AM (#43396119)
> That said, I'm totally not a fan of naming projects in a playfully stupid, disgusting, or, worse, obscene way.

Better call Google, Yahoo, Mozilla ... and let them know. A lack of humor and humility is destroying SV, the country, and the world.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 01100011 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:21AM (#43396027)
Unix is a play on eunuchs, because it was jokingly referred to as an emasculated version of Multics. Linux is a play on top of that. Certainly we must cancel Linus Torvalds posthaste!
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by nomilk on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:26AM (#43396053)
Thankfully the intersection of cancels others and understands li/unix naming is ~ a null set
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ascorbic on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:37AM (#43396363)
Surely it's a play on multi -> uni
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by sgt on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:47AM (#43395856)
Doesn't matter what the name is, as long as people remember it. Trust me, the name "GIMP" is not what's holding their project up. It's competition with Adobe and the likes.

However it's great that they're making gradual progress. I've used Gimp for years.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by th0ma5 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:11AM (#43395987)
Rhetorically speaking here, would you object if the name literally was SGT_Cant_Say_Anything_Smart ? If they did this it would certainly be memorable.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by opan on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:31AM (#43396902)
That name reminds me of PUBG and Proton-GE (specifically the GE part). Both awkwardly named after one person's internet handle. If sufficiently shortened, and ideally also pronounceable, I think it can work. With that in mind, "CSAS" might not be the best, though maybe people could pronounce it "Sergeant Sea-Sass". Then the biggest problem I see is the # of syllables, but if you've already established context, you could probably shorten it further in subsequent usage to "Sea-Sass" or CSAS only, which is only about as bad as "LDAP".
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by WesolyKubeczek on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:32AM (#43396337)
What r-word even is for? Is it Romanian?