News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:56PM (#43395620)
Windows 95, of all things, was actually a good example of a company doing 'proper' research driving UI work.

Btw, I loathe the term UX, because 'interface' (in UI) should already be a big enough term to not just mean pretty graphics, but the whole _interface_ between user and program. But such is the euphemism treadmill.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by VilleSalonen on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:15AM (#43396007)
But UX is bigger than UI. Good UX might simplify some use case so that user might not need to see any UI at all.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by kleiba on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:09AM (#43396794)
The thing with not well-defined names is that they're open to interpretation. To me, the difference between UX and UI is on a completely different axis.

When I was at university, I attended a UI class which - although in the CS department - was taught by a senior psychologist. Here, the premise was very much on how to design interfaces in such a way that the user can intuitively operate a system with minimal error. That is, the design should enable the user to work with the system optimally.

I only heard the term UX much later, and when I first became aware of it, it seemed to be much less about designing for use and more about designing for feel. That is, the user should walk away from a system saying "that was quite enjoyable".

And these two concepts are, of course, not entirely orthogonal. For instance, you can hardly enjoy using a system when you just don't seem to get the damn thing to do what you want. But they still have different focuses.

If I had to put in a nutshell how I conceptualize the two disciplines, it would be "UI: psychology; UX: graphics design".

And of course such a simplification will create an outcry if you're conceptualization is completely different. But that just takes us back to my very first sentence: not well-defined names are open to interpretation.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @09:26PM (#43407390)
Thanks for sharing!

> Here, the premise was very much on how to design interfaces in such a way that the user can intuitively operate a system with minimal error.

Yes, that's a good default goal for most software, but not always appropriate.

Eg for safety critical equipment to be used only by trained professionals (think airplane controls or nuclear power plant controls) you'd put a lot more emphasis on 'minimal error' than on 'intuitive'.

We can also learn a lot from how games interact with their users. Most games want their interface to be a joy to use and easy to learn. So they are good example for what you normally want to do!

But for some select few having a clunky interface is part of the point. 'Her Story' might be an interesting example of that: the game has you searching through a video database, and it's only a game, because that search feature is horribly broken.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by somat on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:28AM (#43396062)
That is still the man-machine interface

UX is just a weaselly sales term, "Our product is not some mere (sneers) interface, no, over here it is a whole experience, you want an experience don't you?"

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by necovek on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:56AM (#43396162)
I don't think it's weaselly: it's not the first term that has lost its original meaning (like "hacker" or, ahem, "cloud") and required introducing specifiers to go back to the original meaning.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by thaumasiotes on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:11AM (#43397136)
For fun, I did a search for "user interface" before:1996-06-01 .

I found a paper that was definitely taking the perspective that the "user interface" encompasses all the ways in which the user can accomplish something via the software. It rated the effectiveness of a user interface in terms of the time taken to complete various specific tasks. (While remarking that other metrics matter to the concept too, and also measuring user satisfaction and error rates.)

But that paper also suggested how the term might have specialized - four pieces of software were studied, and they are presented in a table that gives their "interface technology", in two cases a "character-based interface" and in the other two a "graphical user interface".

Enough usage like that and you can see how "interface" might come to mean "what the user interacts with" as opposed to "how tasks are performed".

( https://www.nngroup.com/articles/iterative-design/ . It really is dated 1993, which I made a point of checking because Google assigns the "date" of a search result based on textual analysis, and it is frequently very badly wrong. I can't really slam the approach, which I assume was necessary to get the right answer here, but the implementation isn't working.)

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:56AM (#43396163)
I wouldn't be so harsh.

It's just the euphemism treadmill. Just like people perennially come up with new technical terms for the not-so-smart that are meant to be just technically and inoffensive, and over time they always become offensive, so someone has to come up with new technical terms.

See eg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idiot

> 'Idiot' was formerly a technical term in legal and psychiatric contexts for some kinds of profound intellectual disability where the mental age is two years or less, and the person cannot guard themself against common physical dangers. The term was gradually replaced by 'profound mental retardation', which has since been replaced by other terms.[1] Along with terms like moron, imbecile, retard and cretin, its use to describe people with mental disabilities is considered archaic and offensive.[2]

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 6510 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @11:00AM (#43400276)
I once upon a time coin the term scientific physics. UX is not progress, it is the astrology of UI design. The UI exists between the silicon and the wetware computer as a means to interface the two. UX aims to modify the human and invade their state of mind. Doom scrolling is an example of great UX. Interact vs subdue. I want to experience the meaning of the email not the email application.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by taylorius on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:44AM (#43396677)
UX includes the possibility that the software will be actively influencing the user, rather than merely acting as a tool to be used. (websites selling you stuff versus a utilitarian desktop app).
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by necovek on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:53AM (#43396149)
See my above comment: UI used to mean all of those and then it became just "pretty", so a new term was invented.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by hulitu on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:46AM (#43396684)
> Good UX might simplify some use case so that user might not need to see any UI at all.

Yeah, just look at Windows {10,11} and Android. They simplified so much that it's unusable.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by nine_k on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:23AM (#43396040)
"Experience" is more than just "interface". E.g. which actions are lightning-fast, and which are painfully slow is an important part of user experience, even if the UI is exactly the same. Performance and space limitations, things like limited / unlimited undo, interoperability with other software / supported data formats, etc are all important parts of UX that are not UI.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by necovek on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:51AM (#43396140)
UI, where I stands for "interface" just like in HCI, used to mean all those things.

But in the industry the focus turned to aesthetics, so a new term was invented to differentiate between focusing on the entire interface ("experience") vs just the look.

Just like "design" encompasses all of it, but we add qualifiers to ensure it's not misunderstood for "pretty".

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by rvense on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:44AM (#43396670)
And that has happened again. Changing the colours is "improving UX".
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:44AM (#43396948)
Thing is: changing the colours _could_ be improving the UX.

Eg I'm colourblind, and a careful revision of a colourscheme can make my life easier. (Though I would suggest also using other attributes to differentiate like size, placement, texture, saturation, brightness etc.)

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by hulitu on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:44AM (#43396674)
> "Experience" is more than just "interface".

UX has become equivalent with crap. Give me back GUI.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by xlii on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:42AM (#43396380)
I remember studying and the difference was not only about interaction but a general impact on the user.

I always found MacOS Finder's spatial file placement a good example (Non-MacOS users - Finder has this thing where it remembers windows locations and file locations in window, so one can arrange files as they please and they stick). Given that that feature is removed the UI stays the same (there are file icons, some windows, same layout), but it does remove some of the cognitive load.

UX is impacted by many non-UI things: load times, responsivity to input, reliability (hello dreaded printer dialogs that promise to print, but never will).

Anti-pattern I hate with passion is MacOS update bar. I want to do some work in the morning, I open my computer and it's friggin' updating. This sucks, but happens, we got forced into this. And then there's this progress bar that jumps: 20%, 80%, 50%, 30%, 90%. Colleague asks when I'm going to be online - "oh, 10% left, probably soon" - ding - progress bar backs to 30%.

UI is the same from observers point of view (it shows the progress, which I suppose is correct and takes into consideration multiple update phases) but UX is dropping ball here.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by anilakar on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:13AM (#43396810)
OSX has had the striped progress bar for hard-to-estimate processes as long as I remember. Did they do away with it?

There are situations where I don't exactly care how far something has progressed but I want to see that it at least has not hung. Fedora's dnf doing SELinux autorelabeling for two hours without any indication of progress is one of those things I hate with passion.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by account42 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:58AM (#43397042)
The only real indication of progress being made is a log output of steps completed. All a spinner or similar indicator tells you is that the UI thread is not hung but that isn't really useful information.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by anilakar on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:32AM (#43397296)
Obviously in the ideal case indicator animation would be tied to something else, like background process sending output, and there would be a textual description next to it.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by lupusreal on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:07AM (#43397563)
Scrolling logs scare common people. I don't know why.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 6510 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @10:18AM (#43399737)
In the 90's I had this idea that in the future steps completed would be confirmed to the server so that the progress can be calculated for other users. Like, on system A downloading step 1 takes 1 minute and step 2 takes 3 minutes. If on system B step 1 takes 1.5 minutes step 2 should take 4.5. Do the same for stuff that requires processing.

But we apparently chose to make things complicated in other ways.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by xlii on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:31AM (#43397286)
There's still progress bar on update and there's timer (but not always).

The timer also jumps. Once I had ~40 minutes update that was hope-feeding me with "2 minutes left" for most of the time.

My guess is that it's not worth optimizing, but nowadays I shy from updates if I don't have 2h of time buffer (not because I am afraid something will break, but because I know I'll be locked out).

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bayindirh on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:48AM (#43398297)
Their update timer always start from 29 minutes remaining and goes from there, IIRC, and I find that it's way more accurate than Windows' one on 99% of the time.

Funnily, Linux (KDE) got very good at their estimations for some time now. Better behaving storage also has a role, I presume.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:50AM (#43396412)
'Interface' used to encompass all these things.

See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43396140

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by rat87 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:41AM (#43396662)
Spatial file placement is probably not even good on the desktop. In a file manager its definitely an antipattern
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dsego on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:39AM (#43397800)
I think on earlier windows (95 maybe?) opening a folder would also always open in a new explorer window so you had the impression that the window is actually the folder you are opening. Whereas today we're more used to the browsing metaphor where the window "chrome" is separate from the content. I also don't think today it's useful to have the spatial metaphor, but it probably made more sense back then.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by rat87 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @09:02AM (#43398953)
People get way into this desktop metaphor.

A window is a program window not an actual window. A folder is not the same as a folder in a filing cabinet and a save icon is a save icon not a floppy disk.they dont have to stand for or emulate physical things

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by 6510 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @10:35AM (#43399948)
I had my folders themed on win 95. It is kinda hard to explain but the color schemes and images trigger a lot of mental background processes related to the stuff in the folder. Just seeing a green grid on a black background would load a cached version of the folder in my head and alt-tab into a linked mental process that would continue where I left it.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dsego on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @11:29AM (#43400606)
I think we need more visual cues for common operations to give more assurance and reinforce the action. For example, recently I was trying to back up some photos from an android phone by plugging it into a windows machine and copying files over. I already had an older version copied from before, and I was surprised that the copy action resulted in the same number of files after I selected "skip" in the dialogue. What happened was that I probably tried to copy from windows to android by mistake. With everything looking the same it's easy to miss things and have the wrong mental model of what is about to happen. It would be great to have more feedback for actions like this, maybe show the full paths, show the disk/device icons with a big fat arrow for the copying direction or something. Basically the copy/move dialog is the same for 10 files and 10,000 files, same for copying between devices and within the folder... and it will happily overwrite any files if you click the wrong option by mistake. And unlike trashing files I am not sure it's possible to undo the action.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by shadowgovt on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @01:14PM (#43414711)
Historically, it's both, which is how we got here.

The Xerox demo was definitely trying to make near-as-possible 1-to-1 correspondences because their entire approach was "discovery is easier if the UI abstractions are couched in known physical abstractions." UIs that hewed very closely to the original Xerox demo did things like pop open one window per folder (because when you open a folder and there's a folder inside, you still have the original folder).

As time went on and users became more comfortable with computerized abstractions in general, much of that fluff fell by the wayside. MacOSX system 7, for instance, would open one window per double-click by default; modern desktop MacOS opens a folder into the current window, with the option to command-double-click it to open it into its own... tab? (Thanks browsers; you made users comfortable enough with tabbed windows that this is a metaphor the file system browser can adopt!).

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by tambourine_man on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:50AM (#43398310)
You can turn off auto update. I update my Mac when I can, not when it decides.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bookofjoe on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @10:20AM (#43399764)
Bonus: if you do that you don't have to deal with disabling new Apple Intelligence "features" every time.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by Jare on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:22AM (#43396859)
To make a simile with books, to me the UI is the writing and the UX is the story plus how it's ingested via the writing.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by contrast on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:13AM (#43397162)
That’s a good example for showing how “UI” and “UX” are essentially the same thing. At least in a practical context.

We can call an excellent story teller a “writer”. A good story can be described as “good writing”. A great story, let’s say a film being adapted as a book, can become a terrible book if it is “let down by the writing”.

In the context of books and storytelling, “writing” is the all-encompassing word that experts use to describe the whole thing. Just like “UI” used to mean the whole thing.