News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by sejje on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:41PM (#43366434)
> (Yes, it is weird that Zuck goes out of his way to compare himself to a violent dictator.)

Why can't news sites just report the news? Why do they need to tell me what to think about it?

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by fullshark on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:16PM (#43366798)
Because no one goes into journalism to report the news, they go into to influence public opinion. This is done largely by deciding which stories to amplify and to kill.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by smrtinsert on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:45PM (#43366470)
You're thinking of a wire service. Associated Press for example is what you want. TechCrunch is a blog and it's completely normal for blogs to be editorialized.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by sejje on Friday March 14, 2025 @03:58PM (#43366604)
> Top Headlines

> Latest News

> Newsletters

> TechCrunch is an American global online newspaper focusing on topics regarding high-tech and startup companies. [0]

Oh, okay. My fault.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TechCrunch

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by zeroCalories on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:28PM (#43366937)
Yeah and New York Post calls itself a newspaper but we all know it's some trashy shit.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by sejje on Friday March 14, 2025 @06:18PM (#43367878)
That's reflected on its wikipedia page [0], too. Note the word "tabloid":

> The New York Post (NY Post) is an American conservative daily tabloid newspaper published in New York City.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Post

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by hagbard_c on Saturday March 15, 2025 @09:25AM (#43372391)
Tabloid is a form factor for a newspaper - roughly defined as 'half of a broadsheet' - and not directly related to the content of the publication. It got a bad reputation because lots of trashy publications are published in this form factor but this is not its defining characteristic.

Aside from that Wikipedia is not a good source to decide whether a publication is to be trusted due to its heavy political bias. The New York Post has a conservative bias while (English-language) Wikipedia has a heavy 'progressive´ bias as is reflected by its list of what they consider to be 'reliable/perennial sources' [1] which closely resembles a political litmus test.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Per...

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by sejje on Saturday March 15, 2025 @05:25PM (#43375261)
Can you name a newspaper we call a tabloid that has a good reputation? I'd like to check that out.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by hagbard_c on Saturday March 15, 2025 @10:23PM (#43376538)
When you say 'good reputation' I assume you mean 'serious general news' papers?

UK: The Independent, The Times, The Scotsman, The Guardian

NL: Het Parool, Trouw, NRC Handelsblad, de Volkskrant, de Telegraaf, Reformatorisch Dagblad and many others (most of them owned by DPG)

DK: Berlingske Tidende

SE: Dagens Industri, Dagens Nyheter, Svenska Dagbladet, Expressen, Aftonbladet and many others

There are many others, take your pick. As said these are newspapers published in tabloid format, not 'tabloid newspapers' publishing celebrity gossip and other trash although some of them do also venture in that direction on occasion.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by theoryofx on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:02PM (#43366639)
What bothers me about this is not injecting an opinion (it's TechCrunch) but the superficial and ignorant take.

Julius Caesar was not just some "violent dictator" like a Hitler, Stalin, or Putin. He wasn't sending people off to gas chambers, gulags, or out of windows. He was famous for his clemency toward his enemies in the civil war which made him dictator.

Even the title of "dictator" was a legal office in ancient Rome and meant something very different from the modern usage.

Zuck admiring Julius Caesar (which doesn't mean endorsing all his actions) puts him in the company of many of the most successful, ethical, and well informed people in history

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by invalidname on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:16PM (#43366799)
Well... About a million dead and a million enslaved might disagree: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gallic_Wars . He murdered/enslaved for political gain back home, then killed the people who opposed to him back in Rome to stop democracy.

I don't want to compare to these other guys because obviously it was a different time/culture and you can't really make such broad sweeping comparisons. I won't judge people for admiring him because I also appreciate a lot of his political and strategic savvy. But he was a very violent dictator.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by adamc on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:26PM (#43366917)
This. Caesar made a huge fortune from the people he sold into slavery.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by theoryofx on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:34PM (#43367002)
"About a million dead and a million enslaved might disagree"

You might be very surprised at how differently ancient people viewed the world compared to yourself.

Sure, no one wants to be killed or enslaved but the societies of these very people behaved in precisely the same way as the Romans and most ancient societies did. These were not peace loving hippies being invaded by alien monsters.

Anyway, Caesar was not dictator when he fought in Gaul. He was a Roman proconsul/general fighting in his provinces the way all ancient Roman armies did, and was more inclined toward mercy than most, although he also fought a much bigger war than most.

In the civil war Caesar was fighting Pompey, the guy who used his military power to control the Roman government for the previous decade. And who would have continued controlling the government had he won. The narrative that Pompey was defending the republic against a tyrant is more ancient propaganda than reality.

A reasonable and accurate summary is that Julius Caesar led a violent army against violent enemies, fought a civil war with unprecedented clemency, and was a benevolent dictator until his assassination by the envious people he had granted clemency.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by Gud on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:13PM (#43367359)
No, that is not a reasonable take at all. Julius Caesar came as an invader.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by theoryofx on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:37PM (#43367574)
Yes, Caesar was an invader.

But it's important to understand that all of Gaul was tribal. The was no unified country. These tribes were invading each other's land constantly to loot, rape, kill, take hostages, enslave, and extract tribute.

Gallic tribes had famously sacked Rome, and if Rome hadn't become so powerful they would have happily done it again. German tribes had successfully invaded Roman territory as recently as around the time Caesar was born. They were a legitimate threat, especially to the Roman province, although it's also true Caesar's had other motivations.

Again, it's just much more complicated than when for example Hitler and Stalin jointly invaded the entirely peaceful country of Poland. Or when Putin invaded the entirely peaceful country of Ukraine.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by Gud on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:16AM (#43387671)
You have a good point. The Gallic tribes were by no means innocent bystanders.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by invalidname on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:50PM (#43367163)
> Caesar was not dictator when he fought in Gaul. He was a Roman proconsul/general fighting in his provinces the way all ancient Roman armies did, and was objectively merciful than most, although fought a much bigger war than most.

He fought it against the wishes of the senate. Notice I didn't say he was a dictator "while fighting it".

> The Gauls and Germans his armies fought against were not some kind of peace loving hippies. Their armies waged war just as violently and invaded and slaughtered (including Romans) in the same way.

Sure. Notice the size of their armies in the link I provided vs. the count of dead people and enslaved people. These were civilians.

Also notice I specifically said I didn't judge him because he's a product of his time. I just criticized the parent post for misrepresenting him and comparing him to more contemporary figures.

> The narrative that Pompey was defending the republic against a tyrant is more ancient propaganda than reality.

Agreed. Both sides were terrible in that conflict. That doesn't make him a non-dictator because he won over another dictator wannabe.

> A reasonable and accurate summary is that Julius Caesar led a violent army against enemies, fought a civil war with unrivaled clemency, and was a benevolent dictator until his assassination by the envious people he had granted clemency.

I think that's revisionism. I don't know all of these things and they are very much a matter of perspective. Frankly, I don't care since none of that is grounded in fact. It's interpretation of facts.

The two facts I provided were: he was a dictator and he was violent.

Those are indisputable objective historic facts. Were others dictators and even more violent?

Sure. That doesn't dispute these facts. Notice I very specifically avoided passing judgement on him and on the OP article.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by theoryofx on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:19PM (#43367408)
> He fought it against the wishes of the senate.

This is factually incorrect. He was a proconsul in command, fully authorized by the Senate.

You're probably referring to the fact that some of his political opponents in the Senate tried to score political points criticizing his war in Gaul. There was no real question of the legality then or now. False legal claims like this were standard practice and everyone took them for the partisan maneuvering they obviously were.

> Sure. Notice the size of their armies in the link I provided vs. the count of dead people and enslaved people. These were civilians.

These claims are all incredibly speculative. We actually have no real idea how many people (civilians or otherwise) died in these wars. Caesar himself is the primary source and we know for a fact that he tended to wildly exaggerate his numbers.

> Agreed. Both sides were terrible in that conflict. That doesn't make him a non-dictator because he won over another dictator wannabe.

> The two facts I provided were: he was a dictator and he was violent. Those are indisputable objective historic facts.

Another indisputable fact: he wasn't violent as dictator.

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by InfiniteTitan on Friday March 14, 2025 @04:25PM (#43366900)
HN never disappoints.
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by croisillon on Friday March 14, 2025 @05:07PM (#43367320)
because apparently 77M Americans can't add 2 and 2 when it comes to wannabe dictators
Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by hagbard_c on Saturday March 15, 2025 @09:16AM (#43372343)
dictator, in modern political systems, a single person who possesses absolute political power within a country or territory or a member of a small group that exercises such power. The term comes from the Latin title dictator, which in the Roman Republic designated a temporary magistrate who was granted extraordinary powers in order to deal with state crises. Modern dictators, however, resemble ancient tyrants rather than ancient dictators. (from Britannica [1])

In some ways this fits the election of Donald Trump - he was designated as a temporary magistrate who was granted extraordinary powers in order to deal with state crises - but in most ways it does not. Trump does not possess absolute power nor is a member of a small group which possesses such power as the plethora of court cases blocking his decisions make clear. The real important bit here is this:

> apparently 77M Americans

That is the majority of the voting public which you're lambasting for making the wrong decision. Here's a bit more on that subject, read it well:

https://www.britannica.com/topic/democracy and https://www.britannica.com/topic/republic-government

Don't agree with the majority and think they should listen to you or your group instead? There are names for such forms of government as well, names which are generally portrayed as being opposites of the two I pointed at earlier.

[1] https://www.britannica.com/topic/dictator-ruler

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by croisillon on Saturday March 15, 2025 @12:28PM (#43373511)
weird you would prefer to use the 2000 y.o. definition of dictator than the current one but if that helps you cope, be my guest

the 77M people were not the majority but a plurality, although i'm not sure there is a 2000 y.o. definition for that to help you cope

don't look too far for a president who has been elected by a minority, it happened as recently as 2016

Re:Bluesky quickly sold out of the T-shirt its CEO wore to t... by sejje on Saturday March 15, 2025 @05:25PM (#43375255)
> dictator, in modern political systems

He used a modern definition. It referenced the origin of the term.

> the 77M people were not the majority but a plurality

What distinction are you trying to make here? That not everyone voted?

He called it the majority of the voting population.

> cope

heh