News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by blackguardx on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:20PM (#43337714)
PCR is a basic tool. It amplifies, much like your car stereo. If you can hear music when tuning in an AM station, you don’t question the automatic gain correction the stereo is doing internally. PCR is the same way. If the target is present, it is detectable. If it isn’t then it isn’t. There are so many variables at play that the number of cycles isn’t very meaningful.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by aftbit on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:45PM (#43337913)
Is sample contamination more impactful (likely to lead to a false positive) at 100 or 200 cycles than at 20? I remember some distrust of high PCR cycle counts during COVID but I never quite understood the fear.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by blackguardx on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @09:32PM (#43339078)
If there is contamination with the target sequence then it will be found by the PCR analysis. I don’t know the practical limits of sensitivity but theoretically it can detect a single occurrence of the target sequence.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by Izkata on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @11:47PM (#43339785)
With enough cycles, dead virus you're successfully fighting off can be detected. It doesn't need contamination. For what it was used for, those were false positives that inflated the counts.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by tanseydavid on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:26PM (#43337774)
Kary Mullis, inventor of PCR does not agree with your analogy.
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by churchturing on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:37PM (#43337859)
He also

* believed in astrology

* denied Avogadro’s number (???)

* practiced telepathy

* didn’t believe in HIV causing AIDs

* didn’t believe in climate change

* didn’t believe in the ozone hole

While he certainly had incredible intelligence, clearly him believing something isn’t a hugely convincing reasoning.

disclaimer: i am a person who believes in Avogadro’s number and not astrology. truly an intellectual outcast and rebel

Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by dekhn on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:14PM (#43338136)
he didn't deny avogadro's number so much as say that its definition was somewhat arbitrary.

IIRC he made the comment before the modern redefinition of SI units. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_revision_of_the_SI#Mass_a... for more details about the ongoing issues associated with absolute numeric counts of elements and their association with mass.

Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by churchturing on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @12:21PM (#43344850)
this is useful context, thanks. would edit my prior comment but it is no longer editable. after some more research it seems his comments on the matter were reasonable
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by blackguardx on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @09:33PM (#43339093)
Can you expand on this? What does he not agree with?
Re:"It Has Been Determined" That Infected Dairy Herd Serolog... by timewizard on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @11:50PM (#43339798)
You run PCR for cycles. You run it for 32 cycles? You've got a 4 billion times multiplication of the input signal. You see the problem? "Detectable" isn't a single ended specification with "PCR." You really do need to disclose how many cycles you ran.

Similarly there's ionizing radiation in your home. Right now. Flowing through you. If it's not above the background it's not interesting or material. So just saying "we found radiation" is equally meaningless unless you tell me that level in relation to something.