News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by CaptWillard on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:35PM (#43324962)
I reject the premise that people can be sorted into bullies and non-bullies.

It's amusing/frustrating that such a premise is taken seriously.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by bandinobaddies on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:42PM (#43325058)
I agree, somewhat.

In my high school, there was hierarchy of bullies. Some bullied other bullies. The victim bullies bullied other weaker kids. And some bullies only bullied other bullies, they were considered heros.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by bloomingkales on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:55PM (#43325245)
It's a spectrum. I'll give you an example of a story. I knew this kid in kindergarten who was Hindu, and all the kids on the bus on the way home would call him a dirty hindu and spit on him for pretty much the whole bus ride. This was nearly every other day.

Anyway, I'm sure the dude got over it. Or did he? You see, when we undermine these words and concepts of bullying, without knowing that there's a 5 year old going through shit like that, its no good. Also, we know it doesn't stop at kindergarten.

The focal point should be the victim, and that way we cannot do any gymnastics around "well there's a bully for the bully for the bully". There's a crying 5 year old is the main point. I don't think the kid even told his mom (any mother would intervene) because he was a tough kid, kinda just held it together after the bus ride, every fucking day.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by taeric on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:59PM (#43325316)
I'm curious. If you had some that you would categorize as only bullying people that bullied others, would this fit with a justice perception? How does this account for someone "repenting," as it were, of bullying?

Put differently, I think the objection is that "bully" is not an immutable facet of someone. For many, it often isn't even a choice moreso a by product of the general environment they find themselves in. Obviously malicious actors are defined by their intent to bully. But sometimes people will feel bullied from someone's intent to maintain a preexisting order? How does that get categorized?

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by bandinobaddies on Monday March 10, 2025 @05:17PM (#43326203)
> If you had some that you would categorize as only bullying people that bullied others, would this fit with a justice perception? How does this account for someone "repenting," as it were, of bullying?

I think some of it was complex rivalries. Bullies on the top were the cool kids who cared about their image a lot. They mostly bullied bullies who were challenging their status. They were also more sophisticated in their bullying and have other bullies do the dirty work of physical fights.

Then there were hero bullies who targeted other bullies. These hero bullies were usually stronger kids and really looking for fights. They didn't care about their images as much. A lot of time they were already in trouble with school. They would become protectors of the weakest kids. But they were probably the most violent and beat up the bullies of those weakest kids pretty bad. Maybe they had a savior complex. We really considered them heros at the time but now I realize that they went too far and probably pushed their victim bullies to get more violent.

> For many, it often isn't even a choice moreso a by product of the general environment they find themselves in

Yes, it was indeed the environment, at least, for some kids. Almost every kid was victim and a bully at the same time. We were like dogs, there was power hierarchy that was constantly challenged and enforced. Things would be fine most of the time if you didn't challenge anyone, every once in a while someone try to establish their dominance over you by verbally or physically assaulting you.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by rexpop on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:53PM (#43325956)
> some bullies only bullied other bullies, they were considered heros.

Tit-for-Tat is a Nash Optimal survival strategy for the iterated prisoner's dilemma.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by cantrecallmypwd on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:57PM (#43325277)
It's a spectrum rather than binary categorization.

It's pretty easy to see that certain people are bully-like and certain people are definitely not bully-like.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by ithkuil on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:15PM (#43325547)
There is also the effect of the person that engaged in bullying behaviour after having been bullied on the past and finally having the means to enjoy the feeling of being on the other side.
Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by CaptWillard on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @02:55PM (#43346516)
> It's pretty easy to see that certain people are XXXX and certain people are definitely not XXXX.

What a fascinating pattern of thought.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by sitkack on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:23PM (#43325638)
I have known at least 7 people in my short life whose MAJOR defining personality attribute was bullying. Two of them were old enough to have had kids at the time, and both had 5 or more. One has a PhD and that was and still is way outside of the norm. Just anecdotal, but it is a data point.
Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by rexpop on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:52PM (#43325937)
Do you reject the premise that people can be tagged or filtered by any aspects, whatsoever? Bullying behavior, perhaps, needn't be a "core" or "genetic" attribute of a person in order to meaningfully discern whether or not one's engaged in it at significantly higher rates.

What's the distribution, I wonder. Bimodal?

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by CaptWillard on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @01:36PM (#43345677)
I reject the premise for a number of reasons but many of them come down to how wildly subjective it is.

What constitutes bullying behavior?

Is there any context that would shift or nullify the label?

How often must someone engage in this behavior to have it be a defining characteristic?

What parameters would allow someone to shed the label?

You could add many more without much effort.

Re:Study finds bullies have more children than non-bullies by rexpop on Friday March 14, 2025 @01:09PM (#43364681)
Q: What constitutes bullying behavior?

A: Bullying behavior constitutes repeated aggressive actions intended to harm or intimidate another individual.

Q: Is there any context that would shift or nullify the label?

A: Contexts such as mutual consent, playful interactions among friends, or cultural differences may shift or nullify the label of bullying.

Q: How often must someone engage in this behavior to have it be a defining characteristic?

A: Engaging in bullying behavior consistently over time, rather than as an isolated incident, typically defines it as a characteristic of an individual.

Q: What parameters would allow someone to shed the label?

A: To shed the label, a person would need to demonstrate a sustained change in behavior, showing empathy and respect towards others over a significant period.