News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by paxys on Sunday March 09, 2025 @04:46PM (#43313602)
The cost of coffee beans in a standard espresso drink is ~25 cents, and that's if you are brewing ultra high-end $15-20/lbs beans. Raising the price of the beans by 15% or 30% or even 50% isn't going to make all that much difference to margins when the end product retails for $4-6 or more.

The coffee shop business is only tangentially related to coffee. Whether you will be successful or not depends more on location, labor, branding, interior decor, music, bakery, food, upsells..

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by kneath on Sunday March 09, 2025 @05:22PM (#43314006)
Might want to check your math there. At $20/lb, zero waste (!!), 18g of coffee is $0.80/shot. Add in 10-15% waste (accurately predicting exact supply of beans is almost impossible, plus dialing in, mistakes, and training) and a more standard 22g basket, you get $1.12 per drink.

Aiming for 25% COGS, that pushes up the price of a cup to $4.50 before milk, syrups, cups, etc. If the cost of coffee doubled, you'd be looking at the cost of coffee only being 38% COGS for a $6 drink. That kind of increase is not only going to completely remove all margins, but likely put you in the red per drink served.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by paxys on Sunday March 09, 2025 @05:56PM (#43314318)
There is no "standard 22g basket". Regular 8-12 oz drinks at most coffee shops have a single 7-10g shot. Double shots and larger sizes always cost more.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:36PM (#43314638)
Outside of Italy nobody uses single shot baskets.

All espresso based drinks you will find will be double-based.

And especially any place which is doing specialty coffee is going to be using larger doses to make extraction more consistent with lighter roasted coffee (in the realm from 18g to 28g).

It's pretty normal nowadays to see 20g or 22g baskets used in specialty coffee shops.

You can obviously order a single but the price difference is just a trick, the other shot gets dumped unless two people order singles at the same time.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by MichaelZuo on Sunday March 09, 2025 @07:35PM (#43315082)
> Outside of Italy nobody uses single shot baskets. > All espresso based drinks you will find will be double-based.

Do you have a source for these claims?

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Sunday March 09, 2025 @07:59PM (#43315277)
For #1:

Ask any coffee professional (someone who actually knows what they're doing).

Or just go walk around. Try to find a cafe which is using different portafilters with single spouts (an indication of a single shot basket). Or ask them. Buy a single espresso and watch what they do. You will never see them use a single shot basket or a single spouted portafilter. You will always see them split a double.

For #2:

Since nobody is using single shot baskets, and no reputable coffee shop is setting aside split shots to use in someone else's drink, the only time it would make sense to make a coffee from a single shot is if it would be too intense with a double (hard to imagine). The alternative is just wasting coffee in most cases except when you're lucky and your customers order drinks where you can use the other split shot. But I don't really see anyone splitting shots for milk drinks, maybe I've not paid enough attention as I don't drink them that often. Either way, you're still brewing a double shot.

You can again, just watch what they're doing. I've never seen a coffee shop where you can't see the bar and the machine. Just watch what happens.

Lastly, you can't dial in a single shot basket and a double shot basket at the same time, you need to have dedicated grinders dialled in for both. Nobody outside of Italy bothers with that. For specialty cafes you'd be doubling the number of dialled in grinders which would be especially impractical.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by layoric on Sunday March 09, 2025 @09:26PM (#43315953)
> you need to have dedicated grinders dialled in for both. Nobody outside of Italy bothers with that.

Huh? Most cafe's I see (Australia) the grinding is separate from the dispensing, and it is a single shot per pull. It's a big world out there mate, might be more of an isolated cultural thing than you realize or my neck of the woods is special. Either way, likely varies.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:44AM (#43318211)
> Huh? Most cafe's I see (Australia) the grinding is separate from the dispensing, and it is a single shot per pull.

This is just not how espresso works.

You can dose the same grind into a double basket and a single basket and you will never get the same coffee out of both.

Maybe Australia is special but in Europe, the UK and America, except for Italy (and apparently some surrounding places) nobody is using single shot baskets.

This is jusg a well known fact in the coffee industry.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by MichaelZuo on Sunday March 09, 2025 @10:40PM (#43316465)
This reply doesn’t make sense… your own words and opinions can’t substitute for providing sources.

Unless you have some extraordinay amount of authority and/or credibility above and beyond that of the other HN users contradicting?

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @04:56AM (#43318280)
I don't carry around sources for well established industry wide facts which you can verify yourself by opening your eyes. Do you carry around a source that proves that using a keyboard to type is faster than using morse code?

James Hoffman (coffee professional, winner of WBC) discusses the obscurity of single dose baskets in his video here. He mentions they're not often used in the home because he is discussing home espresso but the 50 caveats of single dose baskets apply to the industry too.

https://youtu.be/3oFV88PzEFE?si=_cUs33SeovZ0jHYJ&t=549

Discussion of single baskets by The Wired Gourmet pointing out that in the industry double and triple baskets are used and split in vast preference to single shot baskets. Also covering the difficulty of working with single shot baskets:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OnH2Woluck

The Real Sprometheus video talking about single shot baskets, their obscurity,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y0XariiJiHk

A cafe owner talking about why single shot baskets are not worth it in a commercial environment:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-N3OlSa-4Wg

The reason people in this section are disagreeing with me is because they have never made specialty espresso and have no idea how difficult it is to dial in a single basket, even if you're a cafe.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by MichaelZuo on Monday March 10, 2025 @09:56AM (#43320667)
And what of the second claim?

“All espresso based drinks” seems incredibly broad.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:31AM (#43321685)
Yeah it's a general rule, there are some exceptions, but they're less common than is worth challenging this claim for. Some drinks would be too strong to be made from a double, these will use a split single in countries where doubles are the norm. The second shot will end up wasted unless someone else is ordering the same exact drink or ordering a single espresso (also rare outside of Italy and some other countries). I've seen it but most customers prefer to see bigger drinks these days so most cafes don't usually face this problem and make drinks from double shots.

For reference, I use a 36g shot (basically 36ml if you wait for the crema to dissipate) for a 170ml "flat white" at home. This achieves a balanced strength for this kind of drink. You really have to get into the tiny drink category before you really reach the realm of "this is too strong and I must use a split single". And, in those cases, due to the fact of the double shot (and, I would struggle to come up with "sources" but it's again generally accepted that unless you can use the second split shot for a drink immediately, it goes down the sink), you are still often using a double worth of coffee for a single shot drink.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:57AM (#43321390)
Again, this only takes basic experience in coffee/cafe drinks to understand this is true. The standard espresso based drinks are: espresso, cappuccino, latte, macchiato, cortado, flat white, americano, mocha, and a few other varieties. Every single one of those starts with a double shot of espresso (~1.5-2 fl oz of liquid). This is sometimes even referred to as a 'single shot' even though 1.5oz would put you in what is considered a double shot.

There may be some niche drinks that use less espresso liquid, but they're not common. If I was only given 0.8 fl oz (which, is what a single shot looks like) in an espresso drink I would be upset.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by oglop on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @03:46AM (#43330133)
lol this thread is amazing. Hacker news is truly a place filled with confidently wrong smart people. Showed this to my wife, a barista in Seattle, and she asked me why I go to this stupid fucking site. I wasn’t able to give a good answer other than boredom.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @06:52AM (#43331168)
I mean if you think about it, almost nobody here is a Barista (home or commercial), but most people here are technical. People don't realise the complexity of coffee when they haven't actually tried making espresso so it's not too surprising that you get people who think they've figured it all out in their head. Same thing happens on this website with basically any niche technology (haha, I can't believe I am referring to brewing coffee as technology).
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by jjcob on Monday March 10, 2025 @12:47PM (#43322418)
At least in Austria, this seems to be a recent phenomenon, and limited to "fancy" coffee places. I was surprised the first time I saw the barista throw away half the coffee when I ordered an espresso.

I don't have statistics, but I think that single spout portafilters are still common in traditional Austrian cafes. I agree that you can't perfectly dial in the grinder for both single and double shot, but only a minority of people care about James Hoffmann levels of perfection and outside of speciality coffee shops nobody drinks light roasts.

One curious thing I saw in a bar in Italy that their machine had a much smaller diameter portafilter, so they can make a 7g shot without these conical sieves.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:08PM (#43326672)
Coffee is extremely finnicky and its really not as easy as you think to make even a passable shot when going between baskets with different doses. Even with an Italian dark roast.

This isn't about making amazing shots of light roast coffee, it's about the difference between an acidic and a bitter coffee. If your customers are buying and drinking straight espresso (also uncommon outside of Italy and some bordering countries) then they will notice and complain. Although I guess since most people in these regions drink singles, maybe cafes dial in for the single and just YOLO the double. I don't know much about how Italian cafes are ran as I am simply not into that style of coffee nor do I live in Italy. Outside of these regions where its common to drink straight espresso, most cafes just half ass the dialing in and if you ask for espresso its usually varying kinds of mediocre to trash. Regardless, nobody uses single baskets. In the specialty cafes where you can order a straight espresso and expect something decent to amazing, you also never see single baskets and single shots just result from a split with half of the shot wasted or in another concurrent customer's cup.

Regarding Austria, it seems like countries which border Italy also seem to often do single shots too. I didnt consider this but it also doesn't surprise me.

Regarding the portafilter, the industry has standardized on 58mm group heads in the commercial setting but there are still some smaller diameter machines out there which make pulling smaller shots much easier.

There are currently almost no new commercial machines in that format but its entirely possible it will change in the future.

I for one am considering buying an adapter for 49mm baskets so I can more easily extract good light roast espresso without needing the larger doses.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by jjcob on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:33AM (#43331429)
I know the struggle -- We have an espresso machine at home and would love to be a able to do both single & double shots, but I have never managed to find a setting that works for both, so it's dialled in to single shots. I figured that cafes maybe are better at finding a middle ground. There must be a reason why most grinders have two separate timers for single/double tap.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by paxys on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:57PM (#43314819)
I have no idea what you are talking about. The world's largest coffee chain (Starbucks) uses a single 1 oz/7 g espresso shot in their short (8oz) And tall (12oz) drink sizes. To get two shots you have to upgrade to "grande" (16oz), or specifically ask for (and pay for) an extra shot. Most coffee shops do the same for their smaller drinks.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by gnabgib on Sunday March 09, 2025 @07:46PM (#43315160)
Starbucks does use singles in some Tall drinks (your point stands - Latte & Cappuccino), but not all (Americano & Flat Whites have 2 shots in a tall).

Meta: I've never seen anyone order a short, the only thing I've ever seen in those cups are espresso pulls or water (but it turns out a Short Flat White still has two shots - worth a look)

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Sunday March 09, 2025 @07:32PM (#43315055)
Starbucks makes coffee flavoured desert drinks. We are talking about specialty coffee shops. I've also never seen starbucks use a single shot basket to pour a single shot. They always just split, this is broadly the standard. Nobody outside of Italy is making single shots with a single shot basket.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by rightbyte on Monday March 10, 2025 @12:30PM (#43322262)
> Starbucks makes coffee flavoured desert drinks.

You don't have to order the caramel drinks? There are coffee, latte, cappuccino etc too everywhere, right?

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by kjkjadksj on Monday March 10, 2025 @01:13PM (#43322688)
It depends how nice the machine at your shop is. Some are on a more automated machine that just has a button for one or two shots.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by rlupi on Monday March 10, 2025 @02:24AM (#43317514)
<iamveryculinary country="it">

That's because Starbucks single espresso shot are absolutely atrocious.

</iamveryculinary>

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by protimewaster on Monday March 10, 2025 @01:14PM (#43322699)
Using a single shot basket is different than using a single shot of liquid. Does Starbucks use single shot baskets?
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by rlupi on Monday March 10, 2025 @02:27AM (#43317532)
> Outside of Italy nobody uses single shot baskets.

Some Swiss coffee shops do that, but we are close to Italy here. Lots of Italians live here and would be very unhappy without their espressos.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by UncleEntity on Monday March 10, 2025 @12:45PM (#43322400)
I just did my math (because I was curious, not out of doubt) and it came out to $0.33 per espresso -- $20 for a 2 pound bag of beans from the grocery store @ 15g per "double shot" using the stock basket that came with the machine.

True, I'm not using 'premium' beans and probably doing it wrong but it works for me. Add in 'natural spring water' and 6oz of chocolate milk and I doubt it gets over $0.75.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by kneath on Monday March 10, 2025 @02:08PM (#43323589)
Yes, if you assume coffee costs half as much as previously stated, it does almost halve the cost.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by snailmailstare on Monday March 10, 2025 @03:29PM (#43324884)
If you are paying $20 a lb for expresso beans you are probably not a coffee shop and definitely not buying the coffee that costs $6 at a chain coffee shop.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Monday March 10, 2025 @05:07PM (#43326114)
The standard size for a bag of coffee is 12oz, at least in the US. $20/lb is equivalent to $15/12oz. $15 for a 12oz bag of coffee is pretty standard for anything that isn't bottom rung these days. It's not even 'great' coffee at that price; I'm just talking about something mid-tier like Counter Culture coffee which is available nationwide.

Anything cheaper than that and you are firmly into the budget coffee tiers.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by dns_snek on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @08:22AM (#43331722)
Those are some far fetched numbers, that's the price of premium/specialty coffee and the amount is easily a double shot, even triple by Italian standards.

Common commercial beans are ~$24/kg at retail prices, and while 14g would be a double shot around here, let's assume that's a "single shot" since standards seem to differ a lot. That puts us at a much more reasonable $0.39 per "shot" of coffee after accounting for 15% waste.

On a personal note, I would actively choose to pay $0.40 more for coffee if I knew that the money went back to the farmers who produce it.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by criddell on Sunday March 09, 2025 @05:17PM (#43313953)
$15-$20 / lb is not ultra high end. That’s the normal price for beans from most roasters. High end is around $40 / lb and ultra high end is much more.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:05PM (#43314376)
25 cents (20 pence)? Ultra high end $15-20/lbs (£6.40-£8.50/250g) beans?

Where are you getting good coffee that cheap? You're pulling shots out of 7.5g of coffee?

I am buying some nice beans here in the UK and my espresso coffee cost has now reached £1.10 per.

I'm doing relatively standard 19g shots.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by apelapan on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:30PM (#43314585)
I think you are using a very narrow definition of "nice beans". At one pound per cup in bean cost, you are doing some coffee equivalent of having a glass from a £500 champagne bottle or listening to music from a pair of £10k speakers. Amazing for sure, but not a reasonable floor for defining "nice".

Normal premium beans are around €15 in a 450g bag over here, and I can't imagine they are all that much more expensive in the UK. If you buy in bulk, they will be a lot cheaper.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Sunday March 09, 2025 @06:40PM (#43314668)
The actual premium beans are even more expensive.

Yes at £20 per 350g I am paying slightly more than normal for "nice beans". But most places sell for no less than £10 per 250g of light roast. That's still 76p ($1) per shot.

The only things going for less are darker roasts, supermarket coffee and blends.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by OJFord on Monday March 10, 2025 @10:26AM (#43321029)
Pact is £7.95/250g (or I think £8.95 to new customers) for the mid-tier (any roast) bags. House blend & premium tier are iirc £1 either side.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Monday March 10, 2025 @11:04AM (#43321456)
250g bags are only 70% of the size of a 350g bag. Also, they don't seem to offer anything except blends.

Their actual more expensive coffee (which even then, it's unclear if this is a blend or not) is 14 pounds a bag, which... when you scale to 350g comes out to, unsurprisingly, about 20 pounds.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by OJFord on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:40PM (#43338338)
Comment I replied to said 'no less than £10 per 250g' so I don't know why you're dismissing my response of a specialist (if not high end) supplier at as low as £6.95 in that quantity as irrelevant somehow.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Wednesday March 12, 2025 @11:21AM (#43344202)
The comment you replied to spoke of 10 lbs per 250g for a light roast. I haven't tried Pact personally, but just reading their marketing copy, I don't really have confidence that what they call a 'light roast' is truly a light roast by specialty coffee standards.

For context, a few signs I see:

* The way they even describe the tasting notes don't generally align with coffee selected for light roast suitability. Dark chocolate is rarely a note you see in a light roast.

* Every single bean is described as '<roast level> roast with hints of <tasting note>'.

Also, maybe pricing is better in the UK locally... but their website appears to advertise only their cheapest generic blends at 10pounds/250g. Stepping up to anything else is 11 or 14 pounds per bag.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:23PM (#43326806)
Pact isn't ultra high end. Its pretty middle (maybe a bit better) of the road as far as UK roasters go.

Ultra high end would be Gesha or something equivalent. Those often go for fun prices like £28 (and that is still on the low end) for a 150g bag in the UK. That's £3.50 for a 19g shot, and if I was buying Gesha I would probably get a triple precision basket or a step down basket because I would want the absolute best chance of extracting well if I'm spending that much.

My £1.10 shots are definitely above middle of the road. Maybe you can call them high end. But they're not ultra high end and a single shot of ultra high end is definitely a lot more than $.25 as the initial comment in this chain seems to claim.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by criddell on Monday March 10, 2025 @09:47PM (#43328310)
Coffee from Okinawa would probably be my pick for ultra high end. It sells for about $2 / gram (or 250g for $490). These producers don’t make much coffee each year and it sells out very fast.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:03AM (#43331224)
I heard of that one, have never tried it. I've always wondered how much of that is just the fact that it's some tiny farm vs actually tasting unique.

I am spoiled for choice, I've modded my machine to be able to do electronically controlled pressure and flow profiles. I wouldn't even have a clue how to dial this in quickly enough to enjoy it (other than relying on Gagné's adaptive profile).

If/when I'm ever in Okinawa I might see if there's a local cafe which has already dialled it in and can brew it for me. I think that's probably the most cost effective way of trying this coffee.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by apelapan on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:14PM (#43334768)
I just want to chime back in and say that the post I replied to said "nice beans" at £1/cup and the post that was a reply to talked about the cost of beans for a "standard espresso".

My intended angle was to say that I think "nice beans" for a "standard espresso" starts lower than that, for the coffe-appreciating general public.

People like me, who thinks a Starbucks espresso is nothing special but decent enough. Anything better is nice beans! :-)

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by OJFord on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @07:36PM (#43338313)
> Pact isn't ultra high end.

I don't claim it.

I responded to:

> But most places sell for no less than £10 per 250g of light roast. That's still 76p ($1) per shot.

> The only things going for less are darker roasts, supermarket coffee and blends.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Monday March 10, 2025 @01:38PM (#43323032)
> Normal premium beans are around €15 in a 450g bag over here, and I can't imagine they are all that much more expensive in the UK. If you buy in bulk, they will be a lot cheaper.

Those are not premium beans, no offense. I agree, bulk pricing will be cheaper than retail, but premium bean pricing is still quite a bit more.

If you want the equivalent of 'having a glass of 500 euro champagne', you need to look appropriately upscale.

Here's an example of that, from April coffee roasters: https://www.aprilcoffeeroasters.com/collections/limited-coff...

They sell a 250g of a natural Gesha coffee for 928 kr - or ~85 euros. That works out to ~6 euros per 18g of coffee if you were to serve this as an espresso. Most of the time, such coffee is used for pour overs, though.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by brailsafe on Monday March 10, 2025 @07:17PM (#43327279)
It's worth noting that while that's a fair comparison to the wine bottle, it's not necessarily true to say that either the bottle of wine or the Gesha coffee are inherently higher quality or more premium, they're just rarer or more expensive to produce and somewhat more novel than what a person would get most of the time. You can probably brew equally as satisfying and flavorful coffee by spending significantly less than half that rate, it just won't be as fancy feeling.
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Monday March 10, 2025 @09:09PM (#43328125)
As someone who drinks quite a few of these incredibly weird coffees: I don’t agree. You can get some of the way there, but there are flavors and experiences that you won’t recreate with cheaper coffee.

There just is no way to get as clear of flavor separation and striking flavors as you can get with some highly specialized coffee. Gesha coffee is well known, but you can also spend a lot on expensive processing techniques such as fermented coffees.

As an example, there was a coffee I had for a period of time that tasted like cherries. Not just “hint of cherry”, I had multiple people tell me this coffee tasted like candy. Not coffee flavored cherry, just cherry. I’m currently drinking a coffee right now that tastes like red wine.

Can you get a lot of the way there? Absolutely. A nice Ethiopian coffee naturally processed can be half or a third of the price of a Gesha and still have lots of fruity flavors.

It’s true that some expensive coffee doesn’t live up to the hype much like expensive wine, but it’s unfair to say that the only thing expensive coffee is buying you is uniqueness.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by brailsafe on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @12:48AM (#43329231)
> but it’s unfair to say that the only thing expensive coffee is buying you is uniqueness

I don't mean to be intentionally obtuse, but it does seem like you just described that what you get primarily is uniqueness or degrees of uniqueness.

What I was intending to say is that you can absolutely get within a negligible margin for far less than half the price of say, 85 euro per 250g, which is comically expensive, all equipment and other ingredients kept more or less the same in terms of investment. Not all fermented coffees run that high either, and a lot of the cost comes from rarer varietals that may or may not be unique, but just aren't inherently higher quality than high specialty grades of others. For example https://www.prototypecoffee.ca/shop/oxaofizuq8la2g7m9ercvtxv...

That's not to say they aren't worthwhile or in-appropriately priced novel occasional experiences, but in a similar fashion to what you said, there are various high-grade less expensive beans to be had from Ethiopia, Indonesia, Colombia, etc.. that can distinctly taste like watermelon, starburst, blueberry, cherry; they're still very expensive relative to even quite good blends from a local roaster, but they're not that high. Incidentally, if I wanted just cherry, actual cherries at their already high price would be wildly less expensive, but that's besides the point. Ultimately they're still subject to variation in brew consistency, palate, etc.. to the point that I'd prefer to get on average 98% of the way to the same cup with 1/2 the spend considering how likely it is that some of it won't turn out that great anyway, especially without a multi-thousand dollar grinder or custom recipe water.

The exception to my comments may depend on market too, I don't know how expensive some of the extremely fruity Indonesian beans may be in EU for example, or how much a Pink Bourbon might be in Aus.

For all of the best specialty coffee I've had, there's been at least one cup at the same price-point, same roaster, same cafe, that just wasn't anything amazing, and it's a silly amount of money to chase an occasional unique novelty as a regular thing imo. I'd rather have very good most of the time for much less than half as much.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:59PM (#43335275)
> What I was intending to say is that you can absolutely get within a negligible margin for far less than half the price of say, 85 euro per 250g, which is comically expensive, all equipment and other ingredients kept more or less the same in terms of investment. Not all fermented coffees run that high either, and a lot of the cost comes from rarer varietals that may or may not be unique, but just aren't inherently higher quality than high specialty grades of others.

Fully agree. There's plenty of good coffee you can have that isn't stratopherically priced. That said, there's a certain price bracket where you just cannot get some of these flavors. Anyone buying $10/lb coffee will never get those flavors. If you want lightly roasted coffee with fruity or floral flavors, you have to spend a certain amount.

I'm not suggesting you have to spend the "$500 champagne" equivalent to get good coffee; I'm just saying that coffee isn't a percentage goodness thing. For certain types of coffee flavors, there isn't any way around spending money to get them. Certain flavors are a lot easier to achieve with lower cost coffee, though. Any sort of chocolate or nutty flavor is generally easier to achieve with cheaper coffee, so if that's what you like drinking... then you probably don't need to spend as much.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by apelapan on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @01:44PM (#43335081)
Keeping it in a local context: Lidl sells coffe beans for 200kr/kg. That is pretty cheap coffe and they probably have very high margins on it.

Zoegas fairtrade beans are perhaps twice that price. That is premium coffe. (like Barilla is a premium pasta, Galbani makes premium mozarella, Alfa Romeo makes premium cars, Rotari prosecco is a premium sparkling wine).

If you go far beyond that, you are in high end territory. (Ferrari vs Alfa Romeo, champagne over prosecco). There is no limit to what you can spend to get the most unique flavour experiences.

And trying it back to the very root of this thread. A random, generic café that charges 8$ for a single shot espresso, does not need to do that because the cost of beans is killing them. The cost of beans is essentially nothing, unless you are a one-in-a-thousand speciality coffe house.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @02:21PM (#43335487)
> If you go far beyond that, you are in high end territory. (Ferrari vs Alfa Romeo, champagne over prosecco). There is no limit to what you can spend to get the most unique flavour experiences.

I really don't agree with that. $20/kg of coffee is quite cheap, at least in the US. Maybe Sweden has wildly cheaper coffee prices, but I doubt that.

$20/kg equates to roughly $6.80 per 12oz, which is below the bottom end of coffee prices you can find in a store if you're buying 12oz bags.

A normal 'specialty' coffee costs at least $14/12oz (or, ~$40/kg). That coffee is nothing particularly extraordinary. In car analogies, that would be the equivalent of a low-end Lexus or Mercedes.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by apelapan on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @04:48PM (#43336852)
The Lidl-coffe is very cheap at $20/kg! That is my definition of what is currently the cost of low-end, budget-beans.

Stepping to twice the price of the low-cost beans is my definition of premium. Like going from a 30k Fiat to a 60k Alfa Romeo.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Kirby64 on Tuesday March 11, 2025 @04:55PM (#43336900)
> Stepping to twice the price of the low-cost beans is my definition of premium. Like going from a 30k Fiat to a 60k Alfa Romeo.

Your definition of premium isn’t based in reality, though. It’s more equivalent to going from a $5000 motorcycle to a $10000 used car, to continue straining the car analogy.

If the $86/bag coffee is the equivalent of a Ferrari, then scaling down by the same amount would be your $60k car. Which would be like paying $14/bag (for 12 oz of coffee).

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by aicez on Monday March 10, 2025 @02:58PM (#43324453)
I've found that befriending a roaster can get your price down by half. YMMV
Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by Arch-TK on Monday March 10, 2025 @06:26PM (#43326835)
Do you think stalking James Hoffman is a good way to make friends with him? Just taking notes.

There are lots of local roasters but I'm a little bit too introverted to make friends that easily.

I think making an electronically controlled hot air roaster and just roasting at home is less effort than what you suggest. ;)

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by TZubiri on Sunday March 09, 2025 @05:15PM (#43313927)
I think there would be magnifying effects, but possibly in the opposite direction.

If coffee becomes more expensive, buying a bag of coffee for your home and being terribly inefficient with doseages and such would not be so viable.

If coffee houses can maintain price relatively stable they become much more viable. Especially since the other cost factors can keep coffee consumption in check.

Re:Global coffee trade grinding to a halt, hit hard by bruta... by thatguy0900 on Monday March 10, 2025 @09:14AM (#43320249)
I really can't imagine home coffee reaching an expense of 5$+ a cup to equal out to cafes