It doesn't sound like you were all that attached to the coffee mugs to begin with, in which case digitizing them was a good move.
I'd imagine this is part of the reason why my parents still keep my terrible first grade art pieces framed on their desks.
My main issue with electronic tickets and the like is I really prefer to have a relatively robust set of records when traveling. I have broken a phone on a trip and the only reason it wasn't that big a deal was that I had paper info about my itinerary etc.
Something that also works for me is compressing.
Either by filtering: Of a bag of 100 tickets, or hard drives, keep the most important one.
Or reduction: Of a whole page of math doodles, cut everything except the most important part.
And I don't even consider myself an audiophile or feel a need to get snobby about it; it's just when I watched a movie on UHD Blu-Ray as opposed to streaming, I went "wow, you can really notice the sound quality."
I did the exact opposite. I hung onto a bunch of paper TicketMaster stubs for decades because I was indecisive about throwing them away or hanging on to them. The "sentimental baggage" surrounding those tickets distorted my thinking and attached too much importance too them.
And then I read about de-cluttering your life advice from minimalists and learned of a good hack that worked for me: Just take photos of your mementos and then throw them away.
That was the psychological breakthrough I needed. I digitally scanned all my old Ticketmaster stubs as *.tif files and then threw them out. I also had a bunch of useless novelty coffee mugs (free gifts from trade shows or past employers). I just took digital photographs of each mug and then gave them away at Goodwill. Preserving them digitally helped me let go of the physical objects. Everyone once in a while, I might revisit my digital scans of the concert tickets on my computer monitor and that's good enough for me.
Reading passages like hers reminds me that that some people need those physical mementos and some don't. In a similar vein, a lot of people like physical media like DVDs and CDs. In contrast, I got rid of my entire physical library of thousands of discs. I don't miss the space they took up at all.