For example, there's a prescription engineered version of melatonin.
Melatonin is still a huge business.
Kratom, CBD, and delta-8 THC are naturally occurring bioactive substances that are newer to the US market. Both have carved out a pretty nice economic niche with a bunch of claimed health benefits.
A couple of years back, I saw a sign outside a fancy legal highs shop in Fishtown, Philadelphia touting the benefits of kratom as a pre-workout supplement. The insanity that a business was advertising an addictive opioid to healthy, opioid-naive people for better gains in the gym almost makes me want more regulation in this area.
Even synthetic research chemicals are generally legal as long as you add a "not for human consumption" label (and they aren't explicitly banned or analogous to other illegal/regulated drugs).
Clinical trials are a significant expense in developing a drug. Kind of makes me think we should award patents not for coming up with some molecule, but instead award them for showing a molecule is safe and effective.
In any case, none of that refutes that there is a strong economic incentive for market actors to not fund FDA approval trials since any benefit will be shared by the entire market.
You can buy a 3 month supply of Lithium Orotate for like $10. I certainly wouldnt recommend self prescribing this kind of thing though.
You have to dose relatively high in order to have an effect. You’re disrupting your neural sodium-potassium pumps with it.
But it’s still pretty cheap. Hard to charge a lot for a fairly abundant element.
If there's an actual natural, identified substance with huge benefits to people, it's going to go gangbusters and you're going to make a lot, LOT of money selling it, even if you're doing it via roadside lemonade stand.
It feels like this claim is usually used to promote cures and treatments with extremely low quality RCTs backing their use as a sort of panacea.
I used to believe the "just do shrooms to cure depression" claims on principle until I looked into the quality of those studies, which is very low. At that point, you're just making stuff up.