Re:Apple takes UK to court over 'backdoor' order
by gambiting on Thursday March 06, 2025 @03:55AM
(#43277977)
Well it's not automatic 2 year prison sentence. The state charges you with a crime, it goes to trial, and then you have to defend yourself - if your argument is that you forgot, then it would be an interesting case - ultimately the prosecutor would need to prove that it's unlikely you forgot, say if they had proof (say CCTV recording at the airport) showing you using your phone 5 minutes before it was confiscated - it would be pretty hard to argue that in the space of those 5 minutes you forgot the password. But if you had a device in your suitcase and could successfully argue that you haven't used it in ages and the password was long and complex then yeah, I guess you'd be found not guilty - up to the judge/magister/jury depending on where exactly in the justice system you end up. But yeah, while stopped at the border saying "I forgot" is not a good card to play.
Re:Apple takes UK to court over 'backdoor' order
by Lanolderen on Thursday March 06, 2025 @05:58AM
(#43278695)
It probably won't end well but I'm curious what would happen if you give them a password that resets the device. Theoretically it unlocks it, it's just that it takes a minute and it's factory new at that point.
Re:Apple takes UK to court over 'backdoor' order
by gambiting on Thursday March 06, 2025 @10:35AM
(#43281389)
They'd charge you with destroying evidence, or "perverting the course of justice". They aren't stupid, they would know that you gave them a password that wiped the device.
Re:Apple takes UK to court over 'backdoor' order
by joshuaissac on Thursday March 06, 2025 @12:20PM
(#43282677)
They would image the device and try the password against the image, if possible.
What if you say you forgot? I actually had times (after not having used my phone for a month or two) that I (& my muscles) forgot my PIN (not for the SIM card) and I had to do a factory reset.