So if the traditional cable model gets displaced, then HBO will be able to move then to make deals with the new distributors, or start distribution on their own, as long as they still have a product that millions of people want to pay a dozen bucks a month for.
(I'm not fully convinced the current cable model will get replaced... there are an awful lot of people who want nothing more than to be able to pay just one monthly fee to get an enormous amount of video content delivered. I believe the way it's delivered will continue to move towards a pure IP-based system for practical reasons, and I believe alternate services will increasingly provide options for people who really don't need a full cable package, but once you start talking about the amount of programming the average person or family watches, the flat-rate-watch-all-you-want model is extremely attractive for consumers and the cable companies already have the content.)
Around the same time, Netflix announced new episodes of Arrested Development would be appearing exclusively on Netflix. Other expansions into exclusive content seem to indicate that Netflix is going the direction of competing with both the cable companies (distribution) and the content providers, by necessity. In order to continue growing, Netflix is having to make content, too. I would argue that's going to continue. Netflix will find shows in the still-fat middle of the long tail, and pick them up when they get canceled, and they'll probably go into new production, too.
Was it HBO's intention to make a potential future distribution partner into a direct content competitor? Probably not, but that's what happened. Other "distribution" plays will probably end up being force to do the same.
Netflix seems to be thinking ten years out. HBO seems to be thinking next quarter. HBO may be poised to make all the right moves when the time is right; I can't say what's going on behind the scenes, and I am definitely not an expert in the entertainment industry (I worked in broadcast TV for five years about 15 years ago, but that knowledge does not scale). But, the Internet is without a doubt the future of entertainment.
"once you start talking about the amount of programming the average person or family watches, the flat-rate-watch-all-you-want model is extremely attractive for consumers"
There are other values. Watching what you want, when you want, is extremely valuable to many people.
In theory, yes. In praxis, the problem is that the production costs of picking up canceled shows don't make sense relative to the Netflix revenue model. TV productions are extraordinarily expensive. Talent deals are astronomical. Producers' fees, writers' salaries, even technicians' salaries, are dazzling. Union scales aren't cheap, either. The whole thing is very, very costly to produce. The reason a TV network can afford that cost is because a) it doesn't pay all the costs on its own, and b) it doesn't sell the content directly to its consumers. It sells massive amounts of advertising to a handful of deep-pocketed advertisers, and also makes money licensing the shows to cable networks and other distribution outlets.
Netflix, in the original content production business, faces the problem of having disintermediated a costly supply chain, and then having condensed that supply chain into itself. It eliminates the production company, the TV studio, and the TV network, replacing them all with Netflix, but bearing all of those costs as if they went up a three-part value chain (because it inherits all the costs that were already in place when the show was being produced for TV).
This is why I have to believe that Netflix will increasingly depend on for-Netflix originals, and not on picking up canceled TV shows. It may pick up a canceled show here or there, all of which will make great headlines and probably generate a lot of new users (or existing user loyalty). But these aquisitions will be loss leaders, serving primarily to grow the subscriber base at a considerable loss per show. They can't be the basis of a business model, in and of themselves.
TLDR: Netflix will need to build a first-rate originals business, perhaps aquiring canceled shows along the way to season the steak. The bulk of its future originals will be from production companies pitching content directly to Netflix, and not from Netflix's licensing existing content from other sources. Cost models don't translate very well from medium to medium.
Heck, this is the whole reason the idea of "exclusives" exists. Comcast, DirectTV, Nintendo, Sony- they all understand that to many people the content is more compelling than the platform. Sure, platform is of consequence, but if you have no content, it doesn't matter if you have the best content delivery platform in history.
For example, HBO is being presented as a content creation company. They didn't start out as one. They became a content creation company in response to VHS and later DVD and now Internet distribution. They were feeling that crunch when they were just a distributor of premium movies on cable; had they not innovated they would have died. Showtime made the same move. HBO is a market leader because of innovation.
So, I don't disagree with you. If they make great content, they're likely to remain relevant for a long time. But, they will have to evolve as cable (so-called "multichannel TV") fades in relevance...which it absolutely will. The convenience of streaming will guarantee that.
Who's to say HBO doesn't have a plan they are slowing putting into play now? Obviously it's probably not a good ideal to publicly signal to your cable company partners that you have any sort of plan that doesn't involve relying on them in the future.
You know Apple saw the future of tablets because they were working on them for 5-8 years but until the day the iPad launched all you ever heard from Apple/Jobs was he couldn't figure out why anyone would ever want one and they were only good when you're on the toilet.
This may be wildly misguided but I have some faith that the people running HBO aren't idiots. HBO Go itself was way ahead of other channels in bringing their content on demand to customers with digital lifestyles. Yes there's a few major bridges they haven't crossed but that seems to currently be working in their favor. I think they're aware of where those bridges are and as producer of great content they are well positioned to cross them when the time comes.
I also have some confidence that people like Eddie Cue are making the case for the end run around the cable companies to HBO and other content producers behind closed doors. And if/when the big Apple TV This Time It's Really a TV launches maybe HBO will be a featured launch partner. Maybe that will be a good litmus test for whether HBO is going to thrive after the often heralded streaming revolution.
EDIT: Okay, it's a lot more than four. But my point still stands: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_programs_broadcast_by_H...
Or, if you're like me and doesn't want to get basic cable, you can be patient and wait for internet delivery through iTunes or similar later.
So until Netflix, Amazon, Apple, etc. have the viewers that would warrant paying HBO the incredible amount of money they currently get, it's in their best interest to stick with the cable companies.
Even if cord-cutting had a material impact on the cable companies (and there doesn't seem to be any evidence of that), HBO would have no problem getting their content on the next-gen distributors.
The armchair television executives have been amusing ever since this became a story, and I think it's because they don't understand their business model. Or like MartinCron said, they just can't get over that what's best for HBO isn't aligning with their own self-interest.
I'm also not sure if people are really thinking this through to the logical end. HBO is great because they don't have to consider ratings or cater to viewers' tastes. That would all change if they were responsible for getting people to pay for HBO GO.
Of course, history would indicate that new entertainments do not necessarily displace old ones. Cable didn't displace broadcast (though it did slow the growth of broadcast and make a few of the less efficient operators either shape up or get bought up). VHS didn't kill theaters or cable movie channels, but it did raise the bar (it triggered some of the stuff you're talking about being the unique value of HBO; HBO was not always an original content provider).
But, I believe there's plenty of growth opportunities that HBO is currently missing.
By the time the numbers are right for HBO to move forward, it will be too late. They're right to make this choice for profits this year, and maybe next, and maybe even the year after that. But, if they want to be relevant in ten years, the changes need to be happening now. Otherwise, other players will come in under them and simply eat their lunch. They'll have no idea what hit them. I don't know who those players will be (Netflix seems a likely candidate, which is why some of the cable and movie companies have targeted them for retributive licensing deals or simply refuse to license), but they will come...because there's billions of dollars at stake, and there's always someone willing to work really hard on a billion dollar problem.
They're feeling pretty infallible right now, due to a slate of popular shows and a strong subscriber base. But, things change. And, with the Internet, things change faster than ever before.