News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by robertlagrant on Monday March 03, 2025 @03:36PM (#43246387)
Isn't that the same? You want to raise the price of energy to make wind etc competitive?
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by smackeyacky on Monday March 03, 2025 @04:17PM (#43246856)
No, you just need fossil fuel energy to be relatively more expensive, not for energy to be more expensive overall. It's happened already but we're currently being held hostage by the coal burners while they scramble to extract the last bit of rent they can.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lurk2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @06:07PM (#43247929)
There is no way to make fossil fuel more expensive without making energy more expensive overall, because fossil fuel is included in the category of "energy overall." The effect of making fossil fuels more expensive is that energy prices will rise. The point of the GP ("Not really. We need polluting energy sources to be charged for their pollution, ie stop using the atmosphere and land as a free sewer, which in turn will put renewables on an equal footing.") is that the goal is not to raise the cost of energy as a whole (even though this is the inevitable outcome of higher fossil fuel prices), but instead to price in the negative externalities generated by fossil fuels.

Put another way, in a world where fossil fuels are no longer consumed, there isn't any reason to limit energy consumption for its sake, since the whole point was to encourage adoption of cleaner technologies. There is a case to be made that this isn't true, since even the "clean" technologies have an environmental impact, but that is tangential to the discussion.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by smackeyacky on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:34PM (#43249099)
I no longer think it's politically possible to charge anybody for climate externalities, since those people own our governments.

We are basically stuck until even those guys realise that coal is a loser just for practical, non carbon priced reasons.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by robertlagrant on Wednesday March 05, 2025 @05:39AM (#43265038)
> No, you just need fossil fuel energy to be relatively more expensive, not for energy to be more expensive overall.

Can you explain exactly what you mean? Say (very made up numbers) coal is $1 per day, and a renewable is $2 per day. I raise the price of coal to $3 per day to make it relatively more expensive. Haven't I just increased the price of energy overall to $2 per day?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by rawgabbit on Monday March 03, 2025 @03:59PM (#43246622)
Sound bites drives political discussion.

When a polluting industry poisons the air and the water and people go to the hospital because they are coughing or they have dysentery, who will pay to cleanup the mess? If you frame the discussion as about “price” it is a non-starter.

I would argue it is better to talk about workers and their families. As in let us not shit in the river so our children don’t get sick and can go to school. Let us not poison the air so workers can do their jobs and not go to hospital.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by robertlagrant on Monday March 03, 2025 @04:13PM (#43246814)
This seems disingenuous twice:

1. You're welcome to argue that, but you haven't here. You've just stated it.

2. You shouldn't supplant one topic with another. High energy prices kill people, because energy drives the cost of everything, and people can direct less value into things that keep them healthy if they're spending a greater proportion of their income on survival. You can say "also air should be clean", fine, but not "Don't think about prices! Look over here instead!"

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Tade0 on Monday March 03, 2025 @05:07PM (#43247441)
1. Air pollution kills more.

2. You can have your cake and eat it, if you drop the requirement to buy electricity at the price of the most expensive component in the mix. Spain did just that and they're currently experiencing an industrial revival thanks to comparatively low energy prices.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by rawgabbit on Monday March 03, 2025 @06:02PM (#43247885)
No, I would argue I am correctly framing externalized costs ie the tragedy of the commons.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by robertlagrant on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @04:29AM (#43252381)
The context is "You want to raise the price of energy to make wind etc competitive?"

Adding a separate topic seems like a distraction. Everyone knows about negative externalities. I don't think we need to rehearse the same points to obscure the specific one I'm asking about.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Kim_Bruning on Monday March 03, 2025 @06:33PM (#43248163)
I think Rawgabbit is trying to get at the point that you need to price in the externalities to find the actual value of something.

They're trying to explain in good faith as far as I can tell.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Sabinus on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @01:50AM (#43251159)
>High energy prices kill people

Indeed, and so does air pollution. Having (accurate) prices on both allows the market to reduce pollution and energy costs efficiently.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by youngtaff on Monday March 03, 2025 @05:26PM (#43247609)
Wind is competitive already… the price of electricity in the UK is set by the gas fired power generators
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lurk2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @06:38PM (#43248200)
Wind isn't going to power the grid by itself.