I presented it in absolute terms because we're talking high-level here. The possibility to commute from reno to santa monica and having lots of people actually doing that are different things. My point was, if that was a 1-2 hour commute, then housing along side that commute would make economic sense, as will many other economic activities. If it is a train, I personally won't mind a 2-3 hour total daily commute, since I can catch up with books,entertainment,etc.. but if it is a drive, that would be too much, and that in essence is one of the critical issues on how this is being thought about. Cars (EV or not) are one of the root causes of the housing problem.
As for that scenario, 1-2 hour commutes are still misery class. Doing it on a train is better, but countless studies have found that a shorter commute increases happiness more than a big house (the amenities don’t matter, you don’t have time to use them!).
The 1.6 million people in Manhattan would disagree with you.
I'm saying that the people there like the benefits of living in a high-density area more than they dislike the downsides of apartments.
> If manhattan allowed for single-family housing
If Manhattan allowed for single-family housing for 1.6M people, it wouldn't be Manhattan. It would be Austin or Los Angeles, and the people living in Manhattan clearly don't want that because they haven't moved to those places.
Trying to present this in such absolute terms makes it wrong. There’s no feasible way that a 600 mile one-way commute is going to be desirable short of magic teleportation booths. Even if you have a personal jet and priority air traffic control that commute sucks and people want to be enjoy the areas where they live, not spend all of their time traveling somewhere else.
Transportation really is a big problem, but it works the other way around: we need transit and enough density so people don’t need to use cars on a daily basis, freeing up close to half of the land usage in American cities and making housing cheaper. What would help would be if there was a way to live in Burbank or Chatsworth and not need to spend an hour driving to go to Santa Monica, or paying many thousands of dollars per year for the privilege of doing so.