News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by tedsuo on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:11PM (#4320998)
Could someone explain, how the low stock price is bad for Facebook? They are profitable, so they aren't going to go bankrupt. And they made a lot of money on the IPO, arguably more than they should have. Doesn't this mean the joke is on everyone but facebook (the company, not including the stock-owning employees)? Through what mechanism does it come back to bite them? Not defending them, just uneducated on this side of business.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by ChuckMcM on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:35AM (#4321200)
Well in the valley its hard to use stock incentive stock options as a lure if the stock price is going down. That can force you into giving out stock grants and those have their own set of annoyances.

If your stock is going down you are less able to raise capital by doing a private placement (basically a pre-planned sale to fixed investors kind of like Zynga did and is currently being sued for) Anytime a company sells a large amount of stock, and then the stock continues to go down, a number of law firms will file lawsuits.

Perhaps most importantly your 'buying power' is reduced. If you notice there are a lot of 'acquihires' going around. Those can be done 'all stock' when the stock is strong but require 'cash and stock' or worse 'all cash' when the stock is weak. So if Facebook wants to continue to gobble up things like Instagram is can't go into a deal with "Hey, its a billion dollars, uh today, perhaps on Friday it will be 800 million." [1]

[1] Yes, I know its more complicated than that but I simplify for brevity.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by tedsuo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @09:40AM (#4322755)
Thanks, that was succinct and informative.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by drgath on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:56PM (#4321119)
At $22, they are just fine. But if it continues to drop, then you will start to see some changes at FB as they have to free up high operational expenses. If it goes sub-$15, then they'll start making some tough decisions.

Edit: So based off the downvote, either someone didn't like my lack of explanation, or it Zuck is lurking on HN. I'm guessing the former, so I'll explain. FB's value is so heavily tied to future growth expectations. Current P/E is 116, and compare that to a peaked out company whose P/E is more typically between 10-20 (see: YHOO, GOOG, APPL, ADBE, ORCL). If FB gets to $15, it's a P/E of 82, $10 = P/E of 55, $5 and you have 27. At $5 and its current earnings, FB is basically toast as an "innovative" company. So, I say a "sub-$15" value above because once it gets to that point this quickly after the IPO, dropping into single digits has to be a possiblity they consider. They won't have billions of dollars at their disposal to do whatever they please and will have to be more judicious in their spending.

P.S. I'm a programmer, not a finance-guy, so please correct me if I'm wrong about something.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by 1123581321 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @05:08AM (#4321868)
I see what you're trying to say; let me try as a programmer and a finance guy.

1. A lower stock valuation affects their ability to raise money and greatly reduces the amount raised,

2. Affects morale because employee stock holdings and options are worth less,

3. Causes investors to put social or board pressure on Facebook to make changes, effectively reducing management's control,

4. Possibly attracts SEC or DoJ attention which could mean time-expensive hearings and possibly fines for misstatements (a.k.a. lies.)

5. Has a psychological effect on users who want to be part of something popular and winning and on app developers uncertain if they want to trust a company on the downs with their livelihoods.

Edit: this doesn't concern Facebook directly, but its investors and its newly created millionaires/billionaires will want the price to stay up so it doesn't affect IPO prospects of their other companies. This is more the case for VC with a steady deal pipeline than the newly rich employees who won't have anything ready for IPO for several years, possibly with an entire cycle between now and then.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by z92 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:09AM (#4321409)
As the first part, I think you are confusing between profit and share price.

They have to cut expense if they are making net loss or are in cash flow negative. Which is quite different from share price.

And as of your second part. Why would not FB have billions of dollars at their disposal if their share price tanks? They sold the IPO and already have got that cash in their bank account. They won't gain a single dollar if the share price rises neither won't they lose a single dollar if it tanks.

But is there an indirect relation besides the obvious? That's what the original poster asked. Your answer didn't reply it.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by gsibble on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:37PM (#4321069)
Well, all of those Facebook employees have lost 41% of their value of their options portfolio since the IPO. Imagine how you would feel seeing 41% of your hard earned cash just evaporate because management priced the IPO too high or doesn't care about the stock price.

There's many more reasons, but that's a big one. No one is going to come work for a company for equity that doesn't care about their stock price.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by forgottenpaswrd on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:43AM (#4321638)
"Imagine how you would feel seeing 41% of your hard earned cash..."

Yeah, superhard way of making millions. Making a web site in your 20s and convincing the pension funds to give their savings from 30 years of real "hard work" while trying them not to notice the scam before you sell all your stock.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by guynamedloren on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:34AM (#4321197)
Imagine all the employees who were paper 'millionaires' (just over a million) for a short while, but no longer are... that's got to be a bit disheartening.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by dedward on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @06:41AM (#4322121)
This situation is far more common than most people may realize, and has been for a long time. Lots of us have been potential future millionaires only to watch stock prices fall before we could, or did, exercise stock options.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by tedsuo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @09:39AM (#4322750)
Leaving aside the psychology for a moment, and assuming the market prices the stock correctly before employee's are allowed to exercise their options, doesn't that mean they would get the same amount, regardless of whether the IPO was high or low? Am I missing something?

Bringing psychology back in, yes I can see how it would really tear people up to feel like they are "missing out," and the understanding that they are getting the "true value" is probably not much of a substitute. If the money in my bank account fluctuated daily, for reasons beyond my control, it would drive me right up the wall.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by abc_lisper on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:39PM (#4321079)
> hard earned cash

What??

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by wisty on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:46PM (#4321091)
Microsoft had the same problem.

Facebook employees apparently work pretty hard. They get huge rewards, when their stock goes up, so they want to company to succeed.

Once the stock stops shooting up, they stop caring about the company. They won't make money from their stock options, they'll make money from getting promotions or a good bonus. Impressing their manager is going to be more important than the company's overall success.

Employees will lose interest, and managers will have to introduce more rules, to "incentivise" the workers (and other managers).

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by Zenst on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:05AM (#4321397)
You raise a very interesting point. The aspect were a employee's motivation is two-fold. One were it is stock-option motivated and the other were progress in the company is the motivation. Now they should and you would of thought that they would be one and the same. But from personal experience they are seperate.

Gets down to the classic: it's not what you do but how you are seen to be doing it.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by vikas5678 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:50AM (#4321236)
Are you saying stock options are not a reward for their hard work? Its a part of their compensation package, they had to work for it. Its not a lotto.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by z92 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:13AM (#4321416)
He is saying whatever they earned is not "cash".
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by tobtoh on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:17PM (#4321014)
One way it is bad for FB is it makes it harder to make acquisitions. Frequently, when you buy out another company, you offer a mix of cash and stock ... but if your stock is tanking ...
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by veyron on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:01AM (#4321129)
This is not a single-round game. The financial markets represent effectively an infinite game (in game theory jargon), where you assume that the operation isn't closing today. Therefore, you have to consider both the short-term effects and the long-term effects. Short-term this is good for FB but long-term this is terrible (have to give more equity to attract people, you can't borrow as much against your shares, etc.)
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by mikescar on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:18PM (#4321021)
Yahoo's been profitable for a long time, but their imminent death has been on the books for years. No growth, so the stock doesn't increase.

Facebook was somehow hyped as being above the middling concerns that every other public company must address. But they are not, and have lost value accordingly.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jonnathanson on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @07:43AM (#4322317)
The perception that they're overvalued, or poorly managed, or what have you, hurts their ability to sell big advertisers on big-ticket advertising deals. These have been their bread and butter all along.

Over the last few years, many Fortune 500 companies signed $20MM+ yearly deals to advertise on Facebook, develop fan pages, etc. Some -- most infamously, GM -- are starting to pull back (or pull out altogether).

In very basic terms, Facebook makes the majority of its money from advertising. It makes the majority of its advertising money from a relatively small handful of very big advertisers. Shaken confidence in Facebook, for whatever reason, shakes the confidence of these advertisers, which jeopardizes Facebook's ability to make money.

All of this is leaving aside the financial damages associated with declining market cap. In a weird way, that's actually less relevant than the effect the busted IPO is having on Facebook's position in the ad sales business.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by zeroonetwothree on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:42AM (#4321504)
If their stock is perceived as stagnant or declining, it makes it harder to attract top employees (and retain existing employees).

It also hurts the morale of all the employees that started working in the past ~12 months, whose equity was valued at an amount higher than $20.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by frankienwafili on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:18PM (#4321022)
Well you have to remember that the stock price already takes all of this into account. The problem with Facebook's price is that it's based on expectations far higher than what it seems like Facebook will be able to achieve in the near future.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by rieter on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:16PM (#4321012)
Hiring and retention.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by gscott on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:43AM (#4321222)
If it gets low enough, they can just buy the remaining stock, go private again, find new revenue sources, then go IPO again. This may be the plan. Any normal CEO would be out their detailing future plans, like launching in new countries, new revenue initiatives, etc.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by megablast on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:03AM (#4321393)
That would not look good.

I think everybody sees the value in facebook in the tech world, for all the data they have, but the general public does not.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by z92 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:18AM (#4321430)
That would not be good for the general public. But probably will be a good strategy for FB-the-company if stock values go down.

That will make it look like a cycle of cashing the over hype.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by MyNewAccount99 on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @01:46AM (#4321360)
why did facebook need all that money from the IPO anyway?
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by leothekim on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:00AM (#4321387)
Not clear that they needed the IPO money. I think they had to have an IPO due to SEC regulations.

http://www.pehub.com/146588/the-%E2%80%9Cfacebook-problem%E2...

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by ramblerman on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:58AM (#4321676)
As a private company there is a 500 shareholder limit. This made it difficult to use stocks to 'incentivize' employees.

The second argument I've heard is that it allowed Zuckerberg and some of his closer companions to cash out a large chunk of cash for the first time.

Facebook itself did not need money to my knowledge