News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by kiba on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:23PM (#4320649)
Stock price aside, I am not sure how facebook is cool to me. It is a complete blank.

Google is doing exciting and important things like building self-driving AI, google glasses, google fiber and android. However, I don't really consider Google + by itself, "cool".

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by rayiner on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:31PM (#4320687)
I don't know if it's cool to you, but it's been amazing for me. My family is from Bangladesh, I grew up in DC, went to college in Atlanta and grad school in Chicago. I have family in Australia, Canada, and Germany. Facebook lets me see the cute pictures my aunt posts of my baby cousins in Australia, and easily share Romney gaffes with my college friends in Atlanta.

It's way cooler for me than, say, a self-driving car (I live in the city and have no need for one).

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jseliger on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:38PM (#4320719)
It's way cooler for me than, say, a self-driving car (I live in the city and have no need for one).

To be fair, a self-driving taxi may revolutionize urban life by making short taxi trips FAR less expensive and at least moderately more convenient. If self-driving cars become commonplace, city life should also be safer for pedestrians and cyclists.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by obituary_latte on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:56PM (#4320957)
Not to mention reduced carbon emissions if all said cars were, say, electric.

I kept thinking of _The Fifth Element_ while reading your comment. Except instead of flying cars, HOV lanes packed tightly together carrying thousands of passengers traveling safely at 90 MPH. Saving emissions, being efficient. I can see it happening.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:30AM (#4321467)
I don't really think "revolutionize" is the right word to use here. Lots of people live urban lives while interacting with taxis twice a year, on their birthday and on NYE or similar occasions.

Free energy forever might revolutionize things. Cheaper and easier to find taxis will be a small improvement.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by takluyver on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @07:33AM (#4322289)
I think you miss the point of 'revolutionising'. It's not about making a couple of trips a year a bit cheaper. It's revolutionary if taxis become cheap enough that lots of people stop owning their own car. Or even if two car families become one car families.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:45PM (#4323997)
By that measure carsharing and decent transit is revolutionizing urban life today.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by rprasad on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:54PM (#4324052)
People already do that by moving into the city, esp. NY, SF, and CHI. (People moving to LA buy more cars...)

Taxis are disproportionately located in cities because that is where they make the most money (largest customer base). Making taxi rides cheaper would cut into their earnings, and would result in a corresponding loss of taxis until profit margins are restored.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by chunkyslink on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:37PM (#4320714)
Well the things you describe as good about Facebook could be replaced with say email or Google Plus and you would still get to do all those things.

Google are doing a lot of things that can't be replaced with competing services.

What would you replace self-driving AI, google glasses and google fiber with?

I think Google are in a different league altogether than Facebook which is just a glorified noticeboard.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by _pius on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:44PM (#4320731)
Well the things you describe as good about Facebook could be replaced with say Email or Google Plus and you would still get to do all those things .... Facebook is just a glorified noticeboard.

What would you replace self-driving AI, google glasses and google fiber with?

Taxis, AR iPhone apps, and DSL? Ridiculous, yes, but no more so than saying Facebook could just be replaced by e-mail.

Heck, you could even claim that e-mail itself is "just a glorified noticeboard" or a fancy version of the Postal Service. You can glibly disparage nearly any innovation this way if you want.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by ojbyrne on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:23PM (#4320874)
I agree that Google does amazing things, but all 3 things you mentioned are vaporware. I can't buy any of them, even if I lived in Kansas City (fiber is only available if your "fiberhood" meets some adoption level). Promising, interesting vaporware, but vaporware nonetheless.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by optymizer on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:55PM (#4320769)
are you seriously saying a photo-sharing site is at the same level of innovation as a driverless car? EHLO!
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by _pius on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:58PM (#4320776)
No. I am saying that Facebook is nothing to sneeze at. It it were so easy to invent Facebook, you would've invented Facebook.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by samstave on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:20PM (#4320857)
>if it were so easy to invent Facebook, you would've invented Facebook.

The only problem I have with a comment like this is that there were millions of factors and pieces to the puzzle of creating Facebook, that this is a ridiculous over simplification of how it came to be.

Luck, timing, market condition, state of competition etc...

Zuck is the luckiest person alive to have been in the place he was when he was - its not like he simply invented everything required to make Facebook from zilch. Friendster and MySpace verified the market, zuck had a great twist on that and a million other thing fell into place.

Not to say it was simple and non-trivial, but that comment just has way too much bravado and ego and is just plain stupid.

He did a great job, but there is nobody else who should be using that line in any other context.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by sigkill on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @01:11AM (#4321281)
I see that you've read this.

http://www.amazon.com/The-Drunkards-Walk-Randomness-Rules/dp...

It's not rare for people to attribute success only to them self and failure to market conditions.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by wutbrodo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:29AM (#4321464)
You don't need to have read that book to know what should be obvious to anyone given more than a second of thought.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by sigkill on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @04:08PM (#4325331)
Pardon me for not living in the US, and not knowing its culture/social situation completely. That book has given me quite a few historical information where it seems like a chance event turns fortunes of people.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by wutbrodo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @06:28PM (#4326129)
I don't see what the US has to do with this at all. I'd be extremely surprised if the US was the only country in the entire world that wasn't a near-perfect meritocracy. I'm not all that well-acquainted with a ton of foreign cultures, but I feel I can still say with some confidence that luck being a major factor of success is damn-near a universal law.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by samstave on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:02AM (#4321544)
Yup. Never even heard of that book.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by pessimizer on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @09:56AM (#4322836)
>zuck had a great twist on that and a million other thing fell into place.

I'm don't even know what the twist is. People seemed to leave Friendster because it was slow, then left Myspace because it made you sick, then joined Facebook which was like Friendster with active development and also initially seeded with smart people.

The only innovation I can see is that the company was run by a developer who showed that he was going to experiment with and build out the platform continuously in order to attract third-parties to invest in it.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by samstave on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @10:26AM (#4323022)
The twist being only allowing .edu addresses at first.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by _pius on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:24PM (#4320877)
that comment just has way too much bravado and ego and is just plain stupid.

I think you're reading too much into this.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by worldimperator on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:00AM (#4321541)
It's a Sorkin quote, so of course it has bravado and ego. ;-)
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by _pius on Thursday August 02, 2012 @04:04AM (#4327789)
Exactly!
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by optymizer on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:21PM (#4320859)
I don't think anyone is discounting Facebook as an easy project. It has its own set of challenges to address, but, I saw many social networks before Facebook, and a few sprung up after Facebook in a short period of time, with various degrees of success. I don't see the same happening with driverless cars, so I am assuming it is more difficult to implement driverless cars than Facebook. Because, you know, if it were so easy to implement driverless cars, you would've implemented those.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by _pius on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:28PM (#4320892)
I don't see why this has to be zero sum. I can be wowed by Google Glasses without calling Facebook a "glorified noticeboard."

I don't see the same happening with driverless cars, so I am assuming it is more difficult to implement driverless cars than Facebook.

There are actually multiple companies that have prototyped driverless cars, we're just much earlier in the technology cycle for it. But, I digress.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by papsosouid on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:21PM (#4323809)
Thousands of people did invent facebook. The invention is obvious and frankly trivial. Facebook didn't become what it is because of the amazing innovation of "see stupid shit your friends post". Everything about facebook's success has nothing to do with the idea, and everything to do with execution, marketing, timing, etc.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by rayiner on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:02PM (#4320969)
I know this may be a totally foreign concept to people living in the valley, but a driverless car isn't very interesting to people who can just walk onto a regular, punctual bus or subway service on near every corner.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by iron_ball on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:28PM (#4321049)
I live in New York, which has one of the best public transit systems in the US, and I think driverless cars are freaking amazing, even (or especially) in the context of a city with effective public transit. For one thing, they could solve the last-mile problem public transit has at its outer limits.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by wutbrodo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:34AM (#4321472)
Speaking as an SF resident, we've actually got the slowest major transit system in the country (Muni; BART coverage is far from adequate for travel within the city). While this of course beats all the places with NO major transit system, it's laughable to think that widespread use of driverless cars wouldn't improve transportation significantly. I've never wanted to own a car living in the city, but with a little imagination, one can imagine most of the downsides of doing so (cost, parking, etc) significantly diminishing with widespread adoption of driverless cars. Probably more significantly, one can imagine the massive benefits gained by society at large, including those who still have no interest in getting a driverless car (safety, congestion, hell even driverless public transport).
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @04:21AM (#4321754)
> one can imagine the massive benefits gained by society at large

One can also imagine a massive drawback: the continuation of sedentary lifestyle status quo and all of its associated ills.

But hey, who wants to walk 10 minutes to transit, maybe you can take the driverless car to the gym.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by wutbrodo on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @06:56PM (#4326225)
There are so many ways to describe how wrongheaded this is that I don't even know where to start. The idea that less efficient transportation is beneficial because it would require people to be more active is absolutely insane. By that logic, we'd be better off with no transportation other than walking; I find it hard to believe that everyone would be better off if they were constrained to working somewhere within a few miles of them (or alternatively, required to spend half their day just getting to work). Rooting for a higher level of car accidents, pollution (the number of cars needed could easily be cut by as much as half), and congestion in order to force people to walk is ridiculous. Throw in the fact that sedentary lifestyles/obesity are pretty strongly correlated with lower income and education level (ignorance of health/nutrition issues, lack of time due to heavy work schedules, there are different reason for different people in this situation), and the economic benefits alone of a significantly more efficient transportation system would likely cancel out whatever possible increase in sedentary living it may cause.

Driverless vehicles have the potential to transform transportation, full stop. This obviously includes public transit (I highly doubt that a driverless bus is much of a technological leap from driverless cars). Whatever benefits public transit provides are included in the changes that driverless vehicles will bring (unless, as it seems, your only in support of inefficient public transit?).

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @07:16PM (#4326305)
What kind of efficiency are you discussing? What are you comparing? Roaming driverless taxis are not more energy efficient and they are not more space efficient than transit. Being an improvement on human-driven cars is not a particularly difficult achievement.

I have no idea where the car accidents or pollution sentence came from. I'm "rooting" for less cars, not the least because it will reduce pollution, and live my life accordingly. I try to minimize the disease in my life by minimizing my car use - automated or otherwise - rather than addressing the symptoms using a new wundertechnology. I don't control the number of car accidents because I can't control the choices others make.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by mekoka on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:03AM (#4321134)
From all the cities I've been to I can only remember 1 or 2 that approximately fit the description and then again, only at a certain time of the day. In most others, the goal of a public transit service is to get you to destination eventually.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by rayiner on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:21AM (#4321172)
Chicago buses are extremely punctual where I live (+/- 2 minutes) in river north. And of course in Manhattan it takes far longer to get anywhere by car than by subway, or even express bus.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by vacri on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:35PM (#4321066)
Wind back the clock only 20-30 years and such a thing would have been astounding. You're making the mistake of considing current technology humdrum.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by Jaigus on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:53PM (#4320757)
I think the UI is cool but sending pictures around doesn't sound "amazing" to me. Besides the fact that you could have still traded pictures via the web without Facebook, a self-driving car AI is on the fringe and can be applied to society in some pretty cool (at least to me) ways that can still make your life easier even though you live in the city.(better trains for one)

Maybe I'm just starting to get old, and the idea of certain elements from all those cheesy movies about the future I watched as a young kid coming true just isn't as "cool" as it used to be.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by hyperbovine on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @09:54PM (#4320765)
I think the point is that dozens of other tools online let you do those things. Name somebody else making a serious go at autocars, AR glasses or cheap fiber.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by randomdata on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:04PM (#4320796)
> Name somebody else making a serious go at autocars

Kinze plans to release their fully autonomous agriculture tractor to the buying public later this year. I realize the field is not quite the highway, but it is still pretty exciting to see this kind of stuff come into production already.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by modfodder on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:59PM (#4320963)
I think Google may have stolen Steve Jobs reality distortion field if you seriously think Google is the only company making a serious go at all three of those.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by hyperbovine on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @03:43AM (#4321639)
Oh really? What's the other company that's making a serious go at all three of those?
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by modfodder on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:19PM (#4323791)
My mistake in implying there was one company making a go at all three, google may be alone in that category, but there are quite a few companies that have been around longer doing research on each individually.

And just because Google is putting money behind all three doesn't mean it's doing any good. Until they release a product or share their research, it's all vaporware. And I'm not saying that to hate on Google, I actually like that Google is pouring money into these projects, but it doesn't change the fact that Google is getting preferential treatment from the media making it sound like Google is the organization trying to make advancements in these areas, no different than the way the media treats Apple during its product releases.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by mikeryan on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:39PM (#4320924)
Cheap fiber? I'm pretty sure Google's prices are not far off from Fios with a smaller channel lineup.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by pook1e on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:18PM (#4321016)
A 50Mbps connection with Verizon costs about $75 / month. Google's 1000Mbps connection costs $70 / month. It's not even close.

(I'm strictly comparing internet speeds, not TV channel lineup).

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by fpgeek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:02AM (#4321131)
It's even worse than that.

First, the connection you're talking about is 50/25 Mbps, while Google is a symmetric 1 Gbps. Second, Google includes 1 TB of Google Drive, which Google normally sells at $50/mo.

Granted, it's cheaper for them to give you Google Drive if you're a fiber customer. And, of course, you might not even want it, but it's one hell of an extra if you want even part of it. I wonder if that's one of the things they're testing with Google Fiber: What do people do with a lot of cloud storage they have fast access to (at least at home)?

Even on the TV side, the comparison isn't that bad once you realize Google is throwing in a DVR (with 8-way recording??). They lose some ground because of the bundle savings (unless you count the Nexus 7 / local storage towards that), but the competing high-end plans are so expensive (~$200/mo for FiOS) and still a lot slower (3x download, 15x upload) that it's no contest, assuming you want the speed.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by taligent on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:01PM (#4320787)
Please. You act as though Google is doing something revolutionary. It isn't.

Everyone from universities to BMW and Mercedes are working on self driving cars, Google Glasses aren't AR and better attempts have been made previously and as for cheap fibre well countless countries have in reality what Google is just talking about.

In many respects Google is like Apple - taking existing ideas and making them more polished.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by ANH on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:35PM (#4321065)
Perhaps what the parent was getting at is that other companies seem more risk averse. Google isn't afraid to fail in public. I can't remember the last truly exciting thing I heard about from BMW or Mercedes that was being tested in the real marketplace. Rear facing cameras in the bumper? A car that parallel parks itself? A 650 BHP V12? I throw your "please" back at you.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @02:41AM (#4321502)
A recent luxury vehicle has so many "assist" systems it could drive itself if only the manufacturer wanted to deal with the liability. Calculating the route? Trivial. Traction while braking, cornering, accelerating? Done. Staying in lane? Sure. Staying a safe distance behind car in front? Yup. Braking when pedestrians enter unsafe zone around car? Covered too. And yep, it'll parallel park at your destination.

Google's real test will be putting their wundermachines on the market and standing behind them when the liability suits inevitably come in. That's not to say the vehicles themselves will malfunction, but that won't stop some people.

Edit: here are some dates.

- Staying in lane, 2003, Honda Inspire provides up to 80% of required steering torque: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lane_departure_warning_system#T.... Want to bet why it wasn't 100%?

- Traction assist in cornering, 1995-1997 (notably retrofitted onto the Mercedes A-class in 1997 after it was beaten by a Trabant in the elk test): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_stability_control#In.... Early forms of braking traction assist available as ABS starting in 1971.

- Following the car in front, at any speed from 0 to 100 km/h, 2006, Lexus LS 460, with first systems becoming available 1997-2000: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptive_cruise_control#Availab...

- Standard roadside traffic sign recognition, currently implemented for speed limit and overtaking restriction signs, 2008, BMW and GM, soon followed by others http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traffic_sign_recognition

- Blind spot detection, circa 2006, second generation Volvo S80: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blind_spot_detection

- Pedestrian detection, circa 2010, Volvo: http://www.popsci.com/bown/2010/product/volvo-pedestrian-det...

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by corin_ on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @06:31AM (#4322097)
Surely the revolutionary act is making something happen, not in having the ability to make it happen but not doing it. There's nothing Che Guevara did that I physically can't do, but I'm not a revolutionary because of what I've chosen to do.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by jarek on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @12:50PM (#4324028)
Yeah, absolutely, huge credit to Google if they do put a self-driving car on the customer market. I was just responding to parent's question about the last truly exciting thing that was being tested in the real marketplace, which I felt trivialized existing technology and somewhat implied only Google is working on new automobile technology these days.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by drgath on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @11:22PM (#4321032)
"Revolutionary" is such a subjective term. Very, very few ideas are actually novel. In fact, dreaming them up is usually easier than pulling them off, so give Apple & Google some credit. While they aren't inventing the future from scratch, they certainly deserve credit for bringing the future into the present. Multi-touch interfaces and tablets have been around for years and the ideas for them even longer (see: Star Trek), but no one has been able to figure out how to successfully pull it off and popularize it. Apple did. Automated cars have been the future since the Jetsons, and we're going to see it become a reality in the next decade, thanks to Google. We've been talking about "digital libraries" and having the world's knowledge at your fingertips for the last 100 years. Wikipedia figured that one out.

The future is (mostly) already laid out, the roads just need to be paved to get everyone there. That is what Apple & Google are doing, along with some others.

Edit: Just realized we actually used to have (dumb) automated cars. They were called horses.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by untog on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:11PM (#4320826)
Does cool matter? For a start, everyone has different definitions of cool- I assure you that plenty of people do not think that Google Glasses are cool, they think they're a nerdy toy. Luckily, us HNers are nerdier than average...

But Facebook isn't cool, no. It's too established now, in the same way that Gmail isn't cool. However, they're both indispensable services for huge, huge numbers of people.

Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by mahyarm on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:05PM (#4320804)
Facebook is cool like email, SMS & IM is 'cool'. It's a relatively simple, but foundational piece of software.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by Jaigus on Tuesday July 31, 2012 @10:19PM (#4320854)
Yes, that type of "cool". Facebook the idea is also pretty cool, but to me, the "coolness" of an AI operated vehicle is simply on another order of magnitude.
Re:Facebook sinks to record low, 43% below IPO price, as dou... by franzus on Wednesday August 01, 2012 @09:08AM (#4322631)
Cool or not cool is not the question. The problem is that FB feels like some shady scam to me. It's all about extracting personal information and make you click on pixel cows.