There's a systemic failure that a computer wasn't already flagging up the low count for immediate follow-up.
What I find interesting is that AI (or more specifically LLMs / chat-GPT ) has had such an impact it's broken down barriers from people who previously would be against any computer involvement or automation. People have gone from, "You must not automate anything" to "We should feed everything into chat GPT"..
And from someone who has in the past been interested in statistical modelling, it's dizzying. It's as if statistics were seen as boring and fallible, but "AI" is exciting and wonderful.
AI is more flexible and can make up requirements on the go, that is, based on information it has it "knows" that a low platelet count is bad and what the recommended course of action is.
Of course, search engines and public websites do the same thing - "what should I do if I have a low platelet count" or "low platelet count and red skin dots" are valid search queries.
> I was told I’d receive a response in 2-3 business days
2-3 "business days"? Yea, I can see how LLMs are going to be super helpful in patients taking their health more in their own hands.
Having someone on-call to deal with routine lab results that just happen to catch a possible imminent threat would be an enormous waste of resources.
So now you need an extra on-call doctor just to filter out the false positives, or the on-call doctor gets notification fatigue and ignores them.
Or in the best case you send a lot of people to ER in the middle of the night for no reason. Again thanks to liability concerns, but this time on the part of the primary care practice.
Or a PA or CRN. They are cheaper. As the last resort you can have an AI doing it :-)
Source: resident in a few months
I should be a able to put a few drops of each of my bodily fluids into a set of disposable receptacles or strips and it should be able to test for hundreds of thousands of issues initially and millions of issues in the future. A pocket fictional Dr. House so to speak. This would distribute the testing workload to the people at home or work and give doctors something better to start with than only perceived symptoms and would allow prioritizing patients during triage. It should find everything from the obvious emergencies to the most obscure anomalies that could be addressed at a later time. It should also be able to tell me what to start or stop eating.
There should also be a high-risk-accepted mode where the device can make guesses about what is occurring based on all the data it gathered even if it does not have 100% of the scientific data to do so. All this in a sub $1000 device I can buy online without a prescription. This device must not have any way to leak patient data. Connect it to a printer via USB and it just makes a hard copy to hand to a doctor or they could just read this device with their eyeballs. No cell phone required. No wifi or bluetooth. No dial home. No uploading to LLM's. No cloud. Patients can download an updated OS and firmware image for updated medical data and update using a thumb-drive or micro-SD.
Yes I'm sure a human doctor would have noticed the low platelet count -- if they bothered to look at it. Which they didn't (or at least hadn't got around to yet).
Almost no one refuses.
I do NOT want a transcription ERROR in my medical records.
I bet if she says something like "AI will transcribe" then there will be more hesitation, although maybe not more refusals because most people don't know how it can make mistakes.
Are they informed that their personal medical information will be shared with an unknown set of third parties / LLMs subject to manual QA / cloud services with telemetry?
Honestly sounds like she's opening herself up to massive lawsuits (depending on State law). I would reach out to the legal department if any doctor pulled this kind of shit on me.
Also, I guarantee you signed a paper when you first were enrolled with your PCP giving them permission to share your medical records with third parties when needed (subject to HIPAA compliance of course).
It seems like having that scribe also review lab results wouldn’t be far off, but we are still not ready to let the AI system interpret and inform the patient without human intervention.
The problem here wasn’t that a human missed the low platelet count, it’s just that it wasn’t reviewed yet. Both a doctor and an AI system would haven spotted the issue immediately.
I am not saying this isn’t a great result, but the AI intervention must come from the patient side, not the care providers side. The providers have too much at risk, while the patient is able to pick and choose their own AI and decide what levels of risk they are able to accept.