News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by acdha on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:41PM (#43167473)
Do think that it’s _not_ consent when people all over the country spend decades voting for representatives who create and maintain research programs? Unlike this, those were very deliberate proposals with extensive public debate.

Do you think there was consent to have a guy who wasn’t on the ballot do things which the guy who was on the ballot said he wouldn’t do, with zero involvement or consent from the people’s representatives?

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by UncleMeat on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:38PM (#43167452)
I can think of a large number of vastly worse tyrannies.

The outcome of this is not going to be a smaller government that achieves 80% of its previous goals with 70% of the spending. The outcome of this is going to be massively chaotic organizations and less efficiency because of the huge fucking wrecking balls slammed into everything by people that have publicly spoken about their goal to destroy the post-new-deal society and replace it with CEO-kings running fiefdoms.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:45PM (#43167489)
Heck, I'm living in a vastly worse tyranny. Not like Trump will cut my taxes. I'm not even a millionaire.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sunshowers on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:33PM (#43167417)
Government subsidies should exist in general because fundamentally, humans are very bad at making long-term decisions. Institutions, taxes and transfers are how we make sure that society is oriented away from people's short-term preferences and towards long-term benefit to all.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:35PM (#43167429)
If people are very bad at making long term decisions, then how would a government (made of people) somehow mitigate this? Governments also have demonstrated their fundamental inability to outperform in making long-term decisions.

“People are bad, therefore let’s throw organizations of even more people at the problem” doesn’t even pass the laugh test.

In fact, not only does this “solution” not solve the problem, it creates a whole host of new ones: corruption, graft, human rights abuses, and perpetuation of the status quo due to codification.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sunshowers on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:38PM (#43167451)
Most people are bad at making long-term decisions. Some are not. Biases can be overcome with sustained training and dedication.

Using taxes to fund basic research is one of many ways our institutions have a countervailing effect towards long-term thinking. In fact we should be taxing much more and doing much, much more of it.

This is explicitly anti-majoritarian, yes.

Corruption is indeed a potential issue, and we should focus on ways to e.g. root out peer review rings. But the numbers we're talking about are tiny.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @06:52AM (#43170769)
What you are describing is by definition an oligarchy.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by architango on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:25PM (#43167360)
If you require taxpayers to consent to every single line item, voting is going to become rather cumbersome.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:29PM (#43167388)
Maybe it would be a huge improvement if the federal government spending our money (taken without consent; every constituent who voted for every representative who ratified the 16th amendment is now dead) becomes substantially more cumbersome.

Perhaps we could then focus on spending money on things with broad popular support. If you’re going to have taxes they should serve the people doing the paying. It seems to me this is obvious.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by rights_reminder on Monday February 24, 2025 @11:11PM (#43168091)
I will bring this up every time someone mentions this, but your money is not being taken without consent. You are signing tax forms without knowing what they mean in law and voluntarily (incorrectly) giving it to them. Income taxes are excise taxes.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by digitaltrees on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:59PM (#43168017)
You can migrate and renounce citizenship. Staying and benefiting from the spending is tacit consent no?
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @06:48AM (#43170739)
There is no such thing as tacit consent.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by acdha on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @07:24AM (#43170980)
The fact that there’s a term for it which we all know suggests otherwise. It’s literally in textbooks, too, so you’d have a better argument if you explained your conceptual disagreement rather than trying to pretend the concept doesn’t exist.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by inejge on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @07:41AM (#43171120)
taken without consent; every constituent who voted for every representative who ratified the 16th amendment is now dead

Isn't it nice when you get nerd sniped by complete nonsense? I wanted to see what amendments would get invalidated using the quoted line of reasoning, aside from the whole Bill of Rights. Using the date of ratification from Wikipedia and subtracting the voting age at the time gives you the absolute lower limit of the age of any voting constituent:

    Am  Ratified    VA  Latest BD   Age
    -----------------------------------
     1  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     2  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     3  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     4  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     5  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     6  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     7  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     8  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     9  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
    10  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
    11  02/07/1795  21  02/07/1774  251
    12  06/15/1804  21  06/15/1783  241
    13  12/06/1865  21  12/06/1844  180
    14  07/09/1868  21  07/09/1847  177
    15  02/03/1870  21  02/03/1849  176
    16  02/03/1913  21  02/03/1892  133
    17  04/08/1913  21  04/08/1892  132
    18  01/16/1919  21  01/16/1898  127
    19  08/18/1920  21  08/18/1899  125
    20  01/23/1933  21  01/23/1912  113
    21  12/05/1933  21  12/05/1912  112
    22  02/27/1951  21  02/27/1930   95
    23  03/29/1961  21  03/29/1940   84
    24  01/23/1964  21  01/23/1943   82
    25  02/10/1967  21  02/10/1946   79
    26  07/01/1971  21  07/01/1950   74
    27  05/07/1992  18  05/07/1974   50
Using the SSA cutoff date of 115 years, we see that the 20th and the 21st are a bit iffy, which isn't so bad because the 21st is the repeal of the 18th, and the 20th is a bit technical, but: women's suffrage is kaput! Slavery is OK again! Senators are to be appointed! Etc. At least term limits still apply, whew.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by 8note on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:57PM (#43167563)
but the spending was all set by democratic process where citizen's representatives set the spending in their constituents interests.

instead, now that value is being taken away from me without consent, and im goinf to be forced to spend more somewhere else in my life to make up for it, without the actual consent of it going through votes and discussion in congress

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by dsr_ on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:30PM (#43167393)
You don't believe that, or you would have moved to be out from under this ultimate tyranny. Somalia, perhaps.

Your argument is the classic Randist Libertarian one: "There is no such thing as society, everything I did I earned myself with no reference to anyone." It is, of course, complete and utter garbage. Government spending is the only known way of constructing projects that are not attractive money-makers: rural electrification, communications systems, roads, water treatment, education. In order to keep currency flowing, governments remove it from circulation via taxation.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:32PM (#43167413)
This violates consent, though. Consent matters, regardless of how much handwaving occurs after people choose to violate it.

The other such places you describe also violate consent. Same criminal acts: coercion by violence.

I do indeed believe in the things I have said, and I have indeed emigrated from the United States for many such reasons, principally among them my objection to being forced to fund neverending war.

Unfortunately the US Government still taxes me remotely.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by warkdarrior on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:56PM (#43167551)
You can renounce your US citizenship and thus avoid the burden of US taxation.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by daveguy on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:39PM (#43167882)
Yes, please do this GP. Renounce your citizenship and be free of the big bad taxes. Most of us prefer infrastructure and long term public research.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by condorwhilhem on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:01PM (#43167596)
Eh, consent is a little nebulous in this context. Sure in interpersonal relationships, consent is important. But on a societal scale there are plenty of ways in which consent is violated. I don't consent to breathing toxic fumes from other people's cars. Should we make cars illegal? I don't consent to having to wear clothes all the time, is it unethical that I have to wear clothes?

Also, the money they are taking is produced by and guaranteed by the US government. Is it really "your" money? Without the US government that money is worthless.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by hayst4ck on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @04:44PM (#43177898)
The tragedy of the commons... Telling any particular fisherman not to fish the fish to extinction also violates their consent.

Coercion is necessary for governance and you wouldn't want to live in a world without it. The Thief who steals money with a knife doesn't consent to jail time. If the government doesn't levy taxes to pay for policing, then there is no way to punish the theif for violation of the victims consent.

Your unthought out opinion is a position of privilege, not one of reason or sanity.

That doesn't even broach the topic of a child being born into poverty or slavery.

Without a military force, funded by taxes, to defend against neighboring slavers your notion of consent doesn't matter in the first place. That's the fundamental contradiction of anarchy.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by digitaltrees on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:55PM (#43167989)
Congress passed laws allocating the spending. That by definition is consent.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by sneak on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @06:50AM (#43170760)
They did this without my involvement. Furthermore, the amendment that they claim permits them to steal your money was ratified by representatives who were elected by no people alive today.

The current population had no say whatsoever in these laws. They were born into it like being born into slavery.

There is no “unsubscribe”.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by digitaltrees on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @04:45PM (#43177912)
You want all laws to be renewed each generation? Fine, how do you set the renewal date? What about the transition from one law to another? My point is there will always be someone that is subject to a law that was passed prior to them being of the age of consent for a particular law. No serious political theory defines the legitimacy of a law by 100% explicit consent by the governed. Instead the consent given is a broad transfer of the right to govern generally. That’s all that is necessary. I don’t need to consent to everything the police do to protect public safety if I have consented to their general mission.
Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by 0xbadcafebee on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:26PM (#43167783)
> Why should government subsidies exist in general?

Bro... I think you missed the civics class where they explain how economies/governments work.

tl;dr the magical free market isn't, the world is complicated, and governments are supposed to help their people, which includes providing things, like money, to do things, like advance the state of the civilization, its people, its businesses, products, services, technologies, defenses, education, health, food, energy, etc etc etc etc etc

> Why is everyone acting like the sky is falling when an elected official does the things people voted for them to do?

Two words: National Socialism. Sometimes the people are morons, and the leaders psychopaths.

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by 01HNNWZ0MV43FF on Monday February 24, 2025 @09:42PM (#43167476)
Are you happy that trans prisoners, like DeviantOllam's friend Kara*, might be moved into men's prisons where they'll be raped and assaulted constantly?

*Put into prison for non-violent research, as I understand it.

If you support prison rape in general, do you consider yourself a good person?

If you think it's worth it to save yourself some money, do you consider yourself a good person?

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by edward28 on Monday February 24, 2025 @10:17PM (#43167706)
Is this the same Kara as Kara Sternquist the convicted felon charged with "possession of fraudulent badges and credentials for federal agencies" and when their house was searched multiple firearms were found including two fully automatic rifles? [0][1]

[0] https://casetext.com/case/united-states-v-sternquist

[1] https://www.motherjones.com/criminal-justice/2023/01/mdc-bro...

Re:Everyone at NSF overseeing the Platforms for Wireless Exp... by insane_dreamer on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @07:00PM (#43179067)
Gov subsidies of research is one of the smartest public investments because it drives growth in new areas, ultimately opening up new companies/jobs, and allowing the country to keep pace with, or lead, competitors who will otherwise capture that market. Or the research improves medical care which improves the quality of life of citizens.

If you really want to reduce government subsidies, start with the defense industry, which is fully funded by your tax dollars. And it really accomplishes very little for the country, other than the scientific research it funds (which is actually substantial and which often results in breakthroughs with non-military applications).