All things should exist in reasonable degrees. Arrests and blocks are legitimate tools that should be used to keep people safe, but their use should be accountable and subject to due criticism. You can't weasel out of absolutism by overloading alternative solutions unless you also explain why such tools are meaningfully different.
One of my controversial opinions is that I think the Tor network strikes a good balance. Occasional vulnerabilities and raids keep those perpetuating the most severe long-term abuse on their toes, while the scarcity of such exploits facilitates the short-term censorship resistance necessary to serve as a backup for censored communications during political turbulence.
Blocking can shape a whole society.
Also, arrest is the appropriate tool to stop something bad from happening, rather than just hiding it.
(And to be clear, this is all about things that a government is restricting, which should be few and far between. Private sites can block whatever users they wish.)
It is a heavier tool, but it's also a more severe tool, I'm not sure I understand this objection.
Blocks and arrests both serve to reduce the occurrence of bad things because bad things require delivery and arrests take time and are sometimes not possible. Disbanding the drug cartels in Brazil and Mexico would be the best solution to the flow of drugs into the U.S, but that's hard and even at best will take a long time, so in the meantime countries settle for trying to stop drugs at the border instead. The response to overseas distribution of child pornography should be similar.
(To be clear, I do also think it's important to go track down the sites hosting such content and take down the sites. But at the source, not blocking at the border, which is a capability that shouldn't exist.)
Also, at the risk of unrelated political commentary:
> Disbanding the drug cartels in Brazil and Mexico would be the best solution to the flow of drugs into the U.S,
Legalization would be the best solution to the association between drugs and organized crime.
I don't think you've justified that objection any other way than saying "stopping it at the source would be better" (which is unambiguously agreeable).
Teaching a man to fish is obviously better than just giving him a fish, but if tuition is not possible due to resource constraints, a fish distribution system isn't a terrible idea.
On the contrary, it would be an excellent outcome if the Internet became all-or-nothing, and countries could either choose to provide Internet access or block the entire Internet, with zero ability to selectively block things they don't like.
Doing that via a few centralized CDNs would be bad. Doing that at the protocol level would be excellent.