It is for the some "leader". The vast large tech industry is filled with phony leaders who don't understand how the job is done and what makes the doers tick.
But they occupy the place of "leadership". They must be seen as doing something. So they are doing the something that they can - scream at people in a locked room.
If they could actually solve technical problems or talk to their bosses like a real engineering leader, they would. But they literally are incapable of doing so.
So war rooms and BS performative art it is.
If it's your first time, then yeah, you will probably handle it like a dick (or twat). You gotta take on an ancient role with humility.
Exactly. It’s so the leader can ask “do we have an update?” every 10 minutes when nothing has changed.
I once walked out of a war room (at a much smaller company that I wouldn't be at for much longer) that had devolved into finger-pointing and blame games. Half an hour later, my boss came out to find out what I was doing and I pointed at my screen and said, "This. This is what's wrong. Ship my fix and we're done here." The entire war room came to my desk to see and discuss the fix, which we shipped, which solved the issue.
At my next job, I had to hold back laughter when the VP of Engineering, who was pushing mob programming, said, "Think about it. When we have an incident, when something is really important, what do we do? We all get in a room together. No one leaves the war room to go solve the incident on their own."
Lol. This is not hyperbole. Just about everyone has several stories like this, and they are quite hilarious in their utter absurdity. It's like these people get possessed by the spirit of Gordon Gekko in that exact moment and must absolutely play out the role to the tee. Then they become unpossessed and go Skiing on weekends.
Like, literally, an effective way to sell to them is to make them feel like they’re in a movie doing Super Important Things. LOL. Executive Disneyland.
I’m hoping you find SOME leaders who can find a more effective way to convey this priority!
Theoretically in our “data driven” leadership you could think of some metrics that would demonstrate the war room is / is not really working. At least after the fact, to save you from the next one.
Who feels like a powerful leader in those circumstances, though?
On the other hand, it feels good to me to be able to tell people I’m not involved at that level of detail, and they should just talk to X on the team.
If you can invent a strategy that produces even better MTTR than war rooms, I'm sure a lot of managers would love to hear it. I've never seen one and I'm skeptical whether it's possible.
How can you run numbers to find out what would have happened?
Not Meta but at Amazon I always felt like war rooms are a place for some leader to scream at you and not much else. The reality is that debugging some retry storm, resource exhaustion or whatever won't happen in a room with 18 people talking over one another.
Give me a meeting link, I'll join and provide info as I find it, but this type of sweaty hackathon-style all-hands-on-deck was never productive for me.