News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by forrestthewoods on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:33PM (#43145808)
59% is borderline criminal. Perhaps 15% is too low. But 59% is absurd and unacceptable.
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by linksnapzz on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:49PM (#43145921)
The Salk Institute's overhead rate, IIRC, is 90%. Yet, they keep getting funds, so they're doing something right.
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by forrestthewoods on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:20PM (#43146140)
Fraudulent orgs also keep getting funds. That don’t make it right.
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by johnnyanmac on Sunday February 23, 2025 @01:05AM (#43147070)
So, what's the fraud? I'm a bit tired of that word as of late as some kind of catch-all for "I don't understand how this works and I don't like it".
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by forrestthewoods on Sunday February 23, 2025 @01:17AM (#43147139)
I’m not accusing any particular organization of fraud. I am rejecting the notion that just because one institution historically receives funds that those funds were put to good use.

I understand how grants and overhead rates work. It’s an embarrassment.

Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by johnnyanmac on Sunday February 23, 2025 @02:25AM (#43147435)
"you're not literally saying fraud, but you're also not NOT saying it's fraud"

Serious accusations need serious evidence. I'm not a fan of this sowing of doubt without a solid basis to back it up. That's very much the DOGE modus operandi, and it's a lazy and dangerous form of argumentation. I'll call it out wherever I can.

You're just saying "thing bad" and expecting agreement without putting any legwork in. The onus is on the accuser, not the accused.

Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by forrestthewoods on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:10AM (#43147641)
> The Salk Institute's overhead rate, IIRC, is 90%. Yet, they keep getting funds, so they're doing something right.

I do not agree with this statement. Take from that what you will.

> The onus is on the accuser, not the accused.

In criminal law I agree. When it comes to budgeting I do not. The onus is on every program to prove every year that they’re worth funding. I don’t accept the notion that just because something was funded in the past that it was wise then and that it’s wise to continue to fund.

So when someone says “this org has a 90% indirect cost rate and keeps getting funded” I do not think “they must be doing something right”. I instead think “wow they better have a frickin spectacular argument as to how that is possibly justifiable, and I’d bet $3.50 they don’t”.

Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by wredcoll on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:49PM (#43155363)
And yet in all your replies you've yet to make an actual substantial point. All you said was "I think this is bad and they should prove they aren't".

Find something real to criticize and do it with actual facts.

Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by forrestthewoods on Tuesday February 25, 2025 @03:43AM (#43169570)
lol
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by aaronharnly on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:09PM (#43146059)
It’s worth clarifying that the 59% overhead rate doesnt mean 59% of the funds go to overhead. If you have a $1m grant, you add on $590k for overhead. Then the total grant is $1.59m, so actually 37% of the total funds are for overhead.
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by cute_boi on Saturday February 22, 2025 @09:40PM (#43145850)
FYI, Overhead don't include everything. Even in remaining 49% there are many overheads :)
Re:U Pittsburgh pauses all PhD admissions amid DOGE funding ... by MITSardine on Sunday February 23, 2025 @06:00PM (#43154067)
I'm curious, why do you find this so high?

Take the army for example, it's estimated 30~40% of the workforce is dedicated to logistics. This is equivalent to 42~66% overhead (in the same sense that overhead is discussed in the context of academia, as +% cost) if you were to count only combat personnel as the direct costs.

This is was universities do, they only count research expenses as the direct costs. Yet it's quite obvious a university can't run just on scientists.

This 59% overhead is equivalent to 37% of the expenses. So, unlike you, I'm positively surprised that 63% of expenses go directly to the core mission with only 37% "waste" (which is necessary to ensure the scientists can actually work, and work efficiently).