News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surface-Stable Fractal Dither on Playdate by montag on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:36AM (#43138111)
This is a cool novel technique for sure, but for some reason I’m just not aesthetically in love with it. The fact that the pattern is surface aligned just…doesn’t add anything over dithering in screen space. And I really loved the dithering in Return of Obra Dinn. Is it just me?
Re:Surface-Stable Fractal Dither on Playdate by chpatrick on Saturday February 22, 2025 @06:40AM (#43138123)
I agree with you, it's technically very cool but Obra Dinn just looks better.
Re:Surface-Stable Fractal Dither on Playdate by turnsout on Saturday February 22, 2025 @10:47AM (#43139996)
Thought the same thing when the original Surface-Stable dither link made the rounds. There's just something off about 1-bit dither with perspective applied, but constantly shifting scale on different parts of the model.

Super interesting thought experiment (and this version is an impressive exercise in optimization), but the aesthetic of Obra Dinn is in another league.

Re:Surface-Stable Fractal Dither on Playdate by Veedrac on Saturday February 22, 2025 @07:50PM (#43145022)
The author of the technique has an explanation of why screen-alined dithering is hard in their FAQ. https://github.com/runevision/Dither3D/discussions/12

Particular, it's hard to deal with anisotropy, and naive approaches to fix this hurt either break the operation as a dither with uniform dot sizes, or struggle to avoid becoming regular at angles.

I agree with the claim, though, that you lose quite a lot by having the dither pattern stuck to surfaces. There is a charm to it for sure, but a high quality screen space dither would be cool. And so I experimented with some ideas and came up with one. Forgive the jank, I'm learning as I go.

https://www.shadertoy.com/view/WfBGzK

Note that this is using a random dither versus a patterned one, which I think hurts the aesthetics a lot, but I am certain this is incidental to the concept. I think there are probably much smarter techniques, and I have an idea for a large rewrite already, but those are details, just take this as a proof of concept.