This is a red herring. Distros existed before semantic versioning was defined and had to deal with those issues for ages. When packaging, you check for the behaviour changes in the package and its dependencies. The version numbers are a tiny indicator, but mostly meaningless.
To me it seems more attractive than how Nix does it, but I guess they considered such and saw conflicts, therefore went with hashes.
Recently in the python ecosystem the `uv` package manager let's you install a package as it was on a certain date. Additionally, you can "freeze" your dependencies to a certain date in pyproject.toml. So when someone clones it and installs dependencies it will install it at the date you've chosen to freeze it at.
Personally I love this method much more than versioning.
I think versioning is mostly useful to just talk about software and maybe major major additions/changes e.g io-uring shipping with linux mainline.
Yeah, but the package maintainer for a widely used library doesn't actually have the resources to do this. (heck, a package maintainer for a non-trivial application likely doesn't have the resources to do this). Basically they update and hope to get some bug reports from users.
So it is complicated and there is no solution for every context, therefore we use best approximation.
I don't believe that it causes more problems than it fixes. It's just that you didn't notice the problems being silently fixed!
There are issues related to different distros packaging different versions of libraries. But that's just an issue with trying to support different distros and/or their updates. There are tradeoffs with everything. Dynamic linking is more appropriate for things that are part of a distro, because it creates less turnover of packages when things update.
Now a lot of stuff is contnuously buggified so there is no concept of stable and in-progress.
This was the biggest pain point in deploying *application software* on Linux though. Distributions with different release cycles providing different versions of various libraries and expect your program to work with all of those combinations. The Big famous libraries like Qt , gtk might follow proper versioning but the smaller libraries from distro packages - guarantee. Half of them don't even use semantic versioning.
Imagine distros swapping out the libraries you've actually tested out your code with with their libraries for "security fixes" or whatever the reason. That causes more problems than it fixes.
Custom start up script was to find the same xml library I've used in the tar ball i packaged the application in. They could then extract that tar ball wherever they need - including /opt and run the script to start my application and it ran as it should. Iirc we used to even use rpath for this.