Isn't delegating a zone pretty much the same concept in DNS? Or am I missing sarcasm here?
Yeah was sarcasm as it seems to be a really obvious thing to do.
We do it in the UK with <councilname>.gov.uk
(Not sure if it's actual delegation or just A records though)
We also do it in the US, although I feel like it was more common 20-years ago than it is now. For example, here in North Carolina, local school systems are typically “https://[county name]schools.k12.nc.us”
Yeah, our state did that kind of thing 20 years ago, but people get confused with more than x.y, because nobody ever taught anyone the concept that domains are a hierarchy and that periods have a specific role that’s different to slashes, hyphens, etc. So to 90% of people they couldn’t explain how “order.TacoBell.com” is different than “TacoBell.order.com” and as such wouldn’t ever remember what order “k12” “nc” and “us” might go in.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by 6LLvveMx2koXfwn on Friday February 21, 2025 @11:15PM
(#43136043)
Indeed, because the hierarchical nature of addressing conventions is a new thing.
Not sure if sarcastic or not. I think most people don’t think of a URL as an address in the way that a building has an address with a strict hierarchy of meaningful parts. I think people think of it more as an atomic long string of characters that the person who made the site labeled it with just by being the first to claim a certain URL.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by miki123211 on Friday February 21, 2025 @05:44PM
(#43133984)
You still have the "email can't get to Essex or Sussex" problem though.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by paulddraper on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:30PM
(#43131118)
Sarcasm.
People get confused (particularly in the US) if they are always used to x.y.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by ChadNauseam on Friday February 21, 2025 @02:25PM
(#43131779)
I like fully qualifying domain names (like x.y. in your example) and it’s funny how many sites break when you do this
Re:Every .gov Domain
by amingilani on Friday February 21, 2025 @07:48PM
(#43134918)
Wait, really? Could you share some examples? Why would they break for a FQDN. Wouldn’t that mean that the root servers aren’t configured correctly for that TLD?
Re:Every .gov Domain
by ChadNauseam on Saturday February 22, 2025 @12:03AM
(#43136269)
I'm not sure exactly why things break, but as an example: fully-qualifying youtube.com (to youtube.com.) used to break the code that displayed the ads and you could watch ad-free
It is. As an example:
In practice, people get confused by that.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by mikepurvis on Friday February 21, 2025 @09:09PM
(#43135390)
We have that in Ontario and honestly it's often just kind of a source of confusion, like this is for a specific agency overseeing just the St Lawrence:
Whereas the actual Ontario Parks website is this:
Only a marginal improvement though