Re:Every .gov Domain
by EvanAnderson on Friday February 21, 2025 @10:49AM
(#43128875)
Oh, I agree. It's logically guessable and the right hierarchy. It'd also never fly. >smile<
> So far as I am aware, every US state is split into counties...
re: falsehoods - Alaska has no counties. Louisiana has "Parishes". Connecticut and Rhode Island have counties but no county governments. Also, see Townships.
> Connecticut and Rhode Island have counties but no county governments
This breaks my brain.
And even where everything seems the same on paper, different states can handle things wildly differently.
Some the counties run almost everything except where a large city is, some the county does almost nothing, and everything is tied to whatever the biggest town is.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by saalweachter on Friday February 21, 2025 @11:07AM
(#43129126)
I'm always a little bit angry that New York calls Townships Towns.
All of these are tiny exceptions compared to the vast number of counties within US States. However, reality is made of exceptions! All things considered, it is interesting and important to have local exceptions in a nation IMHO.
Virginia is another edge case here, where cities aren't part of counties and are directly under the state. If you look at a map, you'll see holes in a bunch of counties where the cities are, e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_and_counties_...
Sometimes I think our country would be better understood as 50-something separate countries, kind of like the EU, except without the general goal the EU has of increasing amounts of cooperation and convergence. Since in America, everything that’s different from one place to another is generally different because somebody very influential wants it to be. As programmers I feel like all this inconsistency drives us crazy because it seems pointless, but as a citizen, I can see how it would be a tremendous waste of effort to try to force national standardization merely for standardization’s sake when we have so many real problems that need to be addressed.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by saalweachter on Friday February 21, 2025 @11:06AM
(#43129110)
New York spans five counties, which lack county governments, instead having borough governments subordinate to the city government.
Washington, DC is a city which is in neither a state nor a county.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._municipalities_... has a hundred or so cities that span counties.
it turns out, cities are among the least well-defined geographical features in local government of the USA. There are many odd and unusual arrangements at the city level. The US Census maintains a collection of more clearly defined entities.
Re:Every .gov Domain
by dragonwriter on Friday February 21, 2025 @07:18PM
(#43134773)
I can think of lots of exceptions to the part about substate public entities existing within counties; CA, for instance, has quite a number of JPAs and similar entities that involve multiple counties, or entities from multiple counties, for some purpose; e.g., The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California, the Bay Area Rapid Transit District, etc.
Maybe there should be a “falsehoods programmers believe about government structure” article, but I can think of very few exceptions.
“cleveland.cuyahoga.ohio.gov” seems like a logically guessable domain.