News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by abeppu on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:05PM (#43121640)
Except:

- Even in the best of cases, if this is your approach, you need a plan for how to add back the stuff that you learn is critical. DOGE haven't demonstrated that minimal level of competence. Firing National Nuclear Security Administration staff and cutting them off from their work emails meant that when those staff were quickly discovered to be critical, it wasn't possible to quickly bring them back. This is amateurish.

- But further, this principle works with designing rockets because you expect to build multiple rockets during the development process, and failing on one rocket doesn't destroy your ability to iterate. You don't do this with a rocket if you're in the rocket. If we crash the US economy or start a war, we impair our ability to just pick up the pieces and carry on as before.

- And this works with something like rockets b/c no one is actively trying to blow up your rocket, or take advantage of its weaknesses. The US has adversaries, and the current administration is destabilizing agencies in a pretty public way which those adversaries may take advantage of. A crappy way to discover that the NNSA is critical would be if, e.g. some reduction in global monitoring meant that we didn't notice some movement of fissile material to countries we aren't friends with, etc.

Maybe the tactics that work at Tesla and SpaceX aren't universally applicable and governing requires at least a somewhat different approach?

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by rainsford on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:16PM (#43122406)
It's even worse than you point out. DOGE/Musk/whoever is really in charge didn't learn the NNSA staff was critical because the firings cause some immediate impact. Someone who actually knows what they're talking about likely told them about the problems it would cause and the firing squad actually listened. Had they relied on waiting for side effects to understand the impact, it would be far, far too late when you're talking about something like nuclear weapons.

In other words, not only is the strategy wildly likely to result in you learning things are critical years past the point of no return when talking about functions like nuclear weapons, it was completely pointless in this particular case. They didn't learn anything they couldn't have learned beforehand, but did manage to piss off a ton of people with critical skills who are likely looking for the exit now if they even came back at all.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by digitaltrees on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:34PM (#43121957)
So much this. Excellent points. Government is a unique organization with a unique purpose.

We are indeed in the rocket so maybe the minimum effectiveness for safety isn’t how we should evaluate the situation.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by alaithea on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:12PM (#43121717)
> It’s the same with firing people and hiring them back. Performance metrics are unreliable, but firing and then hiring back who you miss isn’t. It shows you who is really critical.

No, it's not. They're not running a test to see who is missed, they are realizing they've made a huge mistake and fired the people who look after the nukes and the people looking into bird flu. Knowing whose job is important doesn't require leaving nukes unattended or bird flu to run rampant.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by fn-mote on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:02PM (#43121602)
> firing and then hiring back who you miss isn’t

Once you fire me, I'm not coming back.

Being hired into a known-unstable situation needs to involve a lot more cash than a stable-for-decades one. Is the assumption you're making that there will be no other market to absorb the employees? The ones who remain available will be the ones unable to find work elsewhere.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by blitzar on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:05PM (#43121642)
> Once you fire me, I'm not coming back.

I am, my salary is now higher. Much higher. And I no longer give a f' about the TPS report.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by ziml77 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:12PM (#43121709)
Nice and efficient. Get the same work for more money.

Actually maybe less work for more money because the employee now knows how vital they are but at the same time knows you don't give a shit about them so why should they care more than they have to about you.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by shriek on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:11PM (#43121694)
Yep. They've made a decision to pay premium price for your service so you know you're worth more now.
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by scarab92 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:16PM (#43121753)
What you’re saying only really applies to mid level people.

Truly talented people consistently gravitate toward organisations that are the best at eliminating underperformers and waste, because it results in a high throughput, high trust environment which is empowering.

It’s why Musk’s companies consistently have the highest talent levels in their respective industries. He eliminates the bs which allows ambitious and capable people to thrive.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by digitaltrees on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:30PM (#43121909)
The functions of government are not like a start up or company. Getting these things wrong isn’t like a rocket crash or twitter going down. The government provides society scale services, and interruptions can trigger contagion. Doge stoping insurance payments to providers has already resulted in companies going out of business. There will be hospitals in rural communities that shut down, and the job losses will close gas stations and grocery stores and collapse housing prices. These things cascade.

They fired FAA staff (that was already understaffed) and plane crashes are increasing. I have several friends that have stopped flying due to distrust of the safety.

They fired the Department of Energy staff than monitors and prevents the international trade of nuclear materials and weapons. Do we really have the luxury of getting that wrong by running an experiment to see “what’s the minimum staff necessary”? Seems like a dumb cost benefit calculation.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by akmiller on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:00PM (#43121569)
> but firing and then hiring back who you miss isn’t. It shows you who is really critical.

Maybe for companies (although I'd argue it's extremely bad there as well), but for Governments this is a terrible idea!

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by tomtomtom777 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:08PM (#43121674)
From a profit maximization maybe.

But the government employs people. And in most of the civilized world, employing people comes with responsibilities over those people. For starters, the responsibility of not firing or changing terms that effects them on whim just for the sake of efficiency.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by fatbird on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:56PM (#43121520)
Anyone with experience in a large org will hate this because it's a stupid, hamhanded way of forcing people to continually beg for the resources to do their jobs. Leaders think it's brilliant because it relieves them of the need to know what's actually going on in their organization, externalizing their responsibilities.

"Unplug it and see who screams" is not effective systems management.

People aren't rockets.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by tobias3 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:08PM (#43121671)
Especially once people stop caring about things actually working and go into CYA mode (stop begging).

"We wrote the memo that we don't have enough peope to check drinking water toxidity, guess leadership is okay with not testing for that anymore"

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by scarab92 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:07PM (#43121656)
Organisations are like rockets, with lots of complex moving parts, lots of uncertainly about performance, and lots of decisions made out of conservative thinking.

Stopping things by default, and then fixing what is worth fixing, cuts through all of that organisational inertia. It’s a ground up, zero based model, that allows you to quickly assess what is actually important rather than guessing.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by fatbird on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:18PM (#43121779)
Organizational inertia can be cut through without causing a tremendous amount of pain and disruption. Stopping things by default is a very lazy way to do it. Doing it this way is a strongman fantasy that inflicts large costs: now your employees aren't doing their jobs, they're going through a round of "justify yourself" (when you should have had the organizational controls in place already).

And there's nothing new about this strategy, either. I read about these tactics decades ago in management self-help books. They were just as crappy and inhuman then as now.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by brazzy on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:17PM (#43121763)
It mainly allows you to quickly destroy your organization's ability to do anything, including repairing the damage you just did.

Which is, of course the goal: to destroy the United States. They already explicitly said that's the goal.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by mac-attack on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:07PM (#43121662)
I agree and would add that people aren't machines either. The concept of 'fire everyone and rehire who is essential' seems to lack comprehension of human psychology. It seems analogous to 'cheat on everyone and marry the person who stays' in that you are settling for the people who have the least self-respect and/or the least amount of options outside of their current position.
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by scarab92 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:11PM (#43121703)
How do you square your theory with the fact that Musk’s companies consistently have the highest talent levels in their industry.
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by m4rtink on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:28PM (#43121884)
Are there some objective data for this ?

Rather I am seeing a lot of new companies and startups by ex-SpaceX people for example.

Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by throw16180339 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:37PM (#43121988)
Your repeating this all over the thread doesn't make it so.
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by fatbird on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:28PM (#43121891)
How often do Tesla or SpaceX fire and rehire only the essential people?
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by ModernMech on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:09PM (#43123252)
How do you square that "fact" with the CyberTruck?
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by brazzy on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:12PM (#43121713)
It's the exact opposite of "brilliant", it's extremely stupid and destructive. It shows they are absolutely incompetent at what they do and have zero understanding or even desire to understand how things work.
Re:DOGE Puts $1 Spending Limit on Government Employee Credit... by wilg on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:58PM (#43121550)
The issue is the goal with SpaceX is clear and something cool, whereas the Trump administration's goals are vile and DOGE's goals are at best unclear but probably just the same as Trump.

An aggressive anti-waste campaign would be more believable if it wasn't coming from an administration vowing to destroy the federal government and openly subverting the Constitution, led by a man who gets his political views from neo-Nazis that tweet at him.