News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by danpalmer on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:26AM (#43116678)
This is a sad outcome. The Bond franchise is very strong, and that’s in large part to a single coherent vision of who the character is.

Bond is in need of some modernisation perhaps, but that still needs the strong creative control. The bean counters at Amazon aren’t that, and it shows in every Amazon studios production (and in most Netflix productions too), they’re too caught up in the numbers, the marketability, ticking boxes for target audiences, that the content is soulless.

I hope Bond survives.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by marinmania on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:07PM (#43117262)
I am not the biggest Bond fan so feel free to ignore my opinion, but it seems possible that Amazon is less of a bean counter than a traditional studio? They will throw money at the first production - with the hopes it is a hit. They are not beholden to it being profitable on paper like a studio would be.

But I also realize they took this approach to Lord of the Rings, and it didn't turn out.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by danpalmer on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:23PM (#43117524)
This may be true, but Bond hasn't been owned by a traditional studio, it has essentially been owned by a family who have inherited control down a few generations.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by bl4kers on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:40AM (#43116854)
The literary version is already public domain in many countries
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by geodel on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:57AM (#43117130)
All Bonds are marketing phenomena. Amazon Prime Bond will be no different. Good time to try new brands for guns, watches, cars, gadgets and so on.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by brickfaced on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:08PM (#43117277)
This is a very sad and soulless way to view Bond's story.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by geodel on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:46PM (#43117830)
At the end of day Bond movies, Star wars saga, Jazz music, many sports culture or even Apple gadgets are great successfully marketed products. Now some people do take it as way of life and are deep into it, for them, it is not just some product. But for lot others these are just a type of movies, music, sports etc.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by brickfaced on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:12PM (#43120263)
I hope you're never in charge of anything in which other people find meaning and community.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by milleramp on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:01PM (#43117170)
I wonder if they will shift production away from Pinewood Studios?
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by esskay on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:10PM (#43117338)
Unlikely, Amazon's already got a long term contract in place with the pinewod group for facilities extending beyond Bond. The actual bond stage is owned by Pinewood and used for lots of different productions however Eon were always given priorty access (again contractually).

You don't really drop contracts like that in the UK, especially right now when theres a shortage of production space due to Amazon, Disney, Netflix, Sky, etc all fighting for access.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by echelon on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:52AM (#43117046)
Amazon needs to be broken up. They are a web host, e-commerce giant, consumer electronics company, grocery store, primary care doctor, and movie studio. That is so wildly fucked.

These companies are entering into entirely new markets, destroying the value, giving it away for free, all subsidized by unrelated business unit profit.

One of the core reasons why Hollywood is floundering is because tech giants are doing this.

Why don't we do trust busting anymore?

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by mainecoder on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:06PM (#43117260)
let them let the customers choose also it allows them to amass substantial capital that can then be spent on R & D that maintains the lead of the US in some areas, as a multinational there is a lot of money coming from other countries that is beneficial to the U.S.. If China is the only country where MegaCorps, then it would be hard for segmented U.S. firms to compete with them
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by zht on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:55AM (#43117098)
we barely do democracy anymore
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:39PM (#43117738)
Hollywood is floundering because:

- there's no secondary market for VHS & DVD anymore. Almost all the money has to be made on opening weekend

- in recent years, content has become preachy instead of focusing on being entertaining

Netflix & Amazon movies are ultra-low quality; you couldn't pay me to watch it. A quality Hollywood production that was made to entertain instead of persuade can still easily outcompete tech company movies

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by danpalmer on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:34PM (#43122583)
> in recent years, content has become preachy instead of focusing on being entertaining

I'm not sure I feel this? From my perspective, the Marvel films feel like a counter example, where they only care about the "entertainment" (arguably the opening weekend!), and there's no lasting quality to them. Each one individually is a reasonable way to pass 2 hours, but they feel like junk food films, I don't feel better for having watched them.

The alternative is things like A24's output, which one may call "preachy", but while I might not enjoy them in the same way as turning my mind off in front of Avengers 8: Avenge Harder-er, they have a much bigger impact on my life and satisfy me much more as a viewer.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:56AM (#43124789)
Having a diverse cast and talking about things that used to be taboo is not being preachy.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Friday February 21, 2025 @08:08AM (#43126993)
Call it what you will but doing the above for reasons of “representation” or “education” rather than entertainment is simply not a fun experience for anyone, even the self-righteous people making those films.

A business needs a laser focus on how it adds value to its customers or it’ll die.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @10:32AM (#43128617)
> doing the above for reasons of “representation” or “education” rather than entertainment

That's basically never the case. People assume it is because they don't like seeing a diverse cast and come up with that excuse.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:30PM (#43131111)
You may very well think that and keep going to the movies, but a large segment of the population sees this as explicit and implicit criticism of aspects that are integral to themselves (white skin, a Y chromosome, conservative beliefs) and won't watch anymore.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @06:02PM (#43134172)
Those people are part of the problem and best left behind IMO.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Friday February 21, 2025 @06:18PM (#43134305)
Learn nothing and you'll keep losing. You'll never leave 40-60% of the population "behind" (who are you to define "the problem"? What's next, "the solution"? Chilling and revealing language) and it's outrageous this notion ever occurred to you in the first place.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @07:58PM (#43134983)
There was only progress. The only people who were losing were lowkey bigots in denial who can't handle change. Bigots might be in charge for the next 4 years, but the pendulum will swing much more forcefully in the opposite direction as a result for the subsequent 8 years. The march of progress is inevitable.

I won't be engaging with you again after this due to your views.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Friday February 21, 2025 @08:01PM (#43134996)
> Learn nothing and you'll keep losing
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Saturday February 22, 2025 @01:01AM (#43136480)
Nah. Keep being bigoted and you'll be left behind.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by jfengel on Friday February 21, 2025 @02:53PM (#43132148)
How much is the secondary market for streaming? When Netflix picks up a major studio release, how much do they pay? Or if it's available on Youtube/Amazon, how much do they make on that?

(All of this is made weirder by the fact that half of the biggest movies every year come out of Disney and go straight to its own service.)

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by FredPret on Friday February 21, 2025 @07:40PM (#43134884)
Here's Matt Damon explaining the economics of the evolution from VHS -> DVD -> piracy.

He doesn't directly address how much Netflix pays for rights, but presumably the answer is "not enough".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jx8F5Imd8A8

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kmeisthax on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:59PM (#43119391)
We did. In fact, some of the Biden-era antitrust lawsuits are still active, AFAIK. What happened is that the capital class acted swiftly and firmly to shut down the FTC (and SEC), by brown-nosing Trump[0], so that the federal government couldn't challenge them.

The word "deep state" gets thrown around a lot here, especially by the people who thought Trump was going to stop this bullshit, but it's useful to describe what's going on: the accumulation of informal power structures that render the formal, legitimate one ineffective. Hollywood was part of the last iteration of the deep state; but they are being gradually pushed out of it, both because they are on Trump's enemies list and because tech centralizes power and control far faster than artistic industry does. In other words, Hollywood is no longer useful and is being replaced with something worse.

[0] To be clear, about half the DNC was hoping a judge would block Lina Khan's lawsuits and make her look weak enough to be replaced with a stooge.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by Mountain_Skies on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:46AM (#43116945)
Seems to be more than just bean counting. Rings of Power was showered with money, so there are properties Amazon is willing to spend lavish amounts of money on. They also boosted the budget when they took over The Expanse, though there's plenty of disagreement over if that netted a better result or not.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by ganoushoreilly on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:51AM (#43117033)
The money wasn't the issue though, it was the lack of respect for the established cannon / materials and most fans / viewers not connecting with it.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by echelon on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:53AM (#43117064)
A web host / grocery store has no taste and should not be disrupting the entertainment industry.

It's time that we start trust busting these trillion dollar giants. Amazon needs a break up.

It's totally unfair that they subsidized all of that using unrelated business unit profit, displayed marquees on Amazon boxes and on the side of their delivery vans, and shipped all of our production crew jobs over to developing economies. US film production is in shambles because of Amazon.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by ganoushoreilly on Thursday February 20, 2025 @01:06PM (#43118050)
I don't see a monopolistic hold on the media from Amazon that would justify this. Anyone can produce content and put it out there. I agree they're not a good steward and they pretty much ruin franchises, but their right to do it is just that. Now if there is evidence that they're taking a substantial amount of business away from everyone else and you can prove they have a controlling hold on it, i'm with you on breaking it up.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by cjpearson on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:27PM (#43117576)
Bond doesn't really have a deep canon. They long ago moved on from the source material, and the first 20 movies were connected only in the loosest sense. For Craig's movies they tried to make a cross-movie continuity, but it didn't really work and required some retconning.

But the movies do have a unique sort of character and consistency that is widely believed to be due to one family running the show for 60+ years. I'm not sure that be replicated with a data-driven, committee-based approach. I also believe it was Broccoli's veto power that prevented over-saturation, and direct-to-streaming releases.

My guess is it will be closer to Star Wars than Lord of the Rings or Wheel of Time. Some of the movies may be "good" and some may be "bad", but they'll be missing that bit that made them special.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by JohnBooty on Thursday February 20, 2025 @01:57PM (#43118626)

    My guess is it will be closer to Star Wars than Lord 
    of the Rings or Wheel of Time.
Yeah. Not all Bond movies were good, but they were at least rare which made them feel special.

Now? Oh boy. Amazon did not buy this franchise to turn out three movies a decade, that's for sure.

I promise there will be a James Bond streaming series, and probably multiple James Bond streaming series. And there will be spinoffs. Ever wonder what Q does when he's not making gadgets for Bond? You're going to find out in his own series. How about Miss Moneypenny? Oh yeah. Another important load-bearing column in the James Bond Cinematic/Streaming Universe. It's absolutely going to be a Star Wars / Marvel kind of thing.

I hate it, even though... if we're honest, it's not like Bond was some highbrow thing. Most of the movies were fun, but few were what people would really think of as "great." Nearly all of them had a camp factor between "moderately high" and "very high." But still.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by JohnFen on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:22PM (#43121088)
> My guess is it will be closer to Star Wars

I mourn about what's become of Star Wars.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by librasteve on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:51AM (#43117045)
spoiler alert - he is dead
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by drewcoo on Thursday February 20, 2025 @03:43PM (#43119912)
> This is a sad outcome. The Bond franchise is very strong

Even back in the Broccoli years, Bond was garbage. The movie bond was a government assassin who we all pretended wasn't. Because sex. Ridiculous!

To Americans he also seemed smart and worldly. Because he had a British accent. Which sexy women liked. True, yet also ridiculous!

Can AMZN bury this relic faster than Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny was reburied? Rate to find out!

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by Molitor5901 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:23PM (#43120388)
Even back in the Broccoli years, Bond was garbage.

LOLWut ?! As of 2023, the James Bond film franchise has grossed over $7 billion globally at the box office. It's the sixth highest grossing film franchise in history. Your opinions of taste aside, Bond was anything but garbage otherwise it would never have lasted as long, or made as much money.

https://www.the-numbers.com/movies/franchise/James-Bond

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:57AM (#43124800)
Some things generate profit regardless of quality become the popular transcends any medium or iteration.

BvS was garbage but made money because people like those characters and will always pay. Same with Bond.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by JojoFatsani on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:47PM (#43121423)
The movies are a lot of fun.
Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by danpalmer on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:44PM (#43122674)
FWIW, I'm British. I won't disagree that there was a certain cringe to Bond, and the older films have aged quite poorly. But there's nostalgia there still, and it's also worth remembering that in many ways Bond defined the image of worldly/sexy. Bond's cultural impact on Men's fashion for example is huge. The films were influential at the time, even if in hindsight they're a bit simplistic or fantastical and more than a bit misogynistic.

I think the films are also worth more than the sum of their parts. Each one is typically an above average blockbuster style action film, but nothing particularly special. Taken together however, they are worth a lot more because of that continuing thread that has been done so well, and it's that which leads to the cultural significance.

The franchise certainly needs updating, but I think it has evolved over time and can likely continue to do so with that strong creative backing. It depends much less on sex now than it did even 20 years ago, they moved past the gadgets (as "gadgets" became less of a thing, it's hard to have a clever gadget when we all have smartphones in our pockets).

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by Molitor5901 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:20PM (#43120351)
Some modernization but I agree that it is very strong with a single coherent vision of the character. Bond does not and should be a woman, or transgender or any other twist to modernize. It can do that with supporting characters, and in how Bond interacts with them. Making a stark change to the main character would cause too much discontinuity with fans, and people who have know Bond as a specific archetype for a very, very long time.

We should think of new characters to fit modern ideas, not changing old out of simplicity; or latching onto the gravy train.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by danpalmer on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:30PM (#43122533)
I doubt that any of the options you've given would have been likely or be any more likely under new management – as you said, that modernisation can happen and is happening already through other characters.

What I could absolutely see happening is a teenage Bond YA fiction style thing, which would dilute the character. Or alternatively, a TV show, which would dilute the brand.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by rasz on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:50AM (#43124753)
>I hope Bond survives.

? Bond died in last movie.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:54AM (#43124776)
Bond was also in his 40s in both the 1960s and 2020s.

It's almost like there are different iterations of the character and will be again.

Re:Amazon MGM Studios will gain creative control of the Jame... by kennysoona on Friday February 21, 2025 @01:55AM (#43124782)
> The Bond franchise is very strong

I'm not sure how well it was doing under the Broccoli stewardship to be honest, I think some younger blood was needed. Although a soulless giant company is not what I would have suggested as a replacement.