(Search for "We send your password via email")
You can't really do much with a realestate.com.au account unless you are an Agent (which is a separate account). There's no payment processing, or any way to add content to the site. The accounts there are basically just a way to save common realestate searches as far as I can tell.
All private user information is equally private. To arbitrarily suggest that certain data is less important is a dangerous road to walk down. We should be holding everyone to the same standards when it comes to security.
This is especially true with the high amount of password reuse that goes on.
Does it really make sense to hold my bank to the same standard as a real estate website? Sure they should all reach some minimum requirement (salted and hashed passwords), but I expect my bank to have far higher standards (e.g. two factor auth) than a a random site.
I guess the issue is that the layman cannot really tell how secure a solution is, and so are unlikely to be able to make well reasoned decisions about the information they release. As such there really needs to be a far greater level of responsibility placed on people who hold the keys so to speak. Once again this is especially true since people re-use (and use overly simple) passwords at a scary rate. By not protecting their information on a crappy real estate website you are potentially leaving open their bank to abuse.
I feel instances like these just show dangerous levels of incompetence and a blatant disregard for user's information. Good solutions generally require less work anyway so there's no excuse.
Amusingly enough, the banks who impose PCI compliance on merchants aren't themselves required to be PCI compliant, and some of them will happily e-mail you extremely sensitive customer data (no matter how many times you ask them not to), even though doing so yourself would violate PCI compliance.
> This is especially true with the high amount of password reuse that goes on.
I do agree that it is a bit off (read: probably illegal) that they allow users to change the password and then store the user's password in plaintext. The system would be considerably better if users could only use a system-generated password.
In other news it's not just REA. I checked and my ISP (TPG) does the same :-(
https://twitter.com/#!/realestate_au/status/2207319148043059...
Anyway, "we are aware of this issue and are working on it".
Click http://www.realestate.com.au/ then "Register".
Then stand in utter amazement at their solution.
-------------------------------------------
Why do we need your email address?
-------------------------------------------This is hilarious. I can only assume that they took offence to you choosing a "strong version" password, so they decided, how can we fix this? I know, lets just pick the password for them.
So, their fix that they told you about, was to ensure that you can't pick a password at all, and they will still email you their "super strong version password"...
> Thank you for registering. Your password has been sent to username[at]gmail.com. It should arrive shortly.
12 seconds later.
Your password is: DTCNE
(In case people aren't aware, realestate.com.au is owned by HomeAway)