News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:47PM (#43105011)
That a UPR inhibitor would inhibit viability of AML cell lines is not exactly a novel scientific hypothesis. They took a previously published inhibitor known to be active in other cell lines and tried it in a new one. It's a cool, undergrad-level experiment. I would be impressed if a sophomore in high school proposed it, but not a sophomore in college.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by CaptainOfCoit on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:56PM (#43105127)
> I would be impressed if a sophomore in high school proposed it

That sounds good enough for a start, considering you can massively parallelize the AI co-scientist workflow, compared to the timescale and physical scale it would take to do the same thing with human high school sophomores.

And every now and then, you get something exciting and really beneficial coming from even inexperienced people, so if you can increase the frequency of that, that sounds good too.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:58PM (#43105147)
We don't need an army of high school sophomores, unless they are in the lab pipetting. The expensive part of drug discovery is not the ideation phase, it is the time and labor spent running experiments and synthesizing analogues.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by petra on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:44PM (#43106563)
So pharmaceutical research is largely an engineering problem, of running experiments and synthesizing molecules as fast, cheap and accurate as possible ?
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:04PM (#43106847)
I wouldn't say it's an engineering problem. Biology and pharmacology are very complex with lots of curveballs, and each experiment is often different and not done enough to warrant full engineering-scale optimization (although this is sometimes the case!).
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:22PM (#43107111)
It also seems to be a financial problem of getting VC funds to run trials to appease regulators. Even if you’ve already seen results in a lab or other country.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @07:01PM (#43109434)
We could have an alternative system where VC don’t need to appease regulators but must place X billion in escrow for compensation of any harm the medicine does to customers.

Regulator is not only there to protect the public, it also protects VC from responsibility

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by melagonster on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @10:11PM (#43110672)
This is why FDA requires experiments before company sells any drugs.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by forgetfreeman on Thursday February 20, 2025 @01:52AM (#43111856)
> VC don’t need to appease regulators

Regulations around clinical trials represent the floor of what's ethically permissible, not the ceiling. As in, these guidelines represent the absolute bare minimum required when performing drug trials to prevent gross ethical violations. Not sure what corners you think are ripe for cutting there.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by lmm on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:11AM (#43111948)
> Regulations around clinical trials represent the floor of what's ethically permissible, not the ceiling.

Disagree. The US FDA especially is overcautious to the point of doing more harm than good - they'd rather ban hundreds of lifesaving drugs than allow one thalidomide to slip through.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by forgetfreeman on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:21AM (#43111998)
Yeah that's not how anything works. Compounds are approved for use or not based on empirical evidence, thus the need for clinical trials. What's your level of exposure to the pharma industry?
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by lmm on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:37AM (#43112086)
> Compounds are approved for use or not based on empirical evidence, thus the need for clinical trials.

But off-label use is legal, so it's ok to use a drug that's safe but not proven effective (to the FDA's high standards) for that ailment... but only if it's been proven effective for some other random ailment. That makes no sense.

> What's your level of exposure to the pharma industry?

Just an interested outsider who read e.g. the Omegaven story on https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/adumbrations-of-aducanumab .

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by forgetfreeman on Friday February 21, 2025 @11:14AM (#43129233)
I strongly encourage you to take a half hour and have a look at what goes into preclinical testing and the phases of official trials. An understanding of the data gathered during this process should clear up some of your confusion around safety and efficacy of off-label uses, which parenthetically pharma companies are strictly regulated against encouraging in any way.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Teever on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:04PM (#43105203)
It sounds like you're suggesting that we need machines that mass produce things like automated pipetting machines and the robots that glue those sorts of machines together.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by 11101010001100 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:10PM (#43105282)
This exists, but does not require AI, so there is no hype.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:19PM (#43106209)
Replacing a skilled technician is remarkably challenging. Often times, when you automate this, you just end up wasting a ton of resources rather than accelerating discovery. Often, simply integrating devices from several vendors (or even one vendor) takes months.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:15PM (#43105349)
They already exist, and we use them. They are not cheap though!
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Teever on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:35PM (#43105617)
Any idea why they're they so expensive?
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:40PM (#43106513)
I've built microscopes intended to be installed inside workcells similar to what companies like Transcriptic built (https://www.transcriptic.com/). So my scope could be automated by the workcell automation components (robot arms, motors, conveyors, etc).

When I demo'd my scope (which is similar to a 3d printer, using low-cost steppers and other hobbyist-grade components) the CEO gave me feedback which was very educational. They couldn't build a system that used my style of components because a failure due to a component would bring the whole system down and require an expensive service call (along with expensive downtime for the user). Instead, their mech engineer would select extremely high quality components that had a very low probability of failure to minimize service calls and other expensive outages.

Unfortunately, the cost curve for reliability not pretty, to reduce mechanical failures to close to zero costs close to infinity dollars.

One of the reasons Google's book scanning was so scalable was their choice to build fairly simple, cheap, easy to maintain machines, and then build a lot of them, and train the scanning individuals to work with those machines quirks. Just like their clusters, they tolerate a much higher failure rate and build all sorts of engineering solutions where other groups would just buy 1 expensive device with a service contract.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by kridsdale1 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:24PM (#43107141)
That’s similar to how Google won in distributed systems. They used cheap PCs in shipping containers when everyone else was buying huge expensive SUN etc servers.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:44PM (#43108132)
yes, and that's the reason I went to work at google: to get access to their distributed systems and use ML to scale up biology. I never was able to join Google Research and do the work I wanted (but DeepMind went ahead and solved protein structure prediction, so, the job got done anyway).
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @05:45PM (#43108735)
They really didn't solve it. AF works great for proteins that have a homologous protein with a crystal structure. It is absolutely useless for proteins with no published structure to use as a template - e.g. many of the undrugged cancer targets in existence.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:13PM (#43108987)
@dekhn it is true (I also work in the field. I'm a software engineer who got a wet-lab PhD in biochemistry and work at a biotech doing oncology drug discovery)
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @05:55PM (#43108813)
that's not true (I work in the field) but it's not an interesting argument to have.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by jiggawatts on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:09PM (#43107713)
This sounds like it could be centralised, a bit like the clouds in the IT world. A low failure rate of 1-3% is comparable to servers in a rack, but if you have thousands of them, then this is just a statistic and not a servicing issue. Several hyperscalers simply leave failed nodes where they are, it’s not worth the bother to service them!

Maybe the next startup idea is biochemistry as a service, centralised to a large lab facility with hundreds of each device, maintained by a dedicated team of on-site professionals.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:19PM (#43107828)
None of the companies that proposed this concept have managed to demonstrate strong marketplace viability. A lot of discovery science remains extremely manual, artisinal, and vehemently opposed to automation.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by concordDance on Thursday February 20, 2025 @03:36AM (#43112448)
> They couldn't build a system that used my style of components because a failure due to a component would bring the whole system down and require an expensive service call

Could they not make the scope easily replaceable by the user and just supply a couple of spares?

Just thinking of how cars are complex machines but a huge variety of parts could be replaced by someone willing to spend a couple of hours learning how.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by shpongled on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:52PM (#43105839)
There is a big range in both automation capabilities and prices.

We have a couple automation systems that are semi-custom - the robot can handle operation of highly specific, non-standard instruments that 99.9% of labs aren't running. Systems have to handle very accurate pipetting of small volumes (microliters), moving plates to different stations, heating, shaking, tracking barcodes, dispensing and racking fresh pipette tips, etc. Different protocols/experiments and workflows can require vastly different setups.

See something like:

[1] https://www.hamiltoncompany.com/automated-liquid-handling/pl...

[2] https://www.revvity.com/product/fontus-lh-standard-8-96-ruo-...

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Teever on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @07:09PM (#43109509)
What are your thoughts on cheaper hardware like the stuff from Opentrons[0]?

I've been interested in this kind of stuff watching it from afar and now I may need to buy / build a machine that does this kind of stuff for work.

[0] https://opentrons.com/

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by devmor on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:23PM (#43107875)
This is the general problem with nearly all of this era of generative AI and why the public dislike it so much.

It is trained on human prose; human prose is primarily a representation of ideas; it synthesizes ideas.

There are very few uses for a machine to create ideas. We have a wealth of ideas and people enjoy coming up with ideas. It’s a solution built for a problem that does not exist.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by falcor84 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:34PM (#43108016)
As discussed elsewhere, Deepmind are also working on extending Alphafold to simulate biochemical pathways and then looking to tackle whole-cell simulation. It's not quite pipetting, but this sort of AI scientist would likely be paired with the simulation environment (essentially as function calling), to allow for very rapid iteration of in-silico research.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by sizzle on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @11:18PM (#43111058)
Also clinical trials
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by hinkley on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:49PM (#43106633)
I have a less generous recollection of the wisdom of sophomores.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by klipt on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:53PM (#43105083)
Only two years since chatGPT was released and AI at the level of "impressive high school sophomore" is already blasé.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by rtkwe on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:14PM (#43105330)
Suggesting "maybe try this known inhibitor in other cell lines" isn't exactly novel information though. It'd be more impressive and useful if it hadn't had any published information about working as a cancer inhibitor before. People are blasé about it because it's not really beating the allegations that it's just a very fancy parrot when the highlight of it's achievements is to say try this known inhibitor with these other cell lines, decent odds that the future work sections of papers on the drug already suggested trying on other lines too...
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by baq on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:21PM (#43107082)
A couple years ago even suggesting that a computer could propose anything at all was sci-fi. Today a computer read the whole internet, suggested a place to look at and experiments to perform and… ‘not impressive enough’. Oof.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Workaccount2 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:06PM (#43107688)
People are facing existential dread that the knowledge they worked years for is possibly about to become worth a $20 monthly subscription. People will downplay it for years no matter what.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by forgetfreeman on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:01AM (#43111903)
You just described a library card.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Der_Einzige on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:20AM (#43111992)
whoosh
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @07:07PM (#43109484)
> Today a computer read the whole internet, suggested a place to look at

Or imagine this one - computer maps the whole world, suggests a route how to get to any destination?!

You just described a basic search engine.

LLM is kind of a search engine for language

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by OvidNaso on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @11:50PM (#43111259)
But so are you and I. That's how you wrote this reply.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday February 20, 2025 @02:53AM (#43112164)
Preposterous- cavemen had no language but they could reason, think and learn.

A child learns how to eat solid food and how to walk. That a square peg fits into a square hole. This has nothing to do with language.

people who deaf and mute and cannot read can still reason and solve problems.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by baq on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:48AM (#43112875)
> cavemen had no language

big if true

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by rtkwe on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:51PM (#43121466)
It's one of those things that's basically impossible to study because language leaves no signs until you get to writing.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Nevermark on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:15PM (#43105341)
Especially when you consider the artificial impressive high school sophomore is capable of having impressive high school sophomore ideas across and between an incredibly broad spectrum of domains.

And that their generation of impressive high school sophomore ideas is faster, more reliable, communicated better, and can continue 24/7 (given matching collaboration), relative to their bio high school sophomore counterparts.

I don’t believe any natural high school sophomore as impressive on those terms, has ever existed. Not close.

We humans (I include myself) are awful at judging things or people accurately (in even a loose sense) across more than one or two dimensions.

This is especially true when the mix of ability across several dimensions is novel.

(I also think people under estimate the degree that we, as users and “commanders” of AI, bottleneck their potential. I don’t suggest they are ready to operate without us. But that our relative lack of energy, persistence & focus all limit what we get from them in those dimensions, hiding significant value.

We famously do this with each other, so not surprising. But worth keeping in mind when judging limits: whose limits are we really seeing.)

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by howenterprisey on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:42PM (#43106543)
I don't need high school level ideas, though. If people do, that's good for them, but I haven't met any. And if the quality of the ideas is going to improve in future years, that's good too, but also not demonstrated here.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by Nevermark on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:49PM (#43107458)
I am going to argue that you do. Then I will be interested in your response, if you feel inclined.

We all have our idiosyncratically distributed areas of high intuition, expertise and fluency.

None of us need apprentice level help there, except to delegate something routine.

Lower quality ideas there would just gum things up.

And then we all have vast areas of increasingly lesser familiarity.

I find, that the more we grow our strong areas, the more those areas benefit with as efficient contact as possible with as many more other areas as possible. In both trivial and deeper ways.

The better developer I am, in terms of development skill, tool span, novel problem recognition and solution vision, the more often and valuable I find quick AI tutelage on other topics, trivial or non-trivial.

And the more valuable I find any increase in quality of response. And increasingly even suggestions. Ideas.

High school level familiarity and idea processing on tap, across most public human knowledge is a godsend, vs. what alternative? Less mindful responses?

So sure, you can project the capability vector of these models onto the one dimension of “school level idea quality”. But lower dimension projections are literally shadows of the whole.

Use them in the direction of their total ability vector (and given they can iterate, their ability vector is actually an ability eigenvector!) and their value goes way beyond “a human high schooler”.

Does it make sense to you, to see “high school” here is a floor of contribution ability, not a ceiling? That every additional “school month” of idea level raises the value multiplier on the access and initiative they can provide to everything you don’t already know or even just need reminding of?

It does take time to appreciate & incorporate new tools for what they are.

What do you think?

TLDR; If you know a bright high schooler highly familiar with an area you are not, but have reason to think might be helpful, don’t you think quick access to talk things over with that high schooler would be valuable?

And that a machine incorporating a million high schoolers familiar with a million of your (or my) non-familiar areas isn’t many times more valuable?

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by the8472 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:43PM (#43109286)
> And if the quality of the ideas is going to improve in future years, that's good too, but also not demonstrated here.

I don't quite understand the argument here. The future hasn't happened yet. What does it mean to demonstrate the future developments now?

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by directevolve on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:12PM (#43105310)
Most people here know little to nothing of biomedical research. Explaining clearly why this isn’t a scientifically interesting result is helpful.
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by thomastjeffery on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @01:11PM (#43105298)
Sure, but is it more impressive than books?
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by dekhn on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:20PM (#43106223)
(to be Shpongled is to be kippered, mashed, smashed, destroyed...completely geschtonkenflopped)
Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by elicksaur on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @08:47PM (#43110140)
I’m not familiar with the subject matter, but given your description, I wouldn’t really be impressed by anyone suggesting it. It just sounds like a very plausible “What if” alternative.

On the level of suggesting suitable alternative ingredients in fruit salad.

We should really stop insulting the intelligence of people to sell AI.

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by tomrod on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @10:39PM (#43110830)
Incremental progress is incremental progress.

[0] https://matt.might.net/articles/phd-school-in-pictures/

Re:Accelerating scientific breakthroughs with an AI co-scien... by kuhewa on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:47AM (#43111541)
I'm sure the scientists involved had a wish list of dozens of drug candidates to repurpose to test based on various hypotheses. Ideas are cheap, time is not.

In this case they actually tested a drug probably because Google is paying for them to test whatever the AI came up with.