Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by architango on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @07:01PM
(#43096773)
Agreed with all of this. And, there’s an implicit criticism of science journalism here. Any article that suggests useful fusion reactors are X years away should address the massive unsolved engineering problems that have to be surmounted. But no news source is going to spend five or six extra paragraphs explaining neutron metal activation or hydrogen embrittlement.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by 1970-01-01 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @10:29AM
(#43103109)
>Why do you think a result like this would make anyone less skeptical of fusion?
Just 9 days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43000301
>>Ability to run a device for this long is not the obstacle to success for nuclear fusion.
What an odd take. Do you also consider the list of flight endurance records to be immaterial to aircraft evolution?
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by pfdietz on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:51PM
(#43108222)
Focus on relatively unimportant subtasks has a name. It's called "bikeshedding".
This achievement is relatively unimportant. It's not the major issue that would block a DT fusion reactor. As such, achieving it doesn't move the needle much on the plausibility of DT fusion in tokamaks.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by 1970-01-01 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @05:12PM
(#43108424)
This is not the definition of bikeshedding.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by pfdietz on Thursday February 20, 2025 @07:21AM
(#43113850)
Bikeshedding is focusing on triviality at the expense of important issues. That is just what is happening here. The showstopper issues with tokamaks are size, cost, reliability, materials. This has nothing to do with any of those.
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by 1970-01-01 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:55AM
(#43116211)
>The showstopper issues with tokamaks are size, cost, reliability, materials.
Plasma runtime in not a showstopper then?
Re:Nuclear fusion: WEST beats the world record for plasma du...
by pfdietz on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:19PM
(#43117464)
It's an issue that wasn't high risk. I mean, sure, check off the box, but don't pretend this moves the needle much. This was minor compared to those issues that have no clear solutions, or reasons to think there won't be solutions.
Why do you think a result like this would make anyone less skeptical of fusion? Ability to run a device for this long is not the obstacle to success for nuclear fusion. This is just another vastly overhyped "breakthrough", which we seem to have every week.
I've followed fusion for probably longer than you've been alive, and there are fundamental showstoppers for the common approaches, particularly tokamaks and stellarators. Fusion may have a chance with unconventional approaches, like Helion's, but the consensus approach looks like an exercise in groupthink that won't lead anywhere.