News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by agscala on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:18PM (#4309395)
I kind of feel bad for Craigslist. Everyone is attacking them for wanting to hold onto their data. I don't think that they should be obligated to let just anyone scrape it
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by aggronn on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:35PM (#4309436)
But does that mean its okay for them to sue anyone who does? If they make the information public, how could they think they have a right to keep their data private from applications they think could be a competitive threat? Should Walmart sue Target if target scrapes walmart prices to help make decisions about their own online pricing schemes?

In what way is it "their data" if they release it to the public? The law is pretty clear about this--facts can't be copyrighted. They don't own the facts. They don't own the bits that padmapper is referencing. All they own is the db records for the posts that originated the information.

Imagine if they had a CL user meetup in public somewhere, and then they charged users to use a megaphone to announce that they were selling something. Someone writes down the information and has their own meetup for people who couldn't make it to the free, public CL meetup. Whats the difference between that and what padmapper is doing, except that padmapper is getting the information second hand?

If CL thinks they have a right to their data, they should be suing google should they?

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by anamax on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:55PM (#4309501)
> The law is pretty clear about this--facts can't be copyrighted.

While it is true that "facts can't be copyrighted", it's unclear that Craigslist listings qualify as facts in the relevant sense. (The singles listings, for example, surely don't.)

> Someone writes down the information and has their own meetup for people who couldn't make it to the free, public CL meetup. Whats the difference between that and what padmapper is doing, except that padmapper is getting the information second hand?

Getting the information second-hand seems fairly significant.

Don't get me wrong - I think that craigslist should be disrupted, but I don't think that you should just do the easy parts.

Note that the NYT has a dog in this fight - Craigslist has "disrupted" the newspaper biz.

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by aggronn on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:06PM (#4309543)
>Getting the information second-hand seems fairly significant.

I meant to suggest that that made it even less significant. The information is already widely disseminated across multiple platforms because its public information. Sure, everyone knows that CL is the original source for the information, but that doesn't meant that only people they say can have the information should have the information. Its public, broadcasted information.

Sure, they can put something on their website along the lines of "You're not allowed to distribute this information", but why does that have any weight if they don't own the information?

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by learc83 on Sunday July 29, 2012 @06:03PM (#4309903)
> it's unclear that Craigslist listings qualify as facts in the relevant sense.

Padmapper only publishes the relavant facts from the listing. Even if the whole text contains copyrightable material (some prose describing the house maybe), they don't copy the whole text just the facts.

This apartment is available for rent here, it has 4 bedrooms etc...

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by smashing on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:45PM (#4309474)
"...they[Craigslist] charged users to use a megaphone to announce that they were selling something."

I don't get where you came up with that. It wasn't in the article at all.

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by aggronn on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:00PM (#4309519)
I wasn't referencing the article.
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by jacoblyles on Sunday July 29, 2012 @10:05PM (#4310581)
I don't know about anyone else, but I'm attacking them for being an evil monopoly. If there were other viable services, I wouldn't care so much.

They are the IE6 of classified ads. And just like IE6 they are holding back innovation.

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by jonursenbach on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:32PM (#4309428)
No, but there is clearly use cases for Craigslist having an API. Instead of suing everyone who wants to use their data to make beautiful products, they should be giving people legal ways of doing so.
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by gamble on Sunday July 29, 2012 @03:45PM (#4309472)
The problem for Craigslist is that the one thing people want is a better interface. If CL provides an API people can use to build an alternative frontend, and users start to go to these frontends instead of CL itself, there's nothing to stop those new frontends from extending CL with their own listings, and eventually extinguishing it. That was PadLister's business model.
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by iamwil on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:23PM (#4309601)
Padlister/Padmapper doesn't make money from from CL listings. Padlister charges money if listers listing directly on Padlister decides to use the online application.
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by robterrell on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:00PM (#4309518)
Apparently they offered PadMapper paid access but PadMapper declined. Articles like this make PadMapper look even worse to me.

And sloppy journalism. Why won't anyone ask PadMapper why they decided against? This is like half of a linkbait article. The fact that CL offered paid access was in last week's HN stories. I bet there's a breathless follow-up article with that fact, trolling for additional page views.

Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by Mazy on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:12PM (#4309559)
Craigslist offered padmapper a license for using their data in mobile applications only. They gave him no options for padmapper.com
Re:When Craigslist Blocks Innovations by iamwil on Sunday July 29, 2012 @04:21PM (#4309594)
Most users use padmapper through the website. CL offered a license only for mobile apps, which, depending on your point of view "a license with a crappy option, but a license nonetheless", or "a license that's completely not applicable".