Has any of this been experimentally fit to reality?
> sending signals back in time.
First encode stock movements. Then technological discoveries. If it works like many-worlds, then even NP hard problems.
With sufficient bandwidth and time delta, you'd also have to hope that the future isn't sending anything nefarious that could lead to your demise. A future adversary could final destination you pretty easily and use you as a pawn to enrich itself, and there's not much you could do except stop listening - but it'd know you planned that too. A future adversary would be the scariest adversary.
Messing with your own history, given that most systems are chaotic, seems inherently risky. Even in warfare, you’d have a hard time predicting the outcome over more than a short interval.
Fragile universe hypothesis [2].
[1] eg. nucleate vacuum collapse
[2] cf. fragile world hypothesis
Should have written queries into the data mountain of humanity,learn about whats possible and whats not possible. The time we could reuse from ineffective public appeals to work on solveable problems
It's not time reversal symmetric, but it's probably [CPT][1] (charge-parity-time reversal) symmetric.
If you forget about quantum field theory and consider classical physics in Minkowski space (or Cartesian space), then t -> -t indeed doesn't change the physical laws. You could tell the two apart, though, provided that the system is far from thermal equilibrium (e.g. "why is this egg uncracking spontaneously?").
https://januscosmologicalmodel.com/januspoint
There are other players concerned with similar ideas:
- Negative mass, Farnes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_fluid
- Mirror-image universe going backwards in time from the big bang, Turok: https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg25734230-100-neil-tur...
It's widely assumed to be true and not at all physically meaningful. If you sub x -> -x then that's just as good a solution as well, i.e. just as you can count x as running from west to east or east to west and the results will be the same, you can also count time as increasing away from the big bang or as decreasing away from the big bang and all your calculations will be the same.
The use of a quadratic to solve the throw is a mathematical model. We say that "the value x describing the when the ball lands must satisfy the quadratic equation F(x)=0" but that does NOT imply the opposite, which is "all x that satisfy F(x)=0 describe a valid motion of the balle."
So when we get two answers, e.g. F(-1)=0 and F(15)=0 for the two points when the ball is at ground level, that means only this: if I had thrown the ball from ground level to follow the same curve land in the same place at x=15, then I would have stood 1m further back when I threw it. It does have physical meaning, but there is nothing curious about the physical meaning.
This throw is symmetrical in time though, in the sense that if I throw the ball with the same speed in the opposite direction starting at x=15 then it will land exactly in my hand. (But the equation here is y=F(x) and not parametrized on time).
The equation we use to describe the motion does not contain a term for the ground being there. That assumption exists outside of the model described by the equation, and you use that assumption after the fact to reject a solution that would otherwise be valid, and describe the movement of the ball that's pulled down by gravity.
In this form, it doesn't really describe a proper orbit, just a trajectory of being pulled down by a constant force. I believe this would correspond to an infinitely-ish heavy object located infinitely far below. The proper equation that gives you an orbital curve has the force of gravity proportional to inverse-square distance and point at the center of the body, which is what makes it possible to describe a circular or elliptical motion this way. Parabolic orbits exist too, but they're interpreted as failed orbital capture - "object is moving so fast that it'll curve around and fly away to infinity before turning around and coming back".
And in all cases, the solutions make physical sense (+/- infinity), on the assumption the trajectory doesn't cross the ground, as there's no term for it there :). If you want, you can describe the ground as another equation (or inequality), and solve the resulting system - it'll then be clear what exactly is it that rejects some of the solutions.
What both solutions correspond to is the completion of the orbit the ball is briefly in while it is in free fall, in both directions. Every body in free fall (ignoring air resistance) is for that time in orbit around the center of gravity of the Earth. It's just the the body can not complete that orbit due to the fact it impacts the ground, and in the time-reversed direction, couldn't have come from that orbit initially because of the ground.
It's not mystery getting in the way of the equations, it's the physical ground.
(There are many other deviations from the highly idealized "orbit the Earth as if it was a stationary body in perfect Newtonian physics" but compared to air resistance you will not be able to witness any of those effects with anything you can throw with your arm from the ground.)
https://www.scribd.com/doc/287808282/Bearden-Articles-Mind-C... ... https://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&as_sdt=0%2C43&q=%22... ... "p sychon ergetics" .. /? Torsion fields :
- "Torsion fields generated by the quantum effects of macro-bodies" (2022) https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.16245 :
> We generalize Einstein's General Relativity (GR) by assuming that all matter (including macro-objects) has quantum effects. An appropriate theory to fulfill this task is Gauge Theory Gravity (GTG) developed by the Cambridge group. GTG is a "spin-torsion" theory, according to which, gravitational effects are described by a pair of gauge fields defined over a flat Minkowski background spacetime. The matter content is completely described by the Dirac spinor field, and the quantum effects of matter are identified as the spin tensor derived from the spinor field. The existence of the spin of matter results in the torsion field defined over spacetime. Torsion field plays the role of Bohmian quantum potential which turns out to be a kind of repulsive force as opposed to the gravitational potential which is attractive [...] Consequently, by virtue of the cosmological principle, we are led to a static universe model in which the Hubble redshifts arise from the torsion fields.
Wikipedia says that torsion fields are pseudoscientific.
Retrocausality is observed.
From "Evidence of 'Negative Time' Found in Quantum Physics Experiment" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41707116 :
> "Experimental evidence that a photon can spend a negative amount of time in an atom cloud" (2024) https://arxiv.org/abs/2409.03680
/?hnlog retrocausality (Ctrl-F "retrocausal", "causal") https://westurner.github.io/hnlog/ )
From "Robust continuous time crystal in an electron–nuclear spin system" (2024) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39291044 ;
> [ Indefinite causal order, Admissible causal structures and correlations, Incandescent Temporal Metamaterials, ]
From "What are time crystals and why are they in kids’ toys?" https://bigthink.com/surprising-science/what-are-time-crysta... :
> Time crystals have been detected in an unexpected place: monoammonium phosphate, a compound found in fertilizer and ‘grow your own crystal’ kits.
Ammonium dihydrogen phosphate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ammonium_dihydrogen_phosphate :
> Piezoelectric, birefringence (double refraction), transducers
Retrocausality in photons, Retrocausality in piezoelectric time crystals which are birefringent (which cause photonic double-refraction)
Is it gauge theory, though?
From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38839439 :
> If gauge symmetry breaks in superfluids (ie. Bose-Einstein condensates); and there are superfluids at black hole thermal ranges; do gauge symmetry constraints break in [black hole] superfluids?
Probably not gauge symmetry there, then.
it doesn't say anything about time evolution because it isn't something you solve. given a spacetime, you can lay down axes and the metric tells you intervals between events.
it says nothing about allowed trajectories through spacetime.
There's also Wick rotations, where you can sub `t -> it'`, and then Minkowskian spacetime becomes Euclidean but time becomes complex-valued. Groovy stuff.
I'm not much of a physics buff but I loved reading Julian Barbour's The Janus Point for a great treatment of the possibility of negative time.
The craziest thing I've seen though is the suggestion that an accelerating charge, emitting radiation that interacts with the charge itself and imparts a backreacting force on the charge, supposedly has solutions whose interpretation would suggest that it would be sending signals back in time. [0]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abraham–Lorentz_force