> Feed readers are dead.
At least as far as standalone desktop apps are concerned, I think you're right. I can't even remember a time when I was not using Google Reader. I do hope RSS-fed reading in general is not going extinct though.
Re:The Disappointing Surprise From Apple
by AndrewDucker on Saturday July 28, 2012 @11:53AM
(#4305748)
As I got to this page via FeedDemon I think "dead" is an exaggeration.
Sprained seems reasonable though :->
That's a pretty gratuitous assumption that you're making. And I don't see what the "good reason" is. Let's face it, they just dropped a feature that people were using, without clear upgrade path. Few people were using it ? Maybe. That doesn't make it a good decision, only (at best) a sad but necessary compromise.
Frankly, a feed reader that is already there, and works, needs next to zero maintenance. It's not like RSS format changes everyday.
But a feed reader inside another program that IS changing does indeed require maintenance. Even just testing to make sure it still works isn't free. It also adds complexity to the user interface.
Re:The Disappointing Surprise From Apple
by sonnenkiste on Saturday July 28, 2012 @11:50AM
(#4305743)
To remove something is ok. But you should clearly inform the user and give him the possibility to easy get his data back and really cool would be to provide a solution for the now existing problem. Maybe to point him to an App Download. Just dropping a feature without any response is bad practice.
Re:The Disappointing Surprise From Apple
by prodigal_erik on Saturday July 28, 2012 @04:15PM
(#4306385)
If they didn't test it, it might have broken. That outcome is still better than what happened, where they ensured it became completely unusable.
This isn't as much about abandoning features as it is deleting content. It would have been great to say "Hey, we're about to delete all of your feeds, would you like to export them?".
most industries have some thought for their customers, and are not so dictatorial. They will at least give some advance warning of feature removal. Feed readers are far from dead, and I find there are more people than ever using them, mainly through Google Reader. as there are huge advantages to having globally maintained read/unread content.
This happened in every industry, not just the computer industry. The problem here is that the computer industry abandons old features at a MUCH faster rate than other industries, but for good reason.