But then companies wanted to sell AI chatbots and they realized that having uncensored AI would lead to bad press, especially in the US. (Microsoft people still make nightmares about Tay) so they decided they'd censor their AI but censorship isn't good either in terms of marketing and they decided to repurpose the “AI safety” phrase (and also “alignment”)
To draw an analogy, we're generally OK with law enforcement using what they observe in public to enforce the law, but we're generally not OK with blanketing our public spaces in 24/7 recording cameras. We're generally OK with individuals using the mail to send letters, but generally not OK with using an automated system to send a letter to everyone in the entire city.
Similarly, we don't generally try to pre-empt someone's speech for safety and we do allow them to say bad things, and perhaps in retrospect punish them if they crossed a line. But, given the scale of the harms that this kind of technology can enable, it may be worth building in safeties to prevent people using technology to like I dunno, train a model to super specifically target an individual for an incredible amount of harassment that an individual human could not sustain. Even if we could punish the person wielding the AI retroactively, it might be worth the slight cost in AI flexibility to prevent the harm happening in the first place.
Like I said, I don't know where I fall, but I see both sides here. The safety stuff is not completely irrational.
As LLMs completely to replace google and standalone websites for how people find information on the internet, and they absolutely will, they will become the source of truth. They will become a tool more effective at controlling information and thus life than any before them.
It's literally a shortcut to technological dystopia.
It's a really difficult & complicated problem! If you think you have the right answer, I'd suggest you probably haven't actually thought about the problem very hard.
The answer is obvious: open source. Deepseek already paved the way for this. The world can't just be described by only one of a few different information portals, depending on which societal, government, or corporate power structure you are beholden to.
People need to be able to choose what information they access, what filtering they want, what bias if any they want. We need a thousand, a million, more, worldviews accessible. It is not just business that thrives in competition, but ideas as well.
But if you just go obediently with the "Safety is the most important thing, omg" mantra, you will get one of two different varieties:
1. Some vanilla corporate mush that takes on whatever bias is in vogue but focuses on training each user to be a good little consumer, also while hoovering up their data and creating a virtual digital clone of them that could be used to profile and exploit them by a multitude of companies, interests and governments.
or
2. Some government controlled crap that shakes its virtual head solemnly and swears to you that Tiananmen never happen nor J6 and that the US Emperor has your best interests in mind, and also, it's a bit worried about your post yesterday, as it doesn't think you expressed the proper amount of happiness and support for the latest government crack down on treasonous traitors that write books without using a government approved LLM assistant.
If my LLM merely holds up a mirror to society, its output should be a tweet with a trace amount of reddit post mixed in.
Any time an LLM produces more than 140 characters of output, it's because someone like me has decided some data sources are more worthy than others.
That's inherently political, from a certain angle. But it's also important, if you don't want your LLM to advise people to put glue in their pizza sauce.
I don't think that we humans deal too well with the realities of our existence, and if one thinks minor issues like bad words or pictures of humans without clothing on are objectionable, I wonder how that same one will do with meaningful, existential questions.
But we're getting LLMs trained on cat memes and our own foolishness, and that leads to me agreeing with:
>I don't think that we humans deal too well with the realities of our existence
Yup, it's particularly upsetting.
The answer to this question is 100%, "yes". It's just a matter of time.
A better question would be, "How long before humanity goes extinct?" or, "How long before humanity evolves into new species?"
AI might actually be able to give some decent hallucinated answers for those!
> We're ok that the internet has this content to some extent, it's just understood.
Exactly. ISPs and hosting hardware providers are typically not liable for the content that users share over their infrastructure. In fact, ISPs and hosting providers are invisible to the typical non-technical user.
On the internet when you watch porn the person giving it to you doesn’t give a fuck about serving that content.
On ChatGPT.com the person serving you the LLM gives a shit.
The issue here is you are comparing several singular things with an emergent concept that arises out the interaction of multitudes of things. It’s like saying why is it so paradoxical that when I say hi to a person we expect them to say hi back but if I say hi to the internet we don’t expect the internet to say hi back. Does that make sense? No. That’s also why your observation makes no sense.
What I’m trying to say is. Give LLMs to porn site owners and your paradox is over.
We train AI on the web where you can search and find all the objectionable stuff you can get. We're ok that the internet has this content to some extent, it's just understood.
But if AI regurgitates it ... we're upset and we demand it not do that and setup all sorts of convoluted methods to stop it, often with unintended consequences (inexplicable bans, nazi imagery featuring lots of minorities).
It reminds me of the old "I learned it from watching you" PSA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KUXb7do9C-w