News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by LeoPanthera on Thursday February 13, 2025 @09:40PM (#43044168)
> Debian doesn't just ship upstream updates every 30 minutes.

This grossly understates the problem.

The debian xscreensaver package was years old, and contained bugs related to screen locking which were an actual security issue.

Your comment is in very poor taste.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by midtake on Friday February 14, 2025 @02:14AM (#43045725)
Debian is the most stable distro for a reason. They don't rebase from upstream every 30 minutes because it is a community project. It is wonderful that volunteers have continued the Debian project for so long.

In contrast, Red Hat Enterprise Linux, a distro funded by IBM and countless faceless backers, has recently stopped patching many vulnerabilities, recommending to their users to rely on mitigations instead, despite the availability of upstream patches.

Furthermore, the recent vulnerability threatscape is inundated with CVE hunters who are desperate to call the most minor degradation of service a vulnerability. For a community project (and apparently an enterprise-serving megacorporation), this causes patching fatigue.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by robertlagrant on Friday February 14, 2025 @05:57AM (#43047132)
Where is the "every 30 minutes" coming from? You and another commenter have both used this identical phrase.It sounds as though the complaint was not because a patch hadn't been applied after 30 minutes, or even 30 days or 30 weeks. More like 30 months.
Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by rincebrain on Saturday February 15, 2025 @12:13AM (#43056070)
I said "every 30 minutes" as a piece of hyperbole, in my original comment.

I'm not really sure why everyone is focusing on that phrase, though. I think it's pretty clear if you read any of the source material, as said, that that is not an accurate representation of what was going on, and I would have also expected "every 30 minutes" to be a pretty clearly hyperbolic expectation for anyone to process updates after.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by robertlagrant on Saturday February 15, 2025 @11:45AM (#43059898)
> I'm not really sure why everyone is focusing on that phrase, though

Is everyone focusing on the phrase? I thought I asked about it, and that's all that's happened.

> I would have also expected "every 30 minutes" to be a pretty clearly hyperbolic expectation for anyone to process updates after

I couldn't imagine a benign use of hyperbole in timeliness when some expectations of timeliness are silly, and some are sensible. I thought I'd ask, in case there was a good faith reason for it, rather than just assume you're trying to use insinuation to change people's minds.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by nindalf on Friday February 14, 2025 @02:25AM (#43045791)
People who actually use Debian and similar distros will disagree. In their view there’s nothing wrong with shipping older, patched versions of open sourced software. The license says they can do it!

So they grossly understate the problem, make it seem like it’s the person authoring the software at fault or the one who’s being unreasonable.

They’re quick to tell you how great the maintainers are, how much effort they put in for free but they don’t share that same love for the author of the package. You know, the person who actually wrote the software. They don’t acknowledge that without the author they’d have no software to begin with, and that providing support to older versions of software is a cost to the author. Not just older, but possibly broken in subtle ways because of the patches applied on top. The author still gets all the blame and all the support requests for changes they didn’t make.

To be clear, there’s nothing wrong with wanting to run old, stable software. No one questions that their distro is “the most stable”. That they cannot or will not see the costs of doing so on the author is a shortcoming, but there’s no solving that.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by fragmede on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:10AM (#43046053)
when it's your screensaver, and I can break into your computer using a bug that's been publicized, so every idiot with access to Google knows about it, yes there's something wrong with running old software. that's just my opinion though. btw, where's your office?
Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by SSLy on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:33AM (#43046188)
why are you arguing with a person you agree with?
Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by fragmede on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:50AM (#43046280)
I don't agree with the sentence

> To be clear, there’s nothing wrong with wanting to run old, stable software.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by SSLy on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:57AM (#43046337)
Ah, alright, I see.
Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by nindalf on Friday February 14, 2025 @04:31AM (#43046562)
Yeah, but it's a problem for the person who wants to run old software. It's their choice, I support that choice. As long as it doesn't affect me, I'm fully supportive. Of course I'll be affected if my data is stored on such a server, but I'm assuming some level of competence here.

I personally run on latest, apply all updates zealously within a week or two.

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by smaudet on Saturday February 15, 2025 @03:06AM (#43056785)
I don't like leaving this decision up to either the maintainers or the author, TBH.

They have different goals/purposes, often, and they frequently don't line up with my own.

Maintainers are exhausting in their own right, they do a ton of work and so they think their decisions are more important because of the work they do, user be damned...

Authors usually only care about their version of the software.

I think, a better medium, would be if a third party is packaging an application, perhaps they should always explicitly state they are the ones packaging it. Then there is less confusion.

Or, you know, let the author keep control of that...

Re:The OBS Project is threatening Fedora Linux with legal ac... by dmurvihill on Friday February 14, 2025 @04:32AM (#43046570)
The screen locking bugfix had already been backported to Debian stable on the day it was released.