I was once trying to figure out taxes owed on some RSUs granted in California that vested in North Carolina (and some other edge case that I can’t remember). Hoh boy. What a rabbit hole. I didn’t think the CPA that I hired to do my taxes handled it correctly, so I started digging into the tax laws and regulations. Couldn’t find anything that covered my specific case. So I started digging into court cases involving disputes over RSU taxes owed in North Carolina and found conflicting outcomes.
I brought what I had found back to the CPA who basically said something along the lines of: there is no absolute “rule” for what to do in this case like you’re looking for. We make a good faith effort to mirror what was done in similar prior situations, write a number down, and then forget about it unless you hear from the IRS.
Did not make me feel very confident about the legal system.
> In the legal world, however, this assumption does not hold. This is because unlike the laws of nature, political laws are not consistent. The law human beings create to regulate their conduct is made up of incompatible, contradictory rules and principles; and, as anyone who has studied a little logic can demonstrate, any conclusion can be validly derived from a set of contradictory premises. This means that a logically sound argument can be found for any legal conclusion.
The Myth of the Rule of Law:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1I-JhqpU3_0r_HL06hP-5DABhEtG...
I have also been thinking about how basing morality on following laws is a bad idea. You should not be afraid of breaking laws or rules if they are stupid. All of modern workers rights, women's rights, etc are based on brave people of the past that were not afraid of breaking stupid laws of their time, why should today be any different.
This tends to be something people encounter a lot around tax, complex business structures, and various international dealings where you’re more likely to end up in an edge case that hasn’t been well explored.
Civil law systems (which are used in the non-English-speaking parts of Europe for example) don't have this property. In such systems, court precedents don't really exist, so if something isn't clearly defined by law, and there's no extremely ubiquitous legal interpretation that everybody seems to follow, you don't know whether it's legal or not.
For example, the Polish tax authority lets you ask for a tax interpretation for cases that aren't legally obvious, something that I believe the US would have handled via the court precedent system. It's not unusual for two people in identical situations to receive opposite rulings, and Those rulings are not binding on the authority that issued them.
In other words, you don't know how to handle your tax situation, you ask your tax authority, they tell you "hey, we're the tax authority, we're telling you to do x", you do x, they audit you, they say "this isn't clearly defined in law, we now believe you should have done y instead, here's your orange jumpsuit."
And eventual orange jumpsuit would be decided by the court, not tax authority.
If you're a software engineer and you're knee-deep in analyzing court cases to find out how to file some tax correctly, you're definitely overthinking it. The CPA was exactly correct.
(Hint* You can't)
Yes that is 2 different countries. But it is similar. States have their own laws.
You can't expect the law across 3 jurisdictions to work out every permutation and legislate for it. There are 52 (I guess more... lots of territories) * 51 permutations of moves so 2652 moves that are possible.
In addition you are talking RSUs and not some vanilla thing like claiming an expense.
> So what happens in practice is politicians write a vague law. Bureaucrats turn that law into very detailed (but often still vague) specific rules. Those rules might or might not be “legal”, but nobody want to risk fighting them in court. If the regulations are particularly ridiculous or likely to be overturned if challenged, prosecutors may quietly stop bringing cases. But the regulations still sit there on the books. And people still usually pay attention to them, because why risk it?
Separate rant: I live on the west coast and am annoyed when I vote because of the number of ballot measures. None of them are sufficiently detailed and fall victim to vague language that's open to interpretation. I'd rather "hire" law makers to do the hard work of details law creation.
What I thought was missing was an acknowledgement of the circumstances that would cause a _prosecutor_ or _other litigant_ to decide to _bring an action to court._
Prosecutors are political, have limited resources, and are ultimately more or less accountable to electoral forces. Their prerogative is (almost) never going after every single person who does an action that is technically illegal. Factors like harm, the reputation of one's actions in their community, and their alignment with the political establishment are going to be considerations.
As written, I could see the article maybe deterring a particularly rules-abiding individual from running a potato-eating weight loss experiment with their roommates. I've seen friends and relatives get all wound up worrying about whether something is technically illegal in some marginal way.
Understanding the human factors in the pipeline between a potentially unlawful action and a consequence for it is really important. All the institutions that get anything done are keenly aware of them.
I don't think it's fair to call that a deficiency, though; both the letter of the law and the practical applications are complex and interesting topics in their own right(s?), and either could fill a lengthy article as we see here. Both are welcome! One doesn't preclude the other. I would be interested in reading an article covering what you describe too.
But they have been sued, sometimes for extraordinary amounts, as have their employers, corporate sponsors, etc. And they have lost funding for their research and the trust of everyone above (and of future IRBs). These are powerful disincentives.
It's easy for people (especially the kinds of people who gravitate towards engineering) to get all worked up about the necessary implications of the regulations as-written. But it's also important to remember that being facings consequences would require
A) The intentional action of either a state prosecutor or an injured private party B) The involvement of a human being as a judge to interpret the facts and applicable rules
When you look at it from that angle, it's obvious why organizations like META just do the research, imho.