Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by Palomides on Thursday February 13, 2025 @04:30PM
(#43041630)
I get what you're saying, but "in some places, in some disciplines, you could be at a livable level of poverty" is not a very persuasive point
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by dgacmu on Thursday February 13, 2025 @05:39PM
(#43042364)
Grad school is a money loser in CS for people from the US. There's no argument. But I did end up having my net worth increase over the course of it, and it was a fantastic experience. In Boston, even - a pretty HCOL area. And in the end, being "rich but less rich than my FAANG friends" isn't the worst outcome. :)
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by naniwaduni on Thursday February 13, 2025 @05:23PM
(#43042203)
The MIT "living wage" figures are, to put it lightly, utterly deranged; more a statement of the purveyors's ideal of a first-world standard of living than a reflection of reality. If they are to be believed, then evidently grad students—or really like, half the population??—must not be alive.
As maligned as the poverty lines are—and they do have plenty of shortcomings—they are still a far closer approximation of "the true cost of living in a modern economy" than this drivel.
†No, really, go compare the "living wage" figures (https://livingwage.mit.edu/) with AMI stats (https://ami-lookup-tool.fanniemae.com/).
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by lazyasciiart on Thursday February 13, 2025 @07:06PM
(#43043073)
You may not have understood the concept of a living wage. For a start, a living wage is expected to support saving for retirement and future expenses like a new car, or eventually buying a house. "People can live on $100/week for six weeks!!!" is not a relevant counter point to "$100/week is not a living wage."
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by nemomarx on Thursday February 13, 2025 @05:42PM
(#43042413)
generally "living wage" in these contexts also covers like, a house and being able to take care of dependents + maybe a partner?
Which is generally above poverty levels right
Re:Are PhDs losing lustre? Why fewer students are enrolling ...
by naniwaduni on Thursday February 13, 2025 @06:31PM
(#43042829)
It's broken down by number of working adults and children.
There's even a website: https://csstipendrankings.org/
I disagree a little with their cost of living calculations - they're off in both directions for areas I know reasonably well. Most Ph.D. students can live for something under the MIT living wage calculations if they choose -- transportation costs are overstated for most places (e.g., CMU students get a free regional bus pass; MIT students get subsidized transit passes, etc.). Often the medical costs are subsidized as well -- we cover the full cost of (individual) health insurance for Ph.D. students.
You're not going to be banking much, but in CS, it's OK at many institutions, particularly when you factor in summer internship income.