News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by HeikoBehrens on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @09:33AM (#43025770)
FWIW, we considered this technique back at Pebble to make notifications more actionable and even filed a patent for that (sorry!) https://patents.justia.com/patent/9411785

Back then on iOS via ANCS, the watches wouldn't receive much more than the textual payload you'd see on the phone. We envisioned to be working with partners such as WhatsApp et al. to encode deep links/message ids into the message so one could respond directly from the watch.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by palata on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:33AM (#43026356)
Respectfully: how the hell would that be a valid patent? Feels like patenting the idea of writing text in white on white on a Word document such that you don't lose it but it doesn't get printed.

It's just insane to ever call that "an invention".

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by rwmj on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:51AM (#43026538)
Companies acquire indefensible patents all the time. They are used in bulk to threaten smaller competitors ("we've got 500 patents in this field, better not bring your product to market"). This is one reason why patents can be terrible for competition.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by neilv on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:01AM (#43026667)
About 25 years ago, this was explained to me as "sword patents and shield patents".

Sure, some can use patents as swords, to suppress legitimate competition, or to extract undue rents. But you can also use patents as shields, to protect in various ways against those swords.

If I ran a BigTech (like the original warm-fuzzy Google reputation), I'd be registering any plausible patents, and have lawyers figure out how to freely license-out the ones that weren't key secret sauce, under terms that figuratively poisoned anyone doing illegitimate sword patents.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by palata on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @12:39PM (#43027644)
> If I ran a BigTech

History tells us that those who run a BigTech become crazy narcissists serving their own interests :).

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by neilv on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @12:43PM (#43027682)
For myself, that's a chance I'm willing to take. :)
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by shermantanktop on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:54AM (#43026588)
They are also used in bulk to defend against larger competitors using this type of threat. In a war where the ammunition is garbage, you either lose or you start hoarding garbage.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:55AM (#43026595)
Patents are part of the game you have to play, like it or not. If you don't patent your inventions somebody else will and they will come after you with their lawyers. Patents are used defensively far more often than they are used offensively in these stupid "Intellectual Property" battles.

Because of this, there is absolutely no point in shaming someone for patenting a thing, especially when they are apologetic about it like parent is, and most especially when they are not threatening to weaponize the patent themselves.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:06AM (#43026711)
No, I don't buy it. If the patents are publicly and perpetually freely licensed except for defensive-only purposes, then sure, they're not unethical. Red Hat's patent promise ( https://www.redhat.com/en/about/patent-promise ) is one example. If patents were actually intended for defensive purposes only, then this would be an easy and uncontroversial thing to do. However, in practice this is vanishingly rare, and lawyers fight against it tooth & nail. This tells you that the companies do not actually file them for defensive-only purposes, unlike what you claim.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:36AM (#43026980)
My friend, you really don't know what you are talking about, and getting all riled up like this is not the right way to learn.

Freely licensing your patents doesn't protect you against patent trolls. I wrote out how patent fights work in another comment, but here it is again.

Company A comes to Company B and says, "Hey! You are infringing on one of my patents!"

Company B says, "oh really? Well let me look through my collection of patents and see if you are infringing on any of mine."

Company A says, "oh, um, nevermind, I think I was mistaken."

Company B says, "yes, that's what I thought"

Now, imagine if Company B had already freely licensed all their patents. That defense wouldn't work.

I agree with you that it's a crappy system, but simply standing with your arms folded and saying, "I'm not playing," isn't going to work.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:38AM (#43027006)
Yes, that's the reason for the "except for defensive purposes" part. Quoting from Red Hat's promise:

> Our Promise also does not extend to the actions of a party (including past actions) if at any time the party or its affiliate asserts a patent in proceedings against Red Hat (or its affiliate) or any offering of Red Hat (or its affiliate) (including a cross-claim or counterclaim).

Company B may still consult its portfolio and exercise it against Company A defensively, because Company A revoked its license of Company B's patents by asserting against Company B in the first place.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:51AM (#43027143)
So in other words, Red Hat does not freely license their patents, they say "you are free as long as you don't come after us." Which is exactly the system 99% of companies follow, just more formally stated. Yet you berated the poor guy from Pebble for even obtaining the patent he did??
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:59AM (#43027220)
> Which is exactly the system 99% of companies follow, just more formally stated

Not just formally, but in a legally binding manner, including if the patent is acquired by another company (eg during a company purchase). Even if the original filer has the best intentions, companies change ownership or change legal strategy or go out of business. Patent trolls buy up those patents from closed companies. Legally licensing your patents for defensive-only purposes means they can't ever be used by any of those bad actors.

If the intent of these patents is truly only for defense, then why isn't it common to use a license like this? They lose nothing by it.

> Yet you berated the poor guy from Pebble for even obtaining the patent he did??

Yes. It is IMO unethical to create software patents that aren't covered by such a legally-binding license.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:04AM (#43037308)
"including if the patent is acquired by another company (eg during a company purchase)"

Honest questions, I promise: Is that true? Has that ever been tested in court? Why don't more corporations or patent lawyers advocate for this? Is it because the types of engineers that post on hacker news are requesting it not be done?

Look, nobody likes patent trolls, we all hate weaponized patents. It's great that you want to fix the situation. I just think you are barking up the wrong tree trying to lay guilt trips on engineers for doing what their lawyer advised them to do.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Thursday February 13, 2025 @02:45PM (#43040398)
Nothing is certain in courts, obviously, but Red Hat's license is very explicit that that is the intent:

> Red Hat intends Our Promise to be irrevocable (except as stated herein), and binding and enforceable against Red Hat and assignees of, or successors to, Red Hat’s patents (and any patents directly or indirectly issuing from Red Hat’s patent applications). As part of Our Promise, if Red Hat sells, exclusively licenses, or otherwise assigns or transfers patents or patent applications to a party, we will require the party to agree in writing to be bound to Our Promise for those patents and for patents directly or indirectly issuing on those patent applications. We will also require the party to agree in writing to so bind its own assignees, transferees, and exclusive licensees.

If a court somehow overturned that, I wouldn't hold it against the patent filer.

> Why don't more corporations or patent lawyers advocate for this?

My opinion is it's because the patents have value as a weapon, not only for defense (this here is my disagreement with your original claim that these patents only exist for defense). De-fusing the weapon by using a legally binding license like this lowers the value of the patent in a potential purchase scenario. In other words: "money."

> I just think you are barking up the wrong tree trying to lay guilt trips on engineers for doing what their lawyer advised them to do.

Nah. If you do a bad thing, you are responsible for the bad thing you did. I think the OP can probably handle a little light scolding from some anonymous person on an Internet forum. My hope is that they, and other readers, learn from this mistake and don't do it again.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by fortran77 on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:42AM (#43027042)
Perhaps you shouldn't hijack every thread about anything and make it about patents.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Thursday February 13, 2025 @09:13AM (#43036006)
I replied to one comment thread. Perhaps you should put on your big boy pants and use the little [-] thing to minimize threads you aren't interested in reading.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by palata on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @12:40PM (#43027655)
> Because of this, there is absolutely no point in shaming someone for patenting a thing

Well I wouldn't shame someone whose job was to patent something absurd. I was just saying that this is not an invention at all, and any system that protects that "innovation" is a broken system.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by detourdog on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:41AM (#43026440)
I think the magic is in the context of Unicode. Which also makes it almost twice as ridiculous from my point of view. Because it seems to be doing exactly what unicode is meant to do.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by dboreham on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @12:18PM (#43027407)
Almost all filed patents are invalid.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by palata on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @12:46PM (#43027708)
But doesn't it say that the whole patent system is broken? I get the "you pay to file a patent, it's your problem if it's invalid in the end". But the side effect of that is that whether it's valid or not, it's a tool you can use to scare those who don't have the resources to go to court.

It's like those completely abusive non-compete clauses in work contracts (yes in some countries that's the norm). They are completely abusive and therefore illegal. But it still hurts the employee: I have friends who have been declined a job in a company because the company did not want to take any risk. The company was like "okay, it's most likely an invalid clause, but if your previous employer sues us it will anyway cost resources we don't want to spend, so we'd rather not hire you". So an illegal, invalid clause had the effect that the company who abused it wanted. Which means it's a broken system.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by numpad0 on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @02:46PM (#43029016)
fun fact: dSLR lenses are patented all the time. Claims are basically "I made it and it works". And it's considered ok.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @09:48AM (#43025895)
So whoever now owns that patent (Google? maybe some patent troll picked it up?) could, in theory, sue the author of this article for patent infringement, right? Even though they invented it independently and never once used or looked at your patent. Do you think you made the world a better place or a worse place by filing that patent?
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by RealityVoid on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:19AM (#43026212)
_Can_ they sue them for patent infringement? They just described a technique (that you can see in the patent filing anyway) and not selling a product based on it. I think there's nothing to sue here. I'm curious is my understanding of this is correct.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:10AM (#43026748)
One of the benefits of the patent system (that now seems to be far outweighed by negatives) is that patents are public information. Your invention is documented for all to see. I don't think that someone writing about public information is a punishable office, but IANAL
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by singleshot_ on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:29AM (#43026334)
“Except as otherwise provided… whoever without authority… uses… any patented invention… infringes[.]” 35 usc 271
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:57AM (#43026609)
Please see my comment about about the sad necessity for patents

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43026595

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by ooterness on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:33AM (#43026355)
As a wise man once said: "Don't hate the player, hate the game."
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by shermantanktop on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:55AM (#43026594)
Where’d the game come from? Hint: the players.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:59AM (#43026645)
First of all, it's not just a game, it's an outright battle to the death (of your company). Sure, you can choose not to wield patents, even in self defense, but good luck with that.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:34AM (#43026948)
You can also choose to legally declare that your patents may only be used for defensive purposes. But no one ever does this, because they do not actually intend to use them only for defensive purposes. This is a bogus defense of software patents.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:38AM (#43027000)
See my other comments to you. Sometimes the threat of a good offensive weapon is the best defense. It's kinda like a nuclear arms race
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by shermantanktop on Thursday February 13, 2025 @05:07PM (#43042023)
Nope. That’s not how piles of patents are wielded defensively by the big companies. They don’t protect their IP with defensive patents, they defend their company using the threat of using unrelated patents offensively against the attacker.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Friday February 14, 2025 @09:31AM (#43048685)
Yes, I know. That's what this part of my post means:

> may only be used for defensive purposes

It's done with a clause in the public license like "if you sue us, then we revoke this license to you and may in turn sue you." You retain the MAD defensive benefit of the patents, while also not hampering innovation with your patent's existence. If the patents truly exist only for defense, then there is no reason not to do this.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by Hizonner on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:18AM (#43026201)
Well, given that the technique itself makes the world a worse place, anything that impedes its use is probably positive...

And, no, they couldn't do anything meaningful to the author of the article. They could get them ordered not to do it any more, and they could recover their economic damages... which are obviously zero.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by IncreasePosts on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:29AM (#43026330)
No. The author could not be sued for this successfully. All they did was write a blog post about an interesting technique. They could literally read the patent application and write a blog post about that, assuming the methods are the same.

What percentage of your actions are based around making the world a better place, instead of personal fulfillment or gain?

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:34AM (#43026363)
> All they did was write a blog post about an interesting technique. They could literally read the patent application and write a blog post about that, assuming the methods are the same.

Okay, change "sue" to "prevent from creating a marketable product without paying a royalty to the patent owner in return for having provided nothing of value." The point remains.

> What percentage of your actions are based around making the world a better place, instead of personal fulfillment or gain?

Many harms are unavoidable, but I make a point to at least not go out of my way to make it a worse place, for example by filing software patents. The company I work for provides financial bonuses for filing software patents, and I will never participate in that program. (I've even tried to convince the lawyers to license our patents similar to Red Hat's open patent promise, because they claim they are intended only to be used defensively... but no luck so far.)

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by rolph on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:39AM (#43027016)
consider how far you reach to make the world better.

1) thats really good im gonna, strive to keep it.

2) " " tell all and those who want will build one.

3) " " make lots and give them to everyone.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by JadeNB on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @09:59AM (#43026005)
> Do you think you made the world a better place or a worse place by filing that patent?

Come on, what does this contribute to this conversation? The poster clearly is aware of the drawbacks of such patents, and didn't clearly play any role in filing the patent (they said "we … filed it," not "I filed it"). This kind of response just encourages people not to mention such things; it can't possibly change their past behavior, and, since Pebble the company per se doesn't exist any more, is also unlikely to change future behavior.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by coldpie on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:26AM (#43026295)
> The poster clearly is aware of the drawbacks of such patents, and didn't clearly play any role in filing the patent (they said "we … filed it," not "I filed it").

A person with the same name as that commenter is listed as an inventor on the patent.

> it can't possibly change their past behavior

Obviously, but it can change future behavior. Maybe realizing that they made the world a worse place by filing that patent will prevent them, or a reader of this discussion, from doing it again in future.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by delian66 on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @09:54AM (#43025945)
Do you think your comment made the world, and HN specifically a better place?
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by Imustaskforhelp on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:45AM (#43026470)
I think so , yes , it made me be re aware of the patent troll scam in the USA.

In fact it is your comment which to me seems a little hateful , yes the above comment also felt a little hateful

Hate doesn't counter Hate , I guess.

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by RIMR on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:51AM (#43026555)
Yes, calling out unethical practices makes the world a better place by discouraging unethical practices.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by krupan on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @11:04AM (#43026686)
Berating people for filing patents in self defense is not how we fix this problem. The government put these rules in place. Businesses have to at least accumulate patents to use defensively (you found a patent of yours that you think I'm violating? Well let me do a quick search through the patents I have...what's that? Nevermind, I'm not actually infringing your patent? Good, that's what I thought.)
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by frereit on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:17AM (#43026196)
Would this patent cover just the encoding alone? The first sentence says: > A method, apparatus, and system relating to embedding hidden content within a Unicode message and using the hidden content to perform a particular computer action.

So, in my extremely unqualified opinion, just the encoding technique alone is not covered by the patent, only when combined with some action performed based on the encoding?

Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by Etheryte on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:55AM (#43026593)
Hopefully a wholly undefendable patent, you're essentially trying to patent the Unicode spec. The rest of it is perform an action in response to a text message which clearly isn't novel.
Re:Smuggling arbitrary data through an emoji by detourdog on Wednesday February 12, 2025 @10:39AM (#43026421)
Just curious this seems like simple digital Steganography or maybe even even the same as Shannon's boolean gate work. Do you think the patent is defendable in court?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steganography