News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @11:12AM (#4301808)
Excellent. I can now express my view of heartily not giving a damn about my vendors' political opinions by reading a book bought at Amazon while eating a sandwich bought at Chik-Fil-A.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:19PM (#4302113)
I'm curious why you talk about it like its a good thing. Market pressure to get rid of incorrect social views is the only alternative to legislative action to force such change.

As a consumer buying a product, there are lots of things I value besides just the product I'm getting. I care about service, etc. Not being terrible people is also something I value, and I don't see anything wrong with reflecting that in my purchasing decisions.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by lkbm on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:35PM (#4302208)
Political advertising would also work.

I'm opposed to dragging the vitriolic "I refuse to work with you because you're a Publican/Democrat/conservative/liberal/bleeding-heart/homophobe' behavior into a wider arena of life. I'm friends with and work with Republicans, Democrats, Libertarians, etc. and that's a GOOD thing. I don't want a world where our political differences mean we can't function as a society. I can't get my haircut there--he's racist or sexist or homophobic. No, he's a normally-okay dude who cuts my hair well.

I don't know how to best express this. Jon Stewart kind of talked about it at the Rally for Sanity when he mentioned how we don't cut people off for having a McCain bumper sticker.

Step one is to realize that being homophobic doesn't make you "terrible people". Three hundred years ago pretty much everyone was racist, sexist, and homophobic, but were in general as decent people as we are today; they just had some terrible beliefs, and terrible behaviors that came along with those beliefs.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by alecdibble on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:17PM (#4302460)
> Step one is to realize that being homophobic doesn't make you "terrible people". Three hundred years ago pretty much everyone was racist, sexist, and homophobic, but were in general as decent people as we are today; they just had some terrible beliefs, and terrible behaviors that came along with those beliefs.

Are they really decent if they were racist/sexist/homophobic? Just because people were nice to others that didn't fit into their hatepool, I do not feel that makes them generally "decent". No matter what time period you look at, there were people that didn't agree with these "social norms". I would call the such occurrences "decent people".

I understand your message about party differences/etc. but I feel there is a line that can get crossed between differing perspectives and hateful behavior. The latter should not be tolerated, in my opinion.

[deleted]
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by mortenjorck on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:24PM (#4302495)
It would be nice if it were that Godwinningly simple.

You don't have to commit genocide to be racist, you don't have to commit rape to be sexist, you don't have to engage in oppression to be homophobic.

People are complicated. No one is perfect. Everyone has good and bad qualities.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by danielweber on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:27PM (#4302512)
What if you have the incorrect social views, as determined by the society at large?

Let's say you were in 1880's Deep South and thought black should vote. Do you think there's no problem if people in town refuse to sell you goods for that? Is a Hollywood blacklist just something to shrug off.

Obviously you should not be forced, as an individual, to purchase goods or services from someone else you don't like. Going any further than that and society can strangle minority viewpoints almost as oppressively as government. If I refuse to deal with you, or anyone who deals with you, or anyone who deals with anyone who deals with you, than we move away from a pluralistic society towards one where the group most in charge at a given moment wins.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by slurgfest on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:23PM (#4302137)
I'm curious about the method by which one determines when a social view is "incorrect." Take a survey?

What if I think that marriage should be defined religiously by a religious institution rather than legally by the state? I guess I am "incorrect" for not supporting state-recognized gay marriage. But how was I supposed to determine this before you came along to tell me?

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:28PM (#4302176)
Were bans on interracial marriage incorrect? Was slavery incorrect? I'm not saying bans on gay marriage are as bad as slavery, obviously, but rather that there are certain issues which over the course of history will become generally accepted social truth. That is, of course, the only sort of "correctness" that is possible on a social issue.

Marriage, in the legal sense, just a particular type of contract, long recognized because of how commonly people wanted to enter into a particular type of economic arrangement. It is non-sensical to think religious institutions should have any say in defining this type of contract, any more than they have a say in defining the contracts that pertain to, say, residential leases. Should religious institutions be able to use Biblical scripture to argue that implied in any residential lease is a warranty that the landlord will have running water, etc? Of course not, that is the exclusive domain of the secular courts. The marriage contract, being no different, should be treated no differently.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:49PM (#4302300)
I'm not sure how your first paragraph differs from saying that some social consensus, at some point in time, constitutes ethics, for no other reason than that consensus.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by phillmv on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:29PM (#4302179)
>how was I supposed to determine this before you came along to tell me?

You hear other people's opinions and you make up your mind. It's painfully obvious that there isn't an objective repository for this sort of thing; the whole notion of 'inalienable rights" is rather recent and fluffy to begin with.

>What if I think that marriage should be defined religiously by a religious institution rather than legally by the state?

Yet we live in a society where marriage is legally defined. It's fine to work against abolishing the institution of marriage, but if that's the case witholding that legal definition from an arbitrary segment of the population becomes a petty argument over semantics.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by slurgfest on Friday July 27, 2012 @05:05PM (#4303572)
I'm not withholding anything from anybody.

If I have any objection here, it's to the notion of "socially correct." What is the epistemology of social correctness?

From the response it seems there is none, there are just people who are applying force. I don't agree with that.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by phillmv on Friday July 27, 2012 @05:52PM (#4303762)
*shrug

Welcome to every social interaction ever. You come up with an argument and you get people to agree with it.

Re: "socially correct", do you agree with anti-miscegenation laws? If not, why? The argument for gay people is virtually identical.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by natrius on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:35PM (#4302212)
Equal protection and treatment by one's government is so widely accepted (in theory) that it's a part of the U.S. Constitution[1]. It also doesn't conflict with your position.

[1] Granted, the Civil War Amendments were imposed under martial law, but calls for the repeal of the 14th Amendment are rare.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by phillmv on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:25PM (#4302149)
>Market pressure to get rid of incorrect social views is the only alternative to legislative action to force such change.

Thank you.

This is why it infuriates me when you see lolbertarians going about how you shouldn't care. Of all people they should be the ones to recognize why this sort of stuff… matters.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by learc83 on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:36PM (#4302216)
>lolbertarians

That was stupid, this isn't reddit.

libertarians do believe that market pressure should be used instead of government coercion. You'll definitely find plenty of them who do support a boycott of chick-fil-a.

At the same time there are other libertarians who don't support a boycott because they believe that people are entitled to hold opinions that differ from their own.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:41PM (#4302244)
> At the same time there are other libertarians who don't support a boycott because they believe that people are entitled to hold opinions that differ from their own.

There is a difference between boycotting people because they have different opinions, and refusing to give money to a company who turns around and uses it to actively support anti-gay legislation.

The CEO of Chick-fil-A is like 90. If he was just homophobic, sexist, etc, in private, it wouldn't make news anywhere.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by learc83 on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:56PM (#4302337)
>There is a difference between boycotting people because they have different opinions, and refusing to give money to a company who turns around and uses it to actively support anti-gay legislation.

I respect anyone's choice to do so.

However, for me personally I see trying to convince other people to share your opinion as just an extension of having an opinion in the first place.

I wouldn't vote for a law to ban gay marriage, but I'd still patronize a business who's owner did.

Unless that owner was doing something more than peacefully trying to coerce people to vote for said law.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:25PM (#4302836)
There is a difference between "I can't work with you" and "I'm not giving money to you, which you turn around and use to try to take rights away from a minority group."
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by blackbird_t on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:05PM (#4302383)
If the gay community would just leave this company alone he wouldn't be forced to stand up for his views (in public) in the first place. I've known this family for years. They are good people and don't wish any ill will on anyone regardless of their views. The gay community just won't accept the fact that Chick-fil-A will never agree with their moral stance. BTW, this has been going on for years.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by msbarnett on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:34PM (#4302548)
Oh those mean gays, why won't they just leave this poor family alone and let this family continue to pour millions of dollars into keeping them a permanent underclass who will never enjoy the same rights as straight people in peace??

Obviously being a massive funder of a campaign against equal rights for the gay community is totally a neutral position which in no way harms gay people, but pointing out the fact that they've been doing it? Why, that makes gay people big meanies who are attacking this nice family for no reason.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by blackbird_t on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:58PM (#4302692)
Gay activists is a more appropriate term. And many people might agree with you they are "big meanies" looking for a fight.

As far as funding campaigns that support their moral views as a "private" company, why is that so bothersome? They don't get out in front of a microphone in the public media and state this fact every time they get the chance. Although Bezos seems to think this is a good idea.

Gay right=Civil right=Yeah right

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by kbolino on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:49PM (#4302993)
>>> Gay activists is a more appropriate term.

What is Focus on the Family? Or the Family Research Council? Eagle Forum?

>>> And many people might agree with you they are "big meanies" looking for a fight.

They are "looking for a fight" to be fought in the public square, in legislatures and courts, over what many of them consider to be a legal injustice. Is this not the intended form of democracy?

>>> As far as funding campaigns that support their moral views as a "private" company, why is that so bothersome?

Why is it so bothersome to point this fact out? If they do not wish to be injured by the information, then they have the power to make it false.

>>> They don't get out in front of a microphone in the public media and state this fact every time they get the chance.

The fact they were (previously) not very vocal about their views negates them how?

>>> Although Bezos seems to think this is a good idea.

As is his right? Just like the Cathy family has the same right?

>>> Gay right=Civil right=Yeah right

Disagreement does not require a dismissive attitude. I could just as easily denigrate your opinions and your position, but that benefits no one.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by kbolino on Monday July 30, 2012 @12:17AM (#4310884)
For what it's worth, I was not at the time aware of the mayors of Boston and Chicago saying they would oppose the expansion of Chik-fil-A in their cities. I wholeheartedly disagree with those actions, and I support Chik-fil-A in their business goal of selling tasty chicken to whomever will buy it. I still disagree with their political goals, but their freedoms as an enterprise should not be taken away because of them.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:30PM (#4302866)
> As far as funding campaigns that support their moral views as a "private" company, why is that so bothersome?

When you bring your views into the public square by funding public campaigns to espouse those views, you can't complain when people react to those views.

Chick-fil-A did something far stronger than simply get on a microphone in the public media and argue a particular viewpoint. It spent millions of dollars trying to affect legislation.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by stephencanon on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:57PM (#4302685)
There are a variety of phrases that come to mind to describe someone who wants to withhold basic privileges from other people because they believe a man in the sky commands it.

"good people" is not among them.

> Chick-fil-A will never agree with their moral stance

There's the problem. Morals are neither here nor there. You can believe that homosexuality is wrong and still recognize that allowing homosexuals to enter into a civil marriage contract is just and right. I think lying is wrong, but I wouldn't try to advance legislation that prevents liars from getting married.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by monkeyfacebag on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:16PM (#4302455)
Can you be more specific about what the gay community has done to this person that forced him to stand up for his views in public? I am genuinely ignorant here and would like some information.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by blackbird_t on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:36PM (#4302550)
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by monkeyfacebag on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:14PM (#4302774)
OK, I want to hear you out, but I have major problems with this evidence. First, in what way are the mayor of Boston and the Jim Henson company emissaries from the gay community? Second, this article references things that happened after Dan Cathy's remarks. You indicated that there were incidents prior to (indeed causing) those remarks to be made. I'm aware of all the stuff going on now, but you led me to believe there was some history I was unaware of. Can you explain?
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:32PM (#4302882)
What's wrong with Jim Henson Co's actions? If you don't like a person or company and what they stand for, you're free not to work with them.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by gergles on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:25PM (#4302503)
They don't wish any ill will on them, they just want to deny them a civil right. You know, no big deal.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by blackbird_t on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:41PM (#4302578)
The court's don't agree with your loose definition of civil rights and neither do I.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by gergles on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:54PM (#4302669)
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by blackbird_t on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:30PM (#4302871)
Weak argument... This is specifically talking about race not personal preference. Nice try though.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by kbolino on Friday July 27, 2012 @03:42PM (#4303259)
As marriages are (generally) not arranged in this country, all marriages are about personal preferences. Mildred Loving, a black woman, chose a white man to marry. She was as free to marry a black man as any gay person is free to marry a straight person of the opposite sex. The case is completely relevant, and saying that "race is not a choice" is immaterial to the matter; the trial was not about race, it was about the freedom to marry the person of one's choosing.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:33PM (#4302887)
No, Loving v. Virginia is not just specifically about race. It recognizes marriage as one of the fundamental rights.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:50PM (#4302629)
Marriage is a fundamental right according to the supreme court.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:31PM (#4302532)
I question how good they can be given their donations to anti-gay groups. It's one thing to disagree morally with someone's stance on something like gay marriage. It's something else entirely to fund campaigns to take away other peoples' rights. That's a morally bad act.

Nobody is mad at Chick-fil-A for being bigoted in the privacy of their own home. They're mad at Chick-fil-A for their actions and for how they spend their money on bigoted campaigns.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by sigzero on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:56PM (#4302681)
Technically they never had that right and won't until the Supreme Court rules on it. So they aren't taking away anything at all. Currently in the majority of States "marriage equality" is one man can marry one woman and that applies to everyone.

The big deal is that someone that is "famous" said publicly that he doesn't support gay marriage. The LGBT movement, "tolerant" as they are, just can't have that.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by gergles on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:04PM (#4302730)
The Supreme Court did rule on it. In the 60s:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loving_v._virginia

"Marriage is one of the "basic civil rights of man," fundamental to our very existence and survival.... "

There is also a significant difference between "not supporting" something and campaigning to prevent anyone from doing it. I "don't support" tax-exempt religion, but I'm not giving money to a lobbying group to try to end it.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by kbolino on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:38PM (#4302915)
Insofar as the discussion remains civil, either both sides are guilty of "intolerance" or neither are. When one side makes unreasonable demands, and carries them into action, then we can begin to discuss an imbalance of tolerance.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:26PM (#4302849)
No, the big deal is that the CEO of a huge company donated millions to fund anti-gay legislation. That's a huge difference.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by phillmv on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:47PM (#4302285)
>At the same time there are other libertarians who don't support a boycott because they believe that people are entitled to hold opinions that differ from their own.

Whereas I, a progressive libertarian (free-market progressive?) believe that worldview to be inconsistent with libertarianism, hence lolbertarian.

Companies, governments, organizations, institutions at large all exert and respond to their own social pressures and cannot be considered in isolation thereof.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:01PM (#4302359)
One of the strongest arguments for free speech is the practical impossibility of knowing which views are and aren't correct.

Another is the fact that pretty much every apparatus ever erected for the enforcement of "correct views" has ultimately been corrupted and abused.

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @01:29PM (#4302522)
Free speech entitles you to speak your mind. It doesn't entitle you to be free from dislike and rebuke for the things you say.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @02:38PM (#4302920)
Who says it does? But I myself won't dislike and rebuke people simply for disagreeing with me.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @03:43PM (#4303266)
It's ridiculous to call "spending millions funding bigotry" as a matter of simple "disagreement."
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @06:05PM (#4303806)
So your respect for someone's right to a differing opinion stops at the point you regard them as "bigoted." And any third party disagreeing with you about that person's right to their opinion, they're wrong too.

What could possibly go wrong?

Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage by nacker on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:33PM (#4302198)
"incorrect social views" ?

Please let me know where to find the official canon of "correct social views", as I am anxious not to end up in the Gulag accidentally.