Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage
by rayiner on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:28PM
(#4302176)
Were bans on interracial marriage incorrect? Was slavery incorrect? I'm not saying bans on gay marriage are as bad as slavery, obviously, but rather that there are certain issues which over the course of history will become generally accepted social truth. That is, of course, the only sort of "correctness" that is possible on a social issue.
Marriage, in the legal sense, just a particular type of contract, long recognized because of how commonly people wanted to enter into a particular type of economic arrangement. It is non-sensical to think religious institutions should have any say in defining this type of contract, any more than they have a say in defining the contracts that pertain to, say, residential leases. Should religious institutions be able to use Biblical scripture to argue that implied in any residential lease is a warranty that the landlord will have running water, etc? Of course not, that is the exclusive domain of the secular courts. The marriage contract, being no different, should be treated no differently.
Re:Bezos pledges $2.6M to support same sex marriage
by chernevik on Friday July 27, 2012 @12:49PM
(#4302300)
I'm not sure how your first paragraph differs from saying that some social consensus, at some point in time, constitutes ethics, for no other reason than that consensus.
Marriage, in the legal sense, just a particular type of contract, long recognized because of how commonly people wanted to enter into a particular type of economic arrangement. It is non-sensical to think religious institutions should have any say in defining this type of contract, any more than they have a say in defining the contracts that pertain to, say, residential leases. Should religious institutions be able to use Biblical scripture to argue that implied in any residential lease is a warranty that the landlord will have running water, etc? Of course not, that is the exclusive domain of the secular courts. The marriage contract, being no different, should be treated no differently.