News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by solumos on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:30PM (#42992456)
The big problem with health insurance is that it accounts for 17% of the US GDP, so although it's parasitic for everyone involved, it's basically indispensable to the economy. That's a big reason why the Affordable Care Act panned out the way it did, as a partnership with the insurance companies.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by n2d4 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:37PM (#42992515)
That's not how the economy works though — the GDP is correlated, not causated, with economic strength. What drives the economy in the end is positive-sum value creation, not trade in itself (although without any market failures, trade tends to create value). The only reason we use GDP as a measure is because actual subjective value created is very hard to measure.

If I start an extortion business, and make you pay me money in order for me to not kidnap your family, this will increase the GDP but not economic strength. This is particularly obvious during wartime, when GDP is artificially inflated, but the actual economy tends to be doing very badly regardless.

In other words, a trade that harms one party more than it helps the other makes the economy worse — regardless of how it affects GDP.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by orwin on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:33PM (#42993047)
But fiscal and debt policies are built on GDP as primary indicator. That is why recently, some states/nations privileged GDP growth over economic wellbeing (gambling is such any easy example)
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by rented_mule on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:52PM (#42993222)
Goodhart's law strikes again. It's one of those things that explains so many problems in the world once you understand it. I wish there were ways around it, but I think it's a natural thing in matters involving a lot of people.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by knome on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:35PM (#42992503)
>it accounts for 17% of the US GDP, so although it's parasitic for everyone involved, it's basically indispensable to the economy

if people weren't forced to spend it on healthcare, they would spend it elsewhere. if healthcare was free tomorrow, the GDP would be fine, just redistributed.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by darth_avocado on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:48PM (#42992636)
Also, if people get the medical attention they need on time, they’d be more productive and also be more active in the economy. The loss of productivity coming from inadequate healthcare because of insurance coverages is in the order of tens of Billions annually.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by gruez on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:58PM (#42992726)
>Also, if people get the medical attention they need on time

Unclear whether that would bear fruit, given how socialized healthcare systems have a bad reputation of long wait times.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by semi-extrinsic on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:39PM (#42993101)
I think this is an incorrect impression caused by cherry-picking data. E.g. in the dataset linked below, while some European countries have longer waiting times for elective surgery, they have between 2x and 10x shorter waiting times than the US when it comes to seeing a primary physician. Which is arguably one of the most important metrics for getting people medical attention on time.

Furthermore, in many non-US countries you have "controversial" things like emergency contraceptives being prescription free, so people don't even need to see a doctor in the first place. Imagine how much more efficient that is.

https://www.statista.com/chart/33079/average-waiting-times-f...

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by mike_hearn on Monday February 10, 2025 @03:09AM (#42997953)
That page says the lowest waiting times for surgeries are the USA and Switzerland, which has a mostly private healthcare system and private health insurance.

It also claims waiting times for a GP are only ten days on average in the UK which doesn't sound right given the difficulty people have even getting an appointment booked at all lately. I wonder how they compute these numbers.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by darth_avocado on Sunday February 09, 2025 @03:12PM (#42993435)
One thing I don’t like about discourse around healthcare is that we automatically talk about socialized healthcare systems being bad.

Asking for more transparency and accountability in insurance companies is not unreasonable. You pay thousands of dollars every year to these conpanies only to have your medical procedure delayed because the insurance doesn’t think it’s necessary. If you can’t set up a system that requires insurance to fulfill their duty, make health insurance non mandatory and set up a public system with more accountability. Right now these companies want to have their cake and eat it too.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by krupan on Sunday February 09, 2025 @03:58PM (#42993904)
That's funny because I am disappointed that so many people talk as if socialized healthcare is the miracle cure for all our woes.

There are a couple things you just can't get around in any society. The Law of Supply and Demand, and that corporations serve their customers.

That second one is the number one problem we have currently in the US. We, the patients, are not the customer. We are are basically a cost of doing business for the "insurance" companies and medical providers.

Socialized medicine aims to solve this problem by removing all insurance companies and becoming the single customer for all medical providers, and then dictating how much they will pay. Due to Supply and Demand, if this single customer doesn't offer to pay enough, then the supply of medical care will go down. Again in this scenario, you and I are not the customer. If we don't like this reduction in supply, we don't have much we can do. We aren't allowed to offer to pay more to get what we want. If the government offers to pay more, the supply of medical care will go up, but where does that money come from? You and I, but again, we have almost no say in this.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by rstuart4133 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @06:47PM (#42995357)
Here is an observation from someone in a country (Australia) that has mixed public and private. In my country we are continually bombarded with news stories about how bad the public system is. This was puzzling to me, because after experiencing both I think you would be mad to use a private hospital if a public one was available.

There are two dynamics at play. The private hospital's customers aren't the patients, it's the doctors. It's the doctors that chose which hospital their customers go to. Thus if the doctor makes a mistake (or the hospital for that matter), it's in the hospitals interests to suppress the news. The information you do see about them is mostly paid advertising. The masters of the public hospitals on the other hand are the politicians. The opposition picks up on each and every failure in a public hospital, and parades it to every media outlet they can find to show had bad at the government in power is. Thus most of the news you here about public hospitals is bad, often very bad, and its a near continuous stream of unflattering news.

This means the public hospitals are terrified of making mistakes because it will be publicised. There are literally posters in every public hospital ward advising you how to get 2nd opinions, who you can lodge complains with, and urging you to discuss any concerns with nursing staff. They will follow them up, and they will discipline / exclude doctors that cause trouble. They are free after all, so if the patient can't pay the doctor has no choice. The net result is the public hospitals the standard of care from the patients point of view is usually outstanding. Meanwhile, I've had a father-in-law with heart problems literally half carried out of a private hospital, the nursing assuring us he was fine. I think they needed the bed for a patient paying higher fees. My father-in-law died from the condition a couple of weeks later.

It is true that free public hospitals are under funded, and chronically overloaded. Maybe that's probably a tragedy of the commons. The result is non-life threatening treatment can take a long while if you want it for free. But, the public hospitals do take fee paying patients. Insurance companies do pay those fees. When that happens I haven't noticed any wait times. In other words the USA system is available to those who can afford it, and those who can't wait. The major difference with the USA is they don't have the "free" option. The "wait times" thing you referred to is therefore 1/2 true, 1/2 myth.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by wahnfrieden on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:39PM (#42992525)
They would also be healthier to contribute other economically productive labor and organization. When people get sick or die they stop working.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by jimt1234 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:46PM (#42992622)
And more than half of my 50s-year-old friends would be able to retire from jobs where they do the bare minimum just to maintain their health insurance.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by p3rls on Sunday February 09, 2025 @06:51PM (#42995396)
Won't someone think of the 50-year-old office workers?
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by mulmen on Thursday February 13, 2025 @03:57PM (#43041247)
Is it your assertion that we should not care about 50 year old office workers?
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by burnte on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:40PM (#42992540)
Yeah, going single payer alone could reduce that 17% to 13%, maybe more, just through eliminating all the barriers insurers put up to providers being paid and administrative overhead.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by gruez on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:57PM (#42992720)
Source? A study from KFF puts "administration" responsible for only 12% of the increase the US pays over comparable countries, or less than 1 percentage points.

[1] https://www.healthsystemtracker.org/brief/what-drives-health...

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by istjohn on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:04PM (#42992768)
> Administrative costs include spending on running governmental health programs and overhead from insurers, but exclude administrative expenditures from healthcare providers.

From what I've read, healthcare providers spend an inordinant amount of time and effort dealing with insurance companies.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by rickydroll on Sunday February 09, 2025 @03:44PM (#42993763)
Don't forget the overhead created by PBMs and when insurance companies also own the PBM and the drugstore
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by burnte on Sunday February 09, 2025 @06:22PM (#42995181)
Correct, it's cost both for insurers AND provider organizations. We have an entire team of humans who call insurance companies on the telephone to verify insurance benefits because most insurers make it EXTREMELY difficult to determine benefits in an automated manner because that makes it easier to bill them. They do everything they can to make it difficult for patients to get coverage and for providers to collect. We're actually working with an AI company to build a tool that uses AI and lots of data to predict with better accuracy benefit coverage. All because insurers want barriers to treatment to lower their costs.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by burnte on Sunday February 09, 2025 @06:32PM (#42995267)
Source is my own lived work experience. In the healthcare companies I've worked in, the size of teams to investigate benefit coverage, to bill, and then to nag insurers to actually pay us works out to roughly 15% of the total staff. This is where _providers_ are about 25% of staff. Add to those salaries the costs of the tools we have to employ to manage it all, track it, and management of all of those folks, and it bloats the cost by 20%.

We're actually working with an AI company to build a tool that uses AI and lots of data to predict with better accuracy benefit coverage. All because insurers want barriers to treatment to lower their costs.

If we went single payer, we would virtually eliminate benefits investigation teams because Medicare is honestly super easy to determine benefits of a patient unless they're on the private Medicare Advantage plans. We could eliminate the need to work with clearing houses as we'd have one payor, not hundreds of payors each with dozens of plans and single-case agreements. RCM departments would shrink because with one payor, providers wouldn't have to constantly nag payors to actually send the money.

The admin overhead is sickening.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by apple4ever on Monday February 10, 2025 @02:23PM (#43004134)
The problem is the overhead of government is even worse.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by psadauskas on Monday February 10, 2025 @03:32PM (#43004780)
[citation needed]
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by burnte on Monday February 10, 2025 @04:35PM (#43005483)
No, Medicare and CMS are run exceptionally well with some of the least fraud and waste in the entire government. CMS is NOT an agency you want to screw with because they come down like a ton of bricks when they find fraud. People go to prison. It's not like being a DoD contractor where they milk billions from the gov't.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by mulmen on Thursday February 13, 2025 @04:02PM (#43041308)
How much worse? How do you know?

Reagan’s Nine Scariest Words quip sounds nice but it works just as well when you replace “government” with “corporate” or “church” or “next door”.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by gruez on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:35PM (#42992504)
>The big problem with health insurance is that it accounts for 17% of the US GDP

Healthcare overall, not insurance. Insurance is just how most of it gets paid. Conflating the two is like saying credit card companies account for 50% (or whatever) of the US GDP because that's how most people pay for their stuff.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by jimt1234 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:00PM (#42992737)
Good point. However, it's almost impossible not to conflate the two (healthcare overall and health insurance) because, unfortunately, health insurance is pretty much required for healthcare. The credit card companies would be a good measure of GDP if they were required for every purchase.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by marbro on Sunday February 09, 2025 @02:14PM (#42992860)
Only fools pay for healthcare with insurance. If a doctor can't convince you to pay directly, don't use his services. Find a better doctor and pay for it yourself.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by Jcampuzano2 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:34PM (#42992497)
If for-profit health insurance is really almost 1/5th of US GDP, something is entirely wrong.

Then again, maybe it makes sense the country that perpetuates suffering all over the globe through being global police and lately just fucking up any sense of stability is the same one where almost 1/5th of our "output" is built on top of making money off of prolonging our own peoples pain and suffering.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by jfengel on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:32PM (#42992477)
Under the ACA, 20% of that is overhead for the insurers. So you could boost the economy by 20% x 17% = a full year's GDP growth for free.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by brightball on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:38PM (#42992518)
There was a way to solve it in a much more economically effective fashion with the Dr. Ben Carson plan. It was (and still is) the only feasible way to fix things long term.
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by EA-3167 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:33PM (#42992483)
It's a closed circle, Tax money comes in, Insurance companies suck it up with a straw.

That same economic activity could still occur with that money, it would just be in other sectors, and ideally ones that produce real economic value.

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by mvdtnz on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:45PM (#42992603)
Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by outside1234 on Sunday February 09, 2025 @01:38PM (#42992520)
So what you are saying is we could get a dividend by getting rid of these parasites of 8%, since Norway spends 9% of GDP on healthcare.

Sounds great to me!

Re:UnitedHealth Is Sick of Everyone Complaining About Its Cl... by diob on Sunday February 09, 2025 @04:21PM (#42994128)
This seems similar to the broken window fallacy.