Re:Excavated: 52 Egyptian Mummies. Over a Dozen Had Mysterio...
by Cpoll on Thursday February 06, 2025 @11:00AM
(#42963647)
> Whatever descendants remain are given legal stewardship.
After 2000 years, those mummies either have too many descendants to count, or none at all.
Re:Excavated: 52 Egyptian Mummies. Over a Dozen Had Mysterio...
by sandworm101 on Thursday February 06, 2025 @11:47AM
(#42964160)
Early egyptology wasnt about science. Ancient egypt was backdrop to many stories from the bible. Historians were looking to learn more about those events from a literate culture that lived alongside them. They were hoping to confirm or elaborate upon christianity. Only later, after almost zero mention was found, did egyptology evolve away from being a religious mission.
Re:Excavated: 52 Egyptian Mummies. Over a Dozen Had Mysterio...
by spiderice on Thursday February 06, 2025 @03:15PM
(#42966065)
> it somehow justifies the speaker doing exactly Y first.
I think you have a difficult time understanding it because you're equating two things that aren't equal. They aren't doing "exactly Y" if Y is "robbing a grave purely for personal profit without consulting with anyone else first". There is a difference between grave robbing and getting permits from governments, researching, displaying findings in a way that benefits others, etc.. The fact that there is an article in popular mechanics about this means that it isn't "exactly Y".
Recovering artifacts “for science” almost never benefits humanity in the short-term (and it's questionable if the average case fares better over the long-term). More often than not over our history, it has involved desecration and has enabled essentialism, and serves to benefit private collectors more than any other party (frequently to the exclusion of scientists).
Maybe the energy used to “get there first” would be better put towards making sure the burial remains are respected, or at least ensuring that whatever descendants remain are given legal stewardship.
All the best,