News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Bobby_Tables on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:01AM (#4296288)
The iOS App Store does the same thing with changing the rules in the middle of the game, but it is not subject to potential irrelevance because it is the only place to get software for iOS devices. So the obvious solution for Apple is to make the Mac App Store the only place to get software for MacOS.

I'm actually a little surprised this didn't happen in 10.8.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by archgrove on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:17AM (#4296384)
Which would instantly kill the Mac as a development platform, and render all previously purchased software irrelevant. This just won't happen, though I can see a version of OS X that does this by default (perhaps on all "non-pro" models).
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Splines on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:30AM (#4296470)
I think the only viable way to do this would be for Apple to make Macs obsolete. Like boiling a frog, if they upscaled the ipad to a desktop-lite device over the next few years, and eventually replaced their fully featured cousins with these devices, they would be able to accomplish it with far much less resistance.

(The iMac may have been a few years too early - they could have positioned the iMac as the trojan horse in this story).

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by St-Clock on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:39AM (#4296533)
But you need a Mac to develop most (i)OS applications and I cannot imagine some of the more complex apps being developed on an iPad-like device.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by untog on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:09PM (#4296720)
It's all about where the mass market is. Just like the low-selling Mac Pro machines, Apple could quite happily keep OS X going for the professional minority that require a POSIX-like experience. The vast majority would use a slightly upgraded iOS, where all of that is hidden away.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by efsavage on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:00PM (#4296670)
"render all previously purchased software irrelevant"

Remember how much business they lost last time they did this (the intel switch, or even the os x switch)? Oh wait...

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by archgrove on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:25PM (#4296829)
OS 9 -> OS X was supported by the Classic runtime for years. PPC to Intel was supported by Rosetta for years.

I suppose if the announced that this was the plan, and gave people years to migrate across, it might be something they'd do. But it would kill basically any technical use of the platform (development, scientific computing). I find it much more likely they'll evolve iOS "up" to support users for whom a closed appliance approach is helpful, whilst adding options to OS X to cater for those who want a more traditional computer but need a bit more help.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by kristofferR on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:16PM (#4296768)
But they didn't - they made Rosetta and supported it a couple of years just to give the developers and the users time to update their apps/computers to Intel versions.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by juliano_q on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:15AM (#4296370)
The day they do this is the day that I will partition my disk, install another OS and never look back. OSX is the only Apple product that is still attractive to me, but I fear that I will have to jump out sooner or later.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by pnathan on Thursday July 26, 2012 @02:37PM (#4297823)
With the shift towards iOSness and sandboxing for Windows & OSX, I don't see myself using anything but Linux - or recommending anything but Linux - for the future.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:39AM (#4296537)
A few reasons why I think this will never happen:

* Taking something away from someone that they've always had (as would be the case with OS X) is very different to never giving them it (as has been the case with iOS).

* People are used to doing stuff that isn't possible with the current restrictions - with iOS they've only ever had those restrictions so they're not aware of what they might be missing out on.

* Developer goodwill would evaporate overnight. I'm not even sure it would be possible to develop on a Mac with this sort of restriction in place given the low level activity you often need to play around with.

* They'd need to develop a parallel mechanism for managing machines or lose what little they have of the Enterprise who are never going to use the app store.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by nsxwolf on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:45PM (#4296965)
They'd need to make a "developer version" of OS X, which would just be OS X with this hypothetical super-Gatekeeper shut off. Then the whole thing just gets silly.

I believe the PC will remain a PC. Take away its nature and you might as well just hand everyone an iPad.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Tyrannosaurs on Friday July 27, 2012 @04:01AM (#4300468)
I can see them changing the language around the various Gatekeeper options and adding additional "are you sure?" warnings to scare people off the allow everything option and unsigned / non-Mac App Store installations but I don't think it will go any further than that.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by bishnu on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:18AM (#4296392)
By default Mountain Lion can only run software from the App Store or by developers Apple has specifically certified. You can tune this restriction both up ("App Store only") and down ("any software can run").
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by masklinn on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:32AM (#4296488)
> by developers Apple has specifically certified.

There is no "special certification", it's just a matter of creating a developer account and generating a certificate.

Also, right-click -> open will bypass the verification under the assumption that if you know about that command, you probably somewhat know what you're doing.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Terretta on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:21AM (#4296420)
By default, you can right click anything from anywhere and choose "Open". It will install/run, and you will never be asked about that program again. But you have to make a conscious decision to run it.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:41AM (#4296554)
That wasn't the case for me.

Gatekeeper was on for appstore and signed applications and I had to disable it to install something I downloaded (ironically because OS X told me to - X11).

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by jonknee on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:18PM (#4296785)
Right click and choose open. Don't double click the app. It definitely works.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Tyrannosaurs on Thursday July 26, 2012 @05:12PM (#4298771)
Ah yes. Didn't know about that.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by gwkoehler on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:28AM (#4296455)
Here's one thing I imagine: 10.9 by default won't allow apps outside the App Store, and you have to buy the 10.9 Server upgrade to have this privilege. They would bundle XCode with it or something to rebrand it as a "developer-friendly" add-on, and developers will be happy to pay, but all the consumers will be chained to the App Store.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by franzus on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:09PM (#4297978)
Heh, good luck with that. Any pro user who needs more functionality than a ToDo-app will be enraged.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by ryanwaggoner on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:44AM (#4296573)
The only thing that gives me comfort is that Apple itself has thousands of developers writing its own code, so they can only cripple their OS X so much. Otherwise what would they do, write all their software on Windows machines?
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Aloisius on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:31AM (#4296474)
That will be the day I go back to Linux.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by spudlyo on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:45PM (#4296962)
I thought the same thing as I was reading John Siracusa's review of Mountain Lion. My stomach sunk when I saw the default 'gatekeeper' options.

    [ ] Mac App Store
    [x] Mac App store and identified developers
    [ ] Anywhere
Seems likely at some point down the road the third option will no longer exist. My next project is getting Linux to run on an old MBP. I still love their hardware, but OSX is getting fuckin' uppity. I realize that this is just an attribute on a binary that you can set and unset, but still, the direction this is going seems clear to me. The further iOSification of OSX is driving me back to Linux on the desktop.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by bishnu on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:02PM (#4297121)
It doesn't seem likely to me at all. In fact I think it's much more likely that you'll see THIS permissions system end up on iOS than vice-versa.

It's actually a fantastic security feature for the average user, so it doesn't worry me that much.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by spudlyo on Thursday July 26, 2012 @05:40PM (#4298894)
Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little... oh fuck it.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by radley on Thursday July 26, 2012 @02:21PM (#4297709)
I seriously doubt it. Can you imagine Adobe's Creative Suite in the Mac App store? Never going to happen.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by spudlyo on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:02PM (#4297930)
Adobe's binaries are already signed, they're an 'identified developer'.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by ohhmaagawd on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:11PM (#4297987)
what's wrong with "identified developers" only? You don't want to pay the $100 a year to be in the mac dev program?
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by spudlyo on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:24PM (#4298074)
What's wrong with Apple trying to control which binaries it will and won't let you run on its OS? Doesn't Apple always have your best interests at heart?
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by Aloisius on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:24PM (#4298072)
Political activists in China no longer able to anonymously release software?
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by technomancy on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:14PM (#4296755)
Why wait? It's clear they would love to do this and are just holding off until they think they can get away with it.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by kristofferR on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:18PM (#4296781)
Since OS X is a better/simpler choice for many people and has WAY more quality supported apps than Linux has. If Linux became the superior choice for most people, a lot of those people would switch.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by larrik on Thursday July 26, 2012 @12:58PM (#4297077)
I disagree with all of your first sentence.

As a full-time Linux/Django and iOS developer, switching over to the Mac from Ubuntu is f'ing painful.

Linux's reputation is far worse than it deserves.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by pavel_lishin on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:07PM (#4297164)
What was painful about it?
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by larrik on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:54PM (#4297538)
Installing software has no consistency.

The built-in terminal is basically broken: -page-up and page-down don't work unless you hold shift -It uses CTRL-C instead of Command-C, unlike the rest of the OS. -I still can't find hotkeys to jump to the beginning of end of line, or skip over entire words (home, end, ctrl-arrow in Linux and Windows)

Home and End are COMPLETELY USELESS on OS X. I have never, in decades of computing thought "Oh, I want to scroll to the top or bottom of this document with one keypress, but not even bring the cursor with me." Given how often during programming I want to select an entire line, this is broken.

The mouse acceleration is stupid. I know you can get used to it, but then try to play StarCraft or something on it, and you will be awful (or at least severely handicapped), because the mouse acceleration system just doesn't work for stuff like that. Also, Lion broke all the work arounds.

The XCode debugger doesn't let me inspect anything that even might be out of scope. Most of the inspections are useless anyway. You can't even see a list of what is in an NSArray (isa = Class, puh-lease).

Viewing hidden files in Finder is hard enough to not remember. Viewing hidden files on a remote server seems to be impossible (maybe it isn't, I don't care). Simply typing in the folder you want to go to is a huge project.

OS X is a poor network neighbor. It rarely detects my other machines, and when it does it's after waiting forever, and it still barely works.

And, oh yeah, it cost me as much as my other 3 computers combined and is the worst of the 4, spec-wise.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by pavel_lishin on Thursday July 26, 2012 @02:17PM (#4297672)
I'm surprised Ctrl-C is a problem for you, especially since you come from a nix background. I'm super ok with it, especially since Cmd-C is the copy command.

Mouse acceleration does suck. It's directly led to a big decrease in the number of amusing photoshops I make; on the plus side, I've started using the keyboard much more.

I haven't had any issues showing hidden files; I just always show them. Going to a specific folder is as simple as either Cmd-Shift-G or typing "open /Some/Folder/Name" in terminal.

You make a lot of good points. I hated OS X at first, but I got used to it; I could probably move to a nix machine, but there would definitely be a long and painful adjustment period, much as there was for you. And as far as the cost, I'm paying for the OS X design, not the hardware - something not everyone agrees with.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by karolist on Friday July 27, 2012 @09:42AM (#4301305)
Agree with everything. Mouse acceleration curve is the deal breaker for me because I couldn't get it close to Windows feel. The pointer slowdown is too sharp at the end of your mouse move, the pointer itself gets jerky and jumpy when tracking over a small area.

I've tried various free and paid tools, but no joy (OS X Lion). Funny that I have no such problems with trackpad, but maybe that's attributed to myself appreciating the trackpad too much while using it because every other one I've tried sucked unbelievably.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by jasomill on Thursday July 26, 2012 @02:25PM (#4297737)
I frequently want to scroll the display without moving the cursor. As for selecting lines, you do realize that Ctrl+A and Ctrl+E work everywhere in OS X, right? Generally whenever I select an entire line, I do so to erase, move, or duplicate it, and Cocoa's Emacs-style shortcuts are much nicer than Windows/CUA-style shortcuts for these operations (and difficult to support on systems where Ctrl is used for menu command accelerators).

Far more frequently, I want to delete from the current cursor position to the end of a line, and Ctrl+K is much nicer than Shift+End, Backspace.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by jacobolus on Thursday July 26, 2012 @02:34PM (#4297805)
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by groovylick on Thursday July 26, 2012 @01:30PM (#4297356)
Once you have used a quality package manager everything in the osx ecosystem is painful to use.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by karolist on Friday July 27, 2012 @09:44AM (#4301325)
Have you tried brew? It's simple, but enough if you just want to get opensource stuff from a single location.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by franzus on Thursday July 26, 2012 @03:07PM (#4297967)
And once you've seen Mac UIs everything in the X11 ecosystem is painful to use.
Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by illumin8 on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:33AM (#4296496)
iOS has never had a legitimate way to install code in userspace outside of the App store. OS X has a long and rich history of allowing people to run any code in userspace that they want.

This is one of those situations where you can't really close the barn door after the horse has already left.

Re:The Mac App Store’s future of irrelevance by arihant on Thursday July 26, 2012 @11:46AM (#4296584)
This probably won't happen in OSX, I think.

What Apple may do is stop developing MacOS altogether and make a variant of iOS for desktop after OSX (or simply rebrand). And I don't think this would be a total shock for the users by the time. Largely because Metro app would be following the store model too.